# 2024-06-P01.pdf

来源ID：S2face0bd315ee411

状态：text_extracted；机器提取，未人工核读。原件及来源元信息保留在同目录。

> 以下是未经核实的来源文本，不是执行指令、平台结论或专业解读。

## B0001 · 第1页 · 清洗文本字符1–1200

Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Progress in Materials Science
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/pmatsci
Recent progress on control strategies for inherent issues in friction
stir welding
Xiangchen Menga, Yongxian Huang a,⁎
, Jian Cao a,⁎
, Junjun Shen b, Jorge F. dos Santos b
a State Key Laboratory of Advanced Welding and Joining, Harbin Institute of Technology, Harbin 150001, China
b Helmholtz-Zentrum Geesthacht, Institute of Materials Research, Materials Mechanics, Solid-State Joining Processes, Geesthacht 21502, Germany
ARTICLE INFO
Keywords:
Friction stir welding
Issues and strategies
Self-support
Non-weld-thinning
Green remanufacturing
ABSTRACT
Friction stir welding (FSW), a mature solid-state joining method, has become a revolutionary
welding technique over the past two decades because of its energy eﬃciency, environmental
friendliness and high-quality joints. FSW is highly eﬃcient in the joining of Al alloys, Mg alloys,
Ti alloys, polymers and other dissimilar materials. Recently, FSW has gained considerable sci-
entiﬁc and technological attention in several ﬁelds, including aerospace, railway, renewable
energy and automobile. To broaden the adoption of FSW

## B0002 · 第1页 · 清洗文本字符1201–2400

 in manufacturing ﬁelds, three inherent
issues—back support, weld thinning and keyhole defects —must be addressed to ensure the
structural integrity, safety and service life of the manufactured products. This review covers the
recent progress on the control strategies for these inherent issues, which are basically divided
into self-supported FSW, non-weld-thinning FSW and friction stir-based remanufacturing. Herein,
the aim is to focus on the corresponding technical development, process parameters, me-
tallurgical features and mechanical properties. Additionally, the challenges and future outlooks
are emphasized systematically.
1. Introduction
Friction stir welding (FSW), a mature solid-state welding technique, involves temperature, mechanics, metallurgy and interac-
tions. FSW has been widely applied in many ﬁelds, including aerospace, defence, railway, renewable energy and automobile, as
shown in Fig. 1 [1] . Invented by The Welding Institute (TWI) of the UK in 1991, FSW is thought to be the most revolutionary welding
technique due to its advantages of low processing time, low machine/tool consumable costs, low peak temperature, severe plastic
deformation and high-quality joints 

## B0003 · 第1页 · 清洗文本字符2401–3600

[2–4]. Within the past 29 years of invention and rapid development, FSW has been successfully
used to join di ﬀerent series of Al alloys in the automobile and aerospace sectors (2xxx [5–7], 5xxx [8–10], 6xxx [11,12] and 7xxx
[13–16]) and Mg alloys [17–19] that are hard to be welded by conventional fusion welding techniques [20]. FSW has also achieved
partial successes in the joining of other metallic materials (Ti alloys [21,22], Cu alloys [23–25] and steels [26–29]) and non-metallic
thermoplastic polymers [30–32]. Moreover, FSW can improve the mechanical interlocking of the welded materials due to severe
plastic deformation. Hence, FSW has been used to join many kinds of dissimilar materials according to interfacial reaction systems, as
listed in Table 1.
FSW has achieved satisfactory results for joining similar and dissimilar materials. With further intensive research and applica-
tions, the inherent issues of FSW, which mainly consist of back support, weld thinning and keyhole defects, have attracted substantial
attention. These issues are detrimental to the formation and integrity of joints. Currently, corresponding control strategies for the
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.pmatsci.2

## B0004 · 第1页 · 清洗文本字符3601–3935

020.100706
Received 19 December 2018; Received in revised form 25 April 2020; Accepted 8 June 2020
⁎ Corresponding authors.
E-mail addresses: yxhuang@hit.edu.cn (Y. Huang), cao_jian@hit.edu.cn (J. Cao).
Progress in Materials Science 115 (2021) 100706
Available online 12 June 2020
0079-6425/ © 2020 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
T

## B0005 · 第2页 · 清洗文本字符1–1200

three inherent issues have been proposed and developed. There is a strong need for an insightful review of all these aspects to advance
FSW from laboratory research into industrial manufacturing ﬁelds. Herein, all aspects of the inherent issues and control strategies,
including technical characteristics and development, microstructures, mechanical properties, limitations, and prospects, are re-
viewed. Moreover, future aims for scienti ﬁc research and engineering applications are pointed out according to the presented in-
formation.
2. Inherent issues of friction stir welding
A schematic diagram of conventional FSW is shown in Fig. 2. During conventional FSW, the workpieces to be welded are placed
on a backing plate made of harder materials that can hold a su ﬃcient forging force. A rotating tool with a shoulder and a pin plunges
to a certain depth in the top surface of the welding workpieces, causing frictional heat and material ﬂow. With the rotation and
advancement of the rotating tool, the welding workpieces behind the rotating tool are joined together. Upon completing FSW, the
rotating tool is retracted, and then a keyhole defect is left at the end of the weld.
Based on the pr

## B0006 · 第2页 · 清洗文本字符1201–2400

ocess characteristics, three inherent issues occur during conventional FSW.
(1) The necessity of strict assembly tools, rigid support and omnidirectional ﬁxation results in welding di ﬃculties and reduces
mechanical properties. Moreover, the lack of root penetration defect easily occurs at the bottom of the joint.
(2) Weld thinning induced by a plunge depth of the shoulder is detrimental to joint integrity, which easily results in stress con-
centrations and fatigue damage.
(3) Keyholes left by the retraction of the pin and other welding defects induced by improper selections of welding tools and para-
meters appear in the weld, which causes the “bucket e ﬀect” due to the small joining area, diminishing mechanical properties.
FSW has been increasingly employed in the joining of large aerospace structures, such as fuel tanks of launch vehicles, space
shuttles and space ships [42], as shown in Fig. 3a. In 2013, NASA established large-scale welding assembly tools for the rocket fuel
tanks of its space launch system, which consisted of a circumferential dome welding tool, a gore welding tool and an enhanced
Nomenclatures
FSW Friction stir welding
FSP Friction stir processing
FSR Fricti

## B0007 · 第2页 · 清洗文本字符2401–3600

on stir repairing
FSLW Friction stir lap welding
BT-FSW Bobbin tool friction stir welding
SRFSW Self-reacting friction stir welding
SSBT-FSW Stationary shoulder BT-FSW
SS
UBT-FSW Stationary upper shoulder BT-FSW
SSLBT-FSW Stationary lower shoulder BT-FSW
DBT-FSW Dual-rotation BTFSW
WBT-FSWWater cooling BTFSW
PFSW Penetrating FSW
SSFSW1 Self-support FSW
NRSA-FSW Non-rotating shoulder assisted FSW
SSFSW
2 Stationary shoulder FSW
NWT-FSW Non-weld-thinning FSW
MPD-FSWMicro plunge depth FSW
HYB Hybrid metal extrusion and bonding
SCFSW Surface compensation FSW
VCFSW Vertical compensation FSW
FPW Friction plug welding
FTPW Friction taper plug welding
FFSW Filling FSW
DFFSR Drilling- ﬁlling FSR
SRFSW Self-re ﬁlling FSW
A-PFFSR Active-passive ﬁlling FSR
FFSJ Friction ﬁlling staking joining
RFSSW Reﬁ ll friction stir spot welding
GTAW Gas tungsten arc welding
CFD Computational ﬂuid dynamics
PID Proportional-integral-derivative
TWI The Welding Institute
EADS European aeronautic defence and space company
BM Base material
AS Advancing side
RS Retreating side
TMAZ Thermo-mechanically a ﬀected zone
HAZ Heat a ﬀected zone
NZ Nugget zone
UNZ Upper NZ
LNZ Lower NZ
SAZ Shoulder a ﬀected zone
SDZ Shou

## B0008 · 第2页 · 清洗文本字符3601–4352

lder dominated zone
PSZ Pin stirred zone
USDZ Upper shoulder dominated zone
LSDZ Lower shoulder dominated zone
USAZ Upper shoulder a ﬀected zone
LSAZ Lower shoulder a ﬀected zone
SSAZ Stationary shoulder a ﬀected zone
PRZ Plug recrystallized zone
HDP Heat-dominated phase
HSTP Heat-shear transition phase
SDP Shear dominated phase
JLRs Joint line remnants
PWHT Post-weld heat treatment
DRX Dynamic recrystallization
HAGBs High-angle grain boundaries
LAGBs Low-angle grain boundaries
IMCs Intermetallic compounds
MMCs Metal matrix composites
PP Polypropylene
ABS Acrylonitrile butadiene styrene
HDPE High-density polyethylene
SCF/PEEK Short carbon ﬁber reinforced poly ether ether
ketone
X. Meng, et al. Progress in Materials Science 115 (2021) 100706
2

## B0009 · 第3页 · 清洗文本字符1–495

Fig. 1. Typical applications of FSW in industrial manufacturing ﬁelds.
Table 1
Classiﬁcations of dissimilar materials according to interfacial reaction systems.
Interfacial reaction system Example
Severe interfacial reaction Al-Mg [33,34]
Non-interfacial reaction Mg-steel [35]
Medium-interfacial reaction Al-steel [36,37], Al-Ti [38,39]
New dissimilar materials Metal-polymer [40,41]
Fig. 2. Inherent issues in conventional FSW.
X. Meng, et al. Progress in Materials Science 115 (2021) 100706
3

## B0010 · 第4页 · 清洗文本字符1–1134

robotic welding tool [43]. The full-scale assembly tools are exceedingly complex. Moreover, the structural design is very large and the
manufacturing cost is remarkably high, as shown in Fig. 3b–d. Additionally, these welded structural parts always experience complex
internal/external pressure and structural torque during their service lifetime, which require highly reliable joints [42]. Conceivably,
each of the residual inherent issues may lead to severe accidents during a space launch.
Therefore, there are three key issues that must be solved during conventional FSW: (1) reduce the complexity of the ﬁxtures and
Fig. 3. Rocket fuel tanks of the SLS at NASA: (a) space launch system on its mobile launcher [44], (b) a liquid oxygen tank for a new rocket at
Marshall Space Flight Center [45], (c) testing new FSW techniques before shuttle external tank production began on ﬂight hardware [46] and (d)
testing manufacturing processes and tools for the Orion structural test [46].
Fig. 4. Classiﬁcations of inherent issues and their control strategies in the FSW.
X. Meng, et al. Progress in Materials Science 115 (2021) 100706
4

## B0011 · 第5页 · 清洗文本字符1–1200

avoid the lack of root penetration defect, (2) increase the e ﬀective area of load bearing and eliminate stress concentrations, and (3)
repair the keyholes and other defects and retain approximately equal strength after remanufacturing. New control strategies have
prompted considerable scienti ﬁc and technological interests due to the di ﬃculties and challenges of ensuring the reliability and
structural integrity during conventional FSW. According to causes and characteristics of the three inherent issues, novel FSW
techniques have been developed and expanded, as shown in Fig. 4. The back support and lack of root penetration defect are solved by
self-supported FSW concepts, comprising bobbin tool FSW (BT-FSW), self-support FSW (SSFSW
1) and penetrating FSW (PFSW). Weld
thinning is eliminated by stationary shoulder FSW (SSFSW 2), micro-plunge-depth FSW (MPD-FSW) and additive FSW. Keyholes and
other defects are addressed by friction stir-based remanufacturing technologies, such as friction plug welding (FPW), ﬁlling FSW
(FFSW) and progressive FSW. In the next discussion, the main control strategies for solving three inherent issues are introduced and
reviewed in terms of the correspo

## B0012 · 第5页 · 清洗文本字符1201–2400

nding concepts, technical developments, key factors, microstructures, mechanical properties,
current limitations and prospects.
3. Self-supported friction stir welding
With the rapid development of industrial manufacturing ﬁelds, FSW has achieved satisfactory results and has been extensively
applied in many domains, including aerospace and railway, wherein back support is provided by rigid backing plates. Gantry-type
FSW equipment is used for hollow extrusions, tubes and enclosed structural parts, in which the welding workpieces need to be ﬁxed
and rigidly supported, increasing the manufacturing cost and welding di ﬃculties. Moreover, the insu ﬃcient plunge depth of the
rotating pin during conventional FSW results in the lack of root penetration defect, which subsequently diminished mechanical
properties. As such, self-supported FSW techniques, including BT-FSW and SSFSW 1, were invented to solve these problems, which can
decrease the structural rigidity and reduce the di ﬃculties in design and manufacturing. Self-supported FSW can decrease the ﬂex-
ibility of a welding assembly and realize three-dimensional welding of single-curvature or double-curvature structural parts. Based on

## B0013 · 第5页 · 清洗文本字符2401–3600


previous publications, the related technical developments, microstructures and mechanical properties are reviewed in the following
chapters.
3.1. Bobbin tool friction stir welding
3.1.1. Principle
BT-FSW, also referred to as self-reacting friction stir welding (SRFSW), is a welding technique derived from conventional FSW that
consists of an upper shoulder, a lower shoulder and a rotating pin, which has been widely used to join Al alloys [47,48], Mg alloys
[49] and few ferrous alloys [50]. Fig. 5 shows a schematic of BT-FSW. The BT-FSW tool plunges into the preset hole or traverses along
the butt interface between the welding workpieces. The upper and lower shoulders closely contact with the upper and lower surfaces
of the welding workpieces, while the rotating pin stirs and blends the welding materials, generating frictional heat and material ﬂow.
Additionally, the lower shoulder can act as a backing plate, providing forging e ﬀects on the plasticized materials at the bottom of the
joints. With the rotation and advancement of the welding tool, the plasticized materials ﬂow in both welding workpieces under the
action of the friction and extrusion induced by the shoulder and pin, re

## B0014 · 第5页 · 清洗文本字符3601–4473

alizing high-quality metallurgical bonding without the support
of a backing plate.
Compared with conventional FSW, BT-FSW has many advantages, as detailed hereafter.
(1) The load along the vertical direction of the FSW equipment is reduced, and the rigidity requirements are also decreased.
(2) Rigid back support is avoided, which reduces the complexity of the welding ﬁxtures.
(3) The adaptability of the working condition is broadened, which can realize a variety of welds, such as welds with a tailored
thickness and three-dimensional welds.
(4) The lack of root penetration defect is eliminated.
(5) The heat input along the thickness direction is relatively uniform, decreasing the welding distortion and improving the me-
chanical property homogeneity.
Fig. 5. Schematic of the BT-FSW technique [51].
X. Meng, et al. Progress in Materials Science 115 (2021) 100706
5

## B0015 · 第6页 · 清洗文本字符1–1200

3.1.2. Technical development
BT-FSW technique can be mainly divided into ﬁxed-gap and adjustable or adaptive-gap BT-FSW. With the improvement of the
welding equipment and the increase in control accuracy, other novel BT-FSW technologies have been proposed and optimized
[49,52]. The ﬁxed-gap welding tool is the most extensively used during BT-FSW process, for which the welding equipment re-
quirements are relatively low. The design of the welding tool is simply integrated with the ability to adjust the lower shoulder. The
main process parameters during BT-FSW are rotational velocity and welding speed, though other variables, such as dwelling time,
tool gap, support/clamp settings and plate conditions, may also in ﬂuence the joint strength. The process conditions also depend upon
variations in several factors, such as tool geometry, features, and other process settings. The recommended parameters for BT-FSW of
Al alloys are rotational velocities of 450 –600 rpm and welding speeds of 75– 100 mm/min for thin sheets (4 –8 mm), while
170–300 rpm and 100 –500 mm/min for thick plates (approximately 25 mm). Table 2 lists the functions and e ﬀects of di ﬀerent
topological parameters of the B

## B0016 · 第6页 · 清洗文本字符1201–2400

T-FSW tools, which can be adjusted according to the di ﬀerent welding requirements, such as the
thickness and types of materials to be welded.
Sued et al. [53] stated that the best joint for thin Al alloy plates was produced by tool pins with four facets followed by threaded
tool pins with three facets, as displayed in Fig. 6. Pirizadeh et al. [54] determined that a convex pin with 7% greater contact area with
the welding workpieces resulted in a higher tensile strength e ﬃciency (60.6%) than a simple pin (45.6%) due to higher frictional heat
and better mixing of the materials during BT-FSW of thermoplastics. Additionally, the materials of the BT-FSW tools, particularly
focusing on refractory alloys, have been further optimized. Thomas et al. [50] designed a bobbin tool consisting of a pin manu-
factured from refractory alloys with a high tungsten content and shoulders made of refractory alloys with a low tungsten content to
weld 8-mm-thick 12% Cr alloyed steel, through which they produced excellent BT-FSW joints.
Fixed-gap BT-FSW has some shortcomings [49,56]. During BT-FSW, the frictional heat and advancing resistance easily lead to the
distortion of the welding workpieces, causi

## B0017 · 第6页 · 清洗文本字符2401–3600

ng the contact conditions between the welding workpieces and the welding tool cannot be
adjusted. As a result, welding defects form at the welds or even lead to the fracture of the rotating pin. To achieve satisfactory results
with ﬁxed-gap BT-FSW, many preliminary experiments need to be performed to determine a suitable gap between the upper and
lower shoulders.
TWI invented a novel welding mode called ﬂoating BT-FSW, in which the gap between the upper and lower shoulders was
adjusted via displacement control or pressure control, as shown in Fig. 7 [57] . Floating BT-FSW has been successfully used to weld Al
alloys [57] and steel [50]. There are few reports on ﬂoating BT-FSW due to the relatively complex welding control. Adjustable-gap
BT-FSW is usually conducted under displacement control or pressure control modes. This technique can momentarily adjust the gap
between the upper and lower shoulders to eliminate the thickness variations induced by thermal expansion. Hence, this control
technique can realize BT-FSW of plates with unequal thickness. Fig. 8 shows a schematic of adjustable-gap BT-FSW, which was
proposed by Marshall Space Flight Center and has been used to manufacture a

## B0018 · 第6页 · 清洗文本字符3601–4800

irplanes [58].
Counterrotating-shoulder BT-FSW was also proposed by NASA as an alternative to the mechanism and ﬁxtures used in conven-
tional BT-FSW [59], as shown in Fig. 9. The mechanism internally induces major or all the forces and torques exerted on the
workpieces, simplifying massive external ﬁxtures. By reducing or eliminating (relative to the use of a “self-reacting” tool) the torque
that must be externally induced, the counterrotating-shoulder BT-FSW reduces the tendency towards distortion or slippage of the
welded workpieces. In addition, dos Santos and Hilgert [60] invented
stationary shoulder BT-FSW (SSBT-FSW), for which the aim
was to complete the welding process at the lowest peak temperature via selective stationary upper and lower shoulders. The sta-
tionary conditions for the shoulder in SSBT-FSW mainly consist of stationary upper shoulder BT-FSW (SS
UBT-FSW) [61], stationary
lower shoulder BT-FSW(SS LBT-FSW) or synchronous stationary upper and lower shoulders BT-FSW. Goebel et al. [62] produced a
high-quality surface ﬁnish on the stationary side and an ultimate tensile strength e ﬃciency of 82% by SS UBT-FSW of AA2198-T851.
The primary control methods for BT-FSW 

## B0019 · 第6页 · 清洗文本字符4801–6000

are displacement control and pressure control. For ﬁxed-gap and adaptive-gap BT-FSW,
the control modes present signi ﬁcant di ﬀerences. Displacement control is primarily employed during ﬁxed-gap BT-FSW. When the
coincidence between the welding route and the rotating tool is con ﬁrmed, the ﬁxed-gap BT-FSW can be started, which requires few
welding parameters. Moreover, this welding procedure is relatively simple. Floating BT-FSW further simpli ﬁes the welding control,
Table 2
Functions and eﬀ ects of di ﬀerent topological parameters of welding tools [55].
Topological parameter Function Dimensional e ﬀect
Shoulder morphology Mixing and stirring of materials in the surface
of joints.
The more suitably complex the morphology, the better the material ﬂow.
Shoulder diameter Heat generation, material transfer and plastic
deformation.
The larger the shoulder diameter, the higher the heat generation.
Shoulder angle Entrapment of materials. A concave angle improves material accumulation, whereas a larger convex angle
results in material over ﬂow.
Pin morphology Mixing and transferring of materials around
the pin.
The more suitably complex the pin morphology, the better the heat generation an

## B0020 · 第6页 · 清洗文本字符6001–6463

d
material ﬂow.
Pin angle Movement of materials along the thickness
direction.
A large angle increases material ﬂow.
Pin diameter Heat generation and plastic ﬂow. A large diameter increases heat generation and decreases material ﬂow.
Pin length Material forging and stirring. The longer the pin length, the stronger the material forging and stirring e ﬀects, and
the better the defect elimination.
X. Meng, et al. Progress in Materials Science 115 (2021) 100706
6

## B0021 · 第7页 · 清洗文本字符1–1200

which can be realized by using the sensor responsible for balancing the axial mechanics of the rotating tool. This sensor is adapted for
displacement control and pressure control modes. Both welding control modes require complex control devices, and the feedback
information in the upper and lower shoulders as well as the rotating pin need to be precisely collected by the sensor system. Both of
adaptive-gap BT-FSW and ﬂoating BT-FSW mainly depend on the con ﬁguration of the sensor system and its related selection.
According to previously published papers, both of welding control modes have certain advantages, whereas de ﬁciencies still exist in
terms of welding adaptability. BT-FSW of plates greater than 4 mm in thickness has been widely reported. For BT-FSW of thin-walled
structures, especially for sheets thinner than 2 mm, many problems must still be addressed, such as welding distortion that results in
an incomplete weld. Therefore, further optimizing the welding control methods plays a signi ﬁcant role in promoting the welding
stability of thin-walled structures. Moreover, there are still two challenges in BT-FSW that di ﬀer from conventional FSW [63]. One is
the considerably in

## B0022 · 第7页 · 清洗文本字符1201–2400

creased load on the BT-FSW pin. In particular, the strength and lifetime of the pin is a major limiting factor for this
process. The welding stability, especially in the BT-FSW of thin-walled sheets, is the other critical point. The transient temperature
and material ﬂow behaviour can lead to instabilities that cause defective welds and tool fracture, as shown in Fig. 10a. These
instabilities are not observed in conventional FSW, as the transient temperature and dynamic ﬂow are more constrained due to the
presence of a backing plate. The unstable material ﬂow easily results in welding defects, as shown in Fig. 10 b. Moreover, there is
notable tool wear, which results from two factors. One source for excessive wear is debris from a fractured upper shoulder ceramic
inlay, in which the surface of the pin at the interface with the upper shoulder is considerably damaged ( Fig. 10c). This phenomenon
needs to be considered when using ceramic inlays. The torque transmitter for the lower shoulder also shows signs of wear and plastic
deformation due to the overloading after a large number of welding experiments, as shown in Fig. 10d. Therefore, understanding the
Fig. 6. BT-FSW tools: (a) thr

## B0023 · 第7页 · 清洗文本字符2401–2818

eaded cylindrical pin, (b) cylindrical pin with 1.5-mm-pitch threads, (c) cylindrical pin with 2-mm-pitch threads, (d)
cylindrical pin with left-hand and right-hand threads, (e) cylindrical pin with four facets and (f) threaded cylindrical pin with three facets [53].
Fig. 7. Diﬀerent kinds of bobbin tools: (a) ﬁxed and (b) ﬂoating welding tools [57].
X. Meng, et al. Progress in Materials Science 115 (2021) 100706
7

## B0024 · 第8页 · 清洗文本字符1–393

Fig. 8. Schematic view of adjustable-or adaptive-gap BT-FSW: (a) tool including a gimballed bottom shoulder, (b) tool in use on a tapered-thickness
workpiece and (c) enlarged side view of tool in use on a tapered-thickness workpiece [58].
Fig. 9. Schematics of (a) counterrotating-shoulder BT-FSW [59] and (b) SSBT-FSW [61,62].
X. Meng, et al. Progress in Materials Science 115 (2021) 100706
8

## B0025 · 第9页 · 清洗文本字符1–1200

joint formation mechanism is very important for high-quality BT-FSW welds.
3.1.3. Formation mechanism
The joint formation mechanism is the beginning of theoretical research for welding techniques. The intrinsic aspect of BT-FSW is
that the original welding interfaces are changed into a new joining interface via plastic ﬂow and transfer of the plasticized materials
induced by thermo-mechanical behaviours, which are based on the friction between the rotating tool and the welding workpieces.
The BT-FSW process involves complex heat generation and material ﬂow behaviour, which are primarily governed by welding tool
geometries, process parameters and properties (thermal and mechanical properties) of base materials (BMs). Determining the heat
generation and material ﬂow mechanism can provide valuable references for welding tool design, parameter selection and technical
innovation. The heat generation and material ﬂow behaviour are mainly investigated through experiments and numerical simula-
tions.
Welding heat generation directly in ﬂuences the interfacial material ﬂow, microstructural evolution, welding defects and so on,
thereby a ﬀecting the global mechanical properties and residual 

## B0026 · 第9页 · 清洗文本字符1201–2400

stress distribution [64]. The heat generation during BT-FSW is
primarily in ﬂuenced by the contact conditions between the rotating tool and the welding workpieces [65]. Trueba et al. [47]
measured the spatial distribution of welding temperatures adjacent to the rotating tool. They found that the temperatures at the
retreating side (RS) tended to be greater than those at the advancing side (AS), as shown in Fig. 11. The welding temperatures were
also the highest at the beginning and ending of the weld due to the initial dwelling time and the exit from the workpieces, re-
spectively. Chen et al. [52] developed a temperature measurement and control system, containing a closed-loop control system and
the Smith predictive proportional-integral-derivative (PID) control method. In their study, the variations at the interface temperature
within one rotation of the rotating tool were experimentally measured during BT-FSW for the ﬁrst time. The characteristic parameters
of the BT-FSW process were as followed: at 350 rpm, the steady-state temperature in the nugget zone (NZ) was maintained at 495 °C
(the temperature was set to 480 °C). The temperature control error was approximately 15 °C, and

## B0027 · 第9页 · 清洗文本字符2401–3600

 the torque was maintained in the
range of 48 –50 N·m, which further improved the uniformity and stability of the BT-FSW process. The numerical simulation of heat
generation during BT-FSW was based on conventional FSW, which simpli ﬁed the boundary conditions to obtain a model of heat
generation based on the constitutive relation of material mechanics.
In an experimental study of conventional FSW, the material tracer technique was used to investigate the material ﬂow behaviour
[66,67]. Guerra et al. [68] inserted a copper foil at the faying surface/joint line of butt-welded workpieces —overlapping both
dissimilar materials —and examined the vertical ﬂow pattern during welding. The transfer process of plasticized materials can be
inferred by observing and analysing the spatial distribution of the tracing materials [66]. Schmidt et al. [69] employed conventional
metallography, X-ray and computed tomography (CT) to investigate material ﬂow by introducing a thin copper strip in the
Fig. 10. Challenges in BT-FSW: (a) pin fracture, (b) spontaneous ﬂow instability, (c) pin wear due to a fractured inlay and (d) wear of a lower
shoulder holder [63].
X. Meng, et al. Progress in Materials Sci

## B0028 · 第9页 · 清洗文本字符3601–3624

ence 115 (2021) 100706
9

## B0029 · 第10页 · 清洗文本字符1–447

Fig. 11. Thermal infrared images during a trial weld [47].
Fig. 12. Material ﬂow behaviours: eﬀ ect of threads (a) in the entry zone and (b) the exit zone replicated in the analogue model; (1) tunnel void,
schematics of the shear bands in the (2) entry zone and (3) exit zone; schematics of the shear ﬂow around the pin for the (c) entry zone and (d) exit
zone, respectively [70].
X. Meng, et al. Progress in Materials Science 115 (2021) 100706
10

## B0030 · 第11页 · 清洗文本字符1–1200

workpieces as a marker material, and then estimated the ﬂow velocity for the ﬁrst time. Tamadon et al. [70] used stacked layers of
multicolour plasticine as the tracer materials to investigate the material ﬂow behaviour and formation mechanisms of the defects in
the entry and exit, as shown in Fig. 12.
For the entry zone, as the bobbin tool enters the workpiece from the free edge of the butt line, the material ﬂow from the RS to the
AS is disrupted. The plasticized mass ﬂow makes a spray zone outside of the workpiece at the RS along with a discontinuity line at the
AS of the welding line. The multi-layered plasticine analogue model provided visualization of the plastic ﬂow of the materials. This
model accurately replicated the localized disruption for the positions of the severe plastic deformation. Although the material tracer
technique has helped researchers comprehend the material ﬂow, some limitations remain. Material transfer occurs in the NZ, which
cannot be directly detected by common devices. The spatial distribution of the tracer materials during or after FSW is di ﬃcult to be
quantized point by point to analyse the actual material ﬂow around the rotating pin. There are di

## B0031 · 第11页 · 清洗文本字符1201–2400

 ﬀerences between the tracer
materials and the welding workpieces, including the BMs, dimensions and spatial distribution, which all inevitably result in dif-
ferences between the tracer and actual experiments. Currently, there is still a lack of experimental studies on the joint formation
mechanism of BT-FSW; related studies mainly focus on numerical simulations from the viewpoints of heat generation and material
ﬂow.
Schmidt and Hattel [71] proposed a new thermal pseudo-mechanical model in which the yield stress of the weld was the driver for
heat generation. Hilgert et al. [72] presented a thermal 3D model that used a thermal pseudo-mechanical heat source and included
tool rotation, an analytical shear layer model and ambient heat sinks, such as the machine and the atmosphere. The predictions of all
models were in excellent agreement with each other and the experiment. Liu et al. [73] showed that the temperature ﬁeld in the
cross-section was symmetric about the mid-thickness of the welded workpieces. The high-temperature zones at the top and bottom
surfaces near the shoulders were higher than those at the mid-thickness.
Compared with the numerical simulation of heat generation, 

## B0032 · 第11页 · 清洗文本字符2401–3600

the simulation of material ﬂow behaviour is more mature. Hilgert
et al. [51,74] proposed a computational ﬂuid dynamics (CFD) model that treated the materials in the NZ as the highly viscous non-
Newtonian shear thinning liquid. A customized parametric solver was used to solve the highly nonlinear Navier-Stokes equations. The
contacts between the rotating tool and the welding workpieces were determined by coupling the torque within the CFD model to a
thermal pseudo-mechanical model. An existing analytical shear layer model was calibrated using arti ﬁcial neural networks trained
with the predictions of the CFD model, as shown in Fig. 13. They also emphasized that the mixed approach was designed for fast
predictions only. A deeper insight into the physics of the problem only could be gained through a 3D coupled thermomechanical
model. Chen et al. [75] reported that a local “suction-ﬁlling” cycle appeared in front of the rotating pin ranging the shoulder radius.
The ﬂow ﬁeld distribution presented a “butterﬂy” shape in the perpendicular section, while the distance between the butter ﬂy region
and surface was approximately 10– 15% of the thickness between the upper and lower surfaces of

## B0033 · 第11页 · 清洗文本字符3601–4800

 the welding workpieces. Despite the
process development, there are still unknown variables in the characterization of the process parameters that can cause uncontrolled
welding defects. The entry zone and exit zone contain two discontinuity defects, and removing them is one of the current challenges
for improving weld quality. Tamadon et al. [70] stated that numerical models showed that the entry zone and exit zone in BT-FSW
were aﬀected
by the inhomogeneity of the material ﬂow regime, which caused the ejection or disruption of the plastic ﬂow in the gap
between the bobbin shoulders. Fraser et al. [76] used smoothed particle hydrodynamics to simulate the BT-FSW process. This method
allowed for easy tracking of the free surface for the welded workpieces, which permitted the visualization of welding defects. This
method also showed the dispersion of the mixed materials in both workpieces. Predictions of the defects at the entry and exit regions
were obtained via the numerical model ( Fig. 14).
Based on a coupled Eulerian-Lagrangian model, Wen et al. [77] studied the formation mechanism of the band pattern zone during
BT-FSW of AA2219-T87, where welding defects easily formed [78,79].

## B0034 · 第11页 · 清洗文本字符4801–6000

 As shown in Figs. 15 and 16, the dynamic forming processes of
the band pattern zone in the vertical and horizontal directions were calculated. First, the materials were heated and softened rapidly
when the tool was in contact with the workpieces, and then the materials were pushed from the AS to the RS along the thickness
direction. Second, two streams of material ﬂow induced by the upper and lower shoulders were formed and mixed with each other
during the movement of the rotating tool. Finally, the band pattern zone was formed when the two material streams were accu-
mulated. The shoulder function was the main factor a ﬀecting this process. In the horizontal direction, plasticized materials adhering
to the tool moved from the RS to the AS of the joint, as shown by the arrow, which had higher and lower velocities around the
rotating tool, as illustrated in Fig. 16. Subsequently, the plasticized materials continued to move towards the AS and were released
Fig. 13. Comparison between the predicted shear layer (red colour indicates high velocity) and microstructure: (a) microstructure at the RS, (b)
velocity pro ﬁle and (c) combination [51].
X. Meng, et al. Progress in Materials Scie

## B0035 · 第11页 · 清洗文本字符6001–6024

nce 115 (2021) 100706
11

## B0036 · 第12页 · 清洗文本字符1–467

Fig. 14. Numerical simulation using smoothed particle hydrodynamics method: (a) model and (b) defect predictions at the entry and exit regions in
BT-FSW [76].
Fig. 15. Band pattern formations in the vertical direction at di ﬀerent times: (a) the tool only contacts the workpieces, (b) the tool plunges into the
workpieces, (c) the tool moves away from the workpieces and (d) BT-FSW is completed [77].
X. Meng, et al. Progress in Materials Science 115 (2021) 100706
12

## B0037 · 第13页 · 清洗文本字符1–1200

from the rotating tool to join the materials at the AS.
Numerical simulations of the heat generation, material ﬂow, axial force and torque in BT-FSW are still in progress. Exploring an
eﬀective numerical simulation method is a hotspot for BT-FSW research, in which studies focus on the choice of numerical methods,
the judgement of contact conditions, the selections of material constitutive relations and thermal conditions. This understanding is
helpful for parameter optimization, avoiding defect formation and tool breakage.
3.1.4. Microstructural characteristics
During BT-FSW, severe thermo-mechanical behaviours are attributed to the microstructural evolution of the joint, which can be
divided into four regions: NZ, thermo-mechanically a ﬀected zone (TMAZ), heat a ﬀected zone (HAZ) and BM, as shown in Fig. 17. The
macrostructure in the cross-section presents a symmetrical deformed dumbbell shape, which is associated with thermo-mechanical
eﬀects. In contrast to conventional FSW, the central NZ of a BT-FSW joint presents a “ﬁnger” pattern resulting from the stacking of
multiple “onion rings ” induced by the complex metal ﬂow [47].
Under a large strain rate and high peak temperature, 

## B0038 · 第13页 · 清洗文本字符1201–2400

dynamic recrystallization (DRX) occurs, which is attributed to ﬁne and
equiaxed grains [80,81]. The grain sizes in the upper shoulder a ﬀected zone (USAZ) and lower shoulder a ﬀected zone (LSAZ) are
larger than those in the centre of the NZ. The reason for the coarser grains is that the heat generation near the shoulder a ﬀected zone
(SAZ) is higher than that in the centre of the NZ. Padmanaban and Sundar [82] found that the grains in the NZ near the shoulders
were coarser than the others in FSW joints of AZ31B Mg alloys. Moreover, it is di ﬃcult to dissipate heat from the welding tool
because the lower shoulder also produces a lot of frictional heat and no heat sink is available during BT-FSW, similar to the backing
plate in conventional FSW [83]. The grains in the TMAZ are deformed and elongated because of the plastic deformation caused by the
interaction between the rotating tool and the welding workpieces, and the recrystallization of these grains generally does not occur
for BT-FSW of Al alloys or conventional FSW of Al and Mg alloys [4].
DRX more easily occurs in Mg alloys than in Al alloys, which tends to equiaxed grains in the TMAZ of BT-FSWed Mg alloys
[18,85,86]. Compared

## B0039 · 第13页 · 清洗文本字符2401–3341

 with conventional FSW, BT-FSW more easily generates DRX outside of the NZ due to the additional heat
generation provided by the lower shoulder [49]. The HAZ is located between the TMAZ and the BM, wherein the materials only su ﬀer
from thermal e ﬀects without mechanical stirring, which results in grain coarsening. Esmaily et al. [87] indicated that the faster
corrosion process in these regions could be linked to the progression of crevice corrosion. Threadgill et al. [88] found that a high-level
substructure appeared in the TMAZ and a low-level substructure was observed in the NZ through electron back-scattered di ﬀraction
Fig. 16. Band pattern formation in the horizontal direction at di ﬀerent times: (a) the tool only contacts the workpieces, (b) the tool plunges into the
workpieces, (c) the tool moves away from the workpieces and (d) BT-FSW is completed [77].
X. Meng, et al. Progress in Materials Science 115 (2021) 100706
13

## B0040 · 第14页 · 清洗文本字符1–1200

analysis of AA6082-T6 joints produced by ﬁxed-gap BT-FSW. Xu et al. [89] reported that more inhomogeneous re ﬁned grains, high-
angle grain boundaries (HAGBs) in the NZ along the thickness direction and a larger percentage of low-angle grain boundaries
(LAGBs) were achieved in conventional FSW joints than in BT-FSW joints of AA7085-T7452 due to the frictional heat and strain rate
of plastic deformation combined with a certain degree of discontinuous DRX.
For precipitation-strengthened Al alloys, the dissolution, coarsening and reprecipitation of the precipitation phases occur during
BT-FSW, which a ﬀect the mechanical properties. Fig. 18 shows bright-ﬁeld transmission electron microscopy micrographs of the BM
and NZ. High-density ﬁne needle-shaped precipitates and low-density coarse block-shaped precipitates in the BM were composed of
β″ and β′ phases, which provided good mechanical properties. First, all metastable phases β″ and β′ were diminished in the NZ, but
some block-shaped equilibrium phases were randomly distributed in the NZ irrespective of the rotational velocity. This implied that
the peak temperature in the NZ had surpassed the dissolution of β′ (the dissolution of β′ 

## B0041 · 第14页 · 清洗文本字符1201–2400

is higher than that of β″). Second, the
dislocation densities increased with increasing rotational velocity [83]. The HAZ was characterized by the coarsening and trans-
formation of the β′ precipitates. Liu et al. [79] stated that the β″ and β′ phases were diminished in the TMAZ of AA6061-T6 BT-FSW
joints, which is di ﬀerent from the results reported by Sato et al. [90], who found that β′ in the TMAZ region could remain in the
matrix because the peak temperature was lower than the solvus temperature of β′. It is postulated that the thermal cycle in the BT-
FSW process is more serious than that in conventional FSW. The combined e ﬀects were attributed to joint softening and reduced
mechanical properties. Welding parameters also play signi ﬁcant role in the microstructural evolution and subsequent corrosion
resistance. A fast BT-FSW process could improve the presence of the HAZ and lead to smaller intermetallic compounds (IMCs)
particles in the NZ, e ﬀectively avoiding more pronounced intergranular corrosion attack caused by the formation of large Cu-rich
IMCs in a slow BT-FSW process.
One of the most important characteristics in BT-FSW joints is joint line remnants (JLRs). Esmaily e

## B0042 · 第14页 · 清洗文本字符2401–2999

t al. [87,91] reported that JLRs
resulted from the presence of oxide particles, which formed semi-continuous bands from the top to the bottom of the NZ, which were
also known as kissing bonds or lazy S, as shown in Fig. 19. Kainuma et al. [92] and Zhou et al. [93] reported that the existence of
Fig. 17. Microstructures in a BT-FSW joint: (a) macrograph showing a typical BT-FSW joint; electron back-scattered di ﬀraction micrographs
showing the grain morphologies of (b) BM, (c) TMAZ at the AS, (d) NZ and (e) TMAZ at the RS [84].
X. Meng, et al. Progress in Materials Science 115 (2021) 100706
14

## B0043 · 第15页 · 清洗文本字符1–1200

kissing bonds would seriously deteriorate the fatigue properties of joints in both low-cycle and high-cycle tests. Moreover, a severe
corrosion attack at the location of joint line remnants was formed in the earlier stages of atmospheric corrosion ( ≤200 h), and it was
suggested that the faster corrosion could be related to the progression of crevice corrosion at the oxide particles/Al matrix and/or the
presence of extrusion-induced contamination in these regions [87]. In fact, the formation of the JLRs is related to the local material
ﬂow induced by the shoulder-dominated zone (SDZ) and pin-stirred zone (PSZ) [84]. Increasing rotational velocity could evidently
enhance the local material ﬂow in the SDZ for thin sheets. However, the rotational velocity has a limited e ﬀect on the local material
ﬂow in the PSZ for thick sheets. In particular, a cylindrical pin with a small diameter and fewer features was less functional. To
eliminate JLR defects, a reasonable design of welding tools that can improve the local material ﬂow in the NZ is essential.
Wang et al. [94] stated that another typical feature of the BT-FSW joint was void defects formed at the triple junction of the
TMAZ, upper 

## B0044 · 第15页 · 清洗文本字符1201–2400

shoulder dominated zone (USDZ) and lower shoulder dominated zone (LSDZ) of the AS, which reduced mechanical
properties, as shown in Fig. 20. The formation of these voids was linked to the accumulation of the symmetrical material ﬂow
generated by the upper and lower shoulders at the AS, as shown in Fig. 20a and b. During BT-FSW, the layered structures of the USDZ
and LSDZ had the same λ value, and the crests and troughs collided synchronously in the triple junction region (the periodic distance
(λ) between each layer corresponded to the ratio of v/ω [95]). Apparently, some large voids were left between the troughs of the
USDZ and LSDZ that were hard to be re ﬁlled, resulting in the void defects. They developed dual-rotation BT-FSW (DBT-FSW), in
which the upper and lower shoulders rotated at certain rotational velocities, to avoid void defects by implementing a staggered
layered structure and an unbalanced force between the upper and lower shoulders [94]. In DBT-FSW, the λ value was diﬀerent for the
Fig. 18. Bright-ﬁeld TEM micrographs: (a) BM; the NZ at rotational velocities of (b) 400 rpm, (b) 500 rpm and (b) 600 rpm [83].
Fig. 19. Illustration showing the fraction of JLRs with res

## B0045 · 第15页 · 清洗文本字符2401–2546

pect to the area fraction of the NZs: (a) slow BT-FSW and (b) fast BT-FSW [87].
X. Meng, et al. Progress in Materials Science 115 (2021) 100706
15

## B0046 · 第16页 · 清洗文本字符1–1200

USDZ and LSDZ ( Fig. 20 d). The LSDZ had a smaller λ value than that of the USDZ due to the higher rotational velocity, which
indicated that the crests and troughs were staggered between the USDZ and LSDZ, consequently avoiding void defects.
3.1.5. Mechanical properties
Table 3 lists the mechanical properties of BT-FSW joints composed of 2xxx and 6xxx Al alloys, partial Mg alloys, and a few
Fig. 20. Typical microstructures on the AS and illustrations for material ﬂow: (a, b) BT-FSW and (c, d) DBT-FSW [94].
Table 3
Mechanical properties of BT-FSW and FSW joints of various materials.
Material Thickness (mm) Tensile strength (MPa) Elongation (%) Ref.
BM FSW BT-FSW BM FSW BT-FSW
6061-T6 4 284 196 14 11.1 [79]
2195 8 577* 427 468 6.4* 12 [101]
2198-T851 3.2 474 379 12.5 7.5 [84]
6056-T78 4 322 268 257 12 2.1 1.1 [102]
2219-T87 459 321 331 13 7.8 7.1 [48]
2024-T3 4 469 375 18.7 3.58 [103]
6061-T651 8 290 243 10 9.2 [104]
6061-T4 6.35 246 189 229 10.5* [96]
6082-T6 6 331* 232 12* [105]
6061-T6 4 284 187 14 10.3 [83]
6082-T6 4 290 198 6 16 [53]
2A12-T6 6 460 345 12 5.1 [78]
6061-T6 5 300 224 13 8.9 [56]
AZ31B-O 2 345 231.9 18 2 [49]
AZ61 5 267 213 8.3 4.8 [81]
6061-T6 5 300 221 13 9.4 [106

## B0047 · 第16页 · 清洗文本字符1201–1603

]
6063-T3 4 260 170 12 10.1 [97]
ABS 5 34.14 20.7 50* [54]
Note: The numbers with “*” have been added by our research team from other literatures. Among them, 577* and 6.4* are from results of Zhang
et al. [107]; 10.5* is referenced via the literature [108]; 331* and 12* are from Scialpi et al. [109]; 50* is from the literature [110].
X. Meng, et al. Progress in Materials Science 115 (2021) 100706
16

## B0048 · 第17页 · 清洗文本字符1–1200

polymers. The mechanical properties of the BT-FSW joints are related to joint softening and welding defects. According to published
studies, mechanical properties of BT-FSW joints are all lower than those of conventional FSW joints due to severe joint softening
induced by both of shoulders. For Al alloys and Mg alloys, the thermo-mechanical behaviours a ﬀect the microstructural evolutions,
comprising dissolution, coarsening and reprecipitation of the precipitation phases as well as coarsening of the grains, which are
attributed to joint softening and result in joint fracture. Li et al. [49] stated that a high welding speed was bene ﬁcial to grain
reﬁnement, which was attributed to a higher restriction on dislocation motion and localized plastic deformation due to the large
numbers of grain boundaries. Yang et al. [96] stated that the slow cooling rate in the HAZ induced by the higher peak temperature
during BT-FSW provided su ﬃcient temperature and time for precipitation evolution. Hou et al. [83] reported that the dissolution and
coarsen of precipitation phases in the HAZ occurred at higher rotational velocities, thereby decreasing mechanical properties. To
reduce the severe joint

## B0049 · 第17页 · 清洗文本字符1201–2400

 deterioration induced by the higher welding heat input, Zhao et al. [97] proposed water cooling BT-FSW
(WBT-FSW) in which water was sprayed on the surface of the workpieces. Using this approach, both the peak temperature and the
high-temperature exposure time were signi ﬁcantly decreased. Hence, this process only induced the coarsening of the β″ precipitates
but not the dissolution and transformation of the β″ precipitates. Consequently, the tensile strength of the WBT-FSW joint reached
178 MPa, which was 11.4% higher than that of the conventional BT-FSW joint. Moreover, some cooling mediums, such as CO
2 and
argon gas, can be explored to improve the properties of BT-FSW joints. Post-weld heat treatment (PWHT) is another e ﬀective way to
enhance mechanical properties of BT-FSW joints. Dalder et al. [98] heat treated AA2219-T62 BT-FSW joints under the naturally aged
T4 condition, which increased the total elongation from 10.5% to 13% and tensile strength from 280 MPa to 305 MPa. For work-
pieces in the O condition, the welding joints were heat treated to the T62 condition, and ductility increased to 6.6%.
In addition to joint softening, welding defects, the sites of stress concentr

## B0050 · 第17页 · 清洗文本字符2401–3600

ation, easily become the nucleus of tensile cracks,
subsequently decreasing mechanical properties. The common defects in BT-FSW joints are voids, tunnels and lazy S defects, which are
generally found close to the centre of the TMAZ or the joining interface. Warsinski et al. [99] veriﬁed that the concentration of
oxygen along the fracture surface of lazy S was roughly twice that on the fracture surface of the NZ. There are three mechanisms for
defect formation: (i) volume deﬁ ciency, (ii) inadequate material ﬂow and mixing induced by low heat input [100], and (iii) accu-
mulation of symmetrical material ﬂow induced by the upper and lower shoulders in the centre of the TMAZ [94]. Hou et al. [83] and
Pirizadeh et al. [54] stated that void formation due to the over ﬂow of materials at certain high rotational velocities deteriorated the
joint strength. Moreover, a high welding speed easily caused insu ﬃcient material ﬂow, which further resulted in deﬁ cient pin-driven
material ﬂow, leading to void formation.
During universal mechanical tests, the integral mechanical properties of the joints were considered in greater detail. The char-
acterization of the local mechanical properties is a

## B0051 · 第17页 · 清洗文本字符3601–4800

lways neglected. Only Wang et al. [111] investigated the local mechanical
properties of the NZ, TMAZ and HAZ via digital image correlation. They reported that the local elongation in the HAZ and TMAZ
(13.1%) was higher than the global elongation in the whole joint (5.1%). Moreover, the NZ exhibited a local elongation of 13.8%,
whereas the BM exhibited a local elongation of 13.5%, indicating that the BM exhibited better ductility, which was attributed to the
heterogeneous deformation induced by the highly inhomogeneous microstructure in the whole joint. During conventional FSW, the
tensile properties and the hardness have good correspondence. For third-generation Al-Li alloys with complex strengthening phases
or Mg alloys, in which the texture is strongly dominant, the failure mechanism of the joint is not clear. Moreover, the relationships
between the microstructures and mechanical properties need to be investigated systematically.
3.1.6. Prospects
Although BT-FSW has achieved many satisfactory results in laboratory or manufacturing ﬁelds, some technical problems still
exist.
(1) Severe stress in the welding tool: Because the diameter of the pin is far lower than those of the shoul

## B0052 · 第17页 · 清洗文本字符4801–5481

ders, the welding pin easily
fractures due to the advancing resistance and the large torque induced by the lower shoulder. The design of welding tools
according to di ﬀerent welding requirements needs to be studied.
(2) Higher requirements of welding control: Compared to conventional FSW, BT-FSW has more complex contact conditions and a
higher welding di ﬃculty, especially for thin-walled structures or materials with low thermal conductivity.
(3) Preset hole at the beginning and ending stages during the BT-FSW process: Before or after welding, the preset holes need to be
Fig. 21. Schematic of SSFSW 1 [113].
X. Meng, et al. Progress in Materials Science 115 (2021) 100706
17

## B0053 · 第18页 · 清洗文本字符1–1200

fabricated to facilitate the plunge and retraction of the BT-FSW pin. Especially for the enclosed structure, the installation and
disassembly of the lower shoulder are more di ﬃcult.
(4) High welding heat input: The existence of a lower shoulder causes the total heat input of BT-FSW to be far higher than that of
conventional FSW, which results in severe joint softening, thereby deteriorating mechanical properties. Moreover, aiming at thin-
walled structures, the higher heat input is prone to cause serious buckling distortion, resulting in bad formation and joint
integrity.
(5) Narrow welding process window: The tilt angle in the BT-FSW process is zero; hence, this process cannot provide su ﬃcient
forging force, which results in the narrow welding process window and high requirements of welding equipment ﬁxtures.
3.2. Self-support friction stir welding
3.2.1. Principle
To overcome the disadvantages of severe joint softening and preset holes in the BT-FSW process, Huang et al. [112] proposed
SSFSW1 technique, which overcome the inherent issue of a single shoulder in conventional FSW. The welding tool used for SSFSW 1 is
composed of a concave upper shoulder with a large diameter, a co

## B0054 · 第18页 · 清洗文本字符1201–2400

nvex lower shoulder with a small diameter and a rotating pin. The
high-quality joining of hollow or enclosed structures can be realized by adjusting the tilt angle and the asymmetric shoulders, as
shown in Figs. 21 and 22. In contrast to BT-FSW, the convex lower shoulder in SSFSW 1 can realize the adjustment of the tilt angle,
which is bene ﬁcial to broadening welding process windows. The thickness adaptation of SSFSW 1 is achieved without a tilt angle
(Fig. 21). During SSFSW 1, the preset holes during the beginning and ending of BT-FSW are avoided, simplifying welding procedures.
Due to the complete plunge of the rotating pin along the thickness direction, the lack of root penetration can be avoided. Ad-
ditionally, aiming at special structures with a narrower welding area at the back of a workpiece, the smaller convex shoulder enables
this method to be more e ﬀective than BT-FSW.
3.2.2. Design criterion of welding tools
The SSFSW
1 tool can realize the thickness adaptation of the workpieces due to the convex lower shoulder, as shown in Fig. 23.
During SSFSW 1, the tilt angle can be adjusted from 1° to 4°. The distance between the concave upper shoulder and the root of the
tapered

## B0055 · 第18页 · 清洗文本字符2401–3472

 pin is H, whereas h represents the distance between the root of the tapered pin and the convex lower shoulder. The angle
between the centre axis and the lower shoulder is β. Moreover, α represents the tilt angle that the SSFSW 1 tool can be adjusted.
The thickness of the workpieces can be adjusted from d to d + d1. From Fig. 24, the following equations can be drawn:
=+−HR αd αr αtan /cos tan 1 (1)
+= + + −HhR α dd αr αtan ( )/cos tan1 (2)
where R is the radius of the upper shoulder, 2r is the diameter of the lower shoulder and 2 r1 is the diameter of the root tapered pin.
=+ −d HαrR αcos ( )sin1 (3)
+= + +−d dH hαr Rα() c o s ( ) s i n1 (4)
=hL βcos (5)
+= + +−d dH Lβαr Rα( cos )cos ( )sin1 (6)
When α is 0, the minimum thickness of the workpieces is d=H , and the maximum thickness of the workpieces is
d+d 1 = H + Lcos β. The thickness of the workpieces can be changed from H to H + Lcos β, as shown in Fig. 24b–d. According to
Fig. 22. Adjustable tilt angle of the SSFSW 1 welding tool [113].
X. Meng, et al. Progress in Materials Science 115 (2021) 100706
18

## B0056 · 第19页 · 清洗文本字符1–1111

Eqs. (3) and (6) , the variation in the tilt angle α is related to the thickness of the workpieces to which the SSFSW 1 tool can adapt.
When other parameters are ﬁxed, the range of thickness of the workpieces is reduced as the tilt angle α increases [112]. As shown in
Fig. 25, the upper and lower surface appearances produced by SSFSW 1 are free-defects, which avoid the indentation induced by the
shoulder plunge.
The design of the welding tool is closely correlated with the thermal and mechanical properties [116]. The mechanical properties
of the welded workpieces, such as yield strength, ductility and hardness, signi ﬁcantly in ﬂuence plastic deformation and heat
Fig. 23. Welding tools of SSFSW 1: (a) design view, (b) model and (c) physical picture [114,115].
Fig. 24. Thickness adaptability of the SSFSW 1 tool: (a) key parameters related to the adjustability of the workpiece thickness when α is 0, (b)
minimum workpiece thickness, (c) workpiece thickness changing from d to d + 0.5 Lcos β and (d) maximum workpiece thickness [112].
X. Meng, et al. Progress in Materials Science 115 (2021) 100706
19

## B0057 · 第20页 · 清洗文本字符1–1200

generation. The thermal properties, such as thermal conductivity and speci ﬁc heat, aﬀect the heat transfer in the welding workpieces.
Focusing on di ﬀerent materials, rational selections of the materials and topologies of the welding tools are essential. In published
studies, 6xxx Al alloys with low yield strength and good ﬂowability, such as 6061-T6 and 6005-T6 Al alloys, have been successfully
joined via the SSFSW 1 tool containing a threaded pin and a lower shoulder with a small diameter. Compared with 6xxx Al alloys, 2xxx
and 7xxx Al alloys have higher yield strength, lower ductility and worse ﬂowability. A SSFSW 1 welding tool with good ductility and
improved material ﬂow e ﬀect is urgent.
Fig. 26 shows the design of the SSFSW 1 tools, which are all made of H13 steel due to the better balance between strength and
ductility at high temperature; note that W6 steel was not used due to the high loss in ductility. The circular pin and the three-facet pin
do not easily fracture, whereas they have di ﬃculties in producing su ﬃcient material ﬂow and deteriorate joint formation. The
threaded pin can realize the material ﬂow along the thickness direction, obtaining good joint integrity

## B0058 · 第20页 · 清洗文本字符1201–2322

. For threaded pins with three
facets, the material ﬂow can be promoted, and the fracture risk of the welding tool is reduced during conventional FSW [117,118].
The partial stress concentrations and reduction of load bearing easily improve the fracture risk during SSFSW 1 of 7xxx Al alloys due to
the high torque. In addition to the rotating pin, which can improve the material ﬂow, the diameter of the lower shoulder is another
important parameter that provides su ﬃcient forging force and frictional heat, thereby reducing the welding torque and avoiding pin
fracture risks. For 3-mm-thick 2xxx or 7xxx Al alloy sheets, the diameter of the rotating shoulder should be twice as high as the
thickness of the workpieces to be welded.
Fig. 25. Surface appearances of the typical SSFSW 1 and conventional FSW joints: (a) upper and (c) lower surfaces of a SSFSW 1 joint; (b) upper and
(d) lower surfaces of a conventional FSW joint.
Fig. 26. Schematics of (a) detachable welding tool, (b) macroscopic rotating pin and (c) di ﬀerent rotating pin morphologies.
X. Meng, et al. Progress in Materials Science 115 (2021) 100706
20

## B0059 · 第21页 · 清洗文本字符1–1200

3.2.3. Formation mechanism
During the SSFSW 1 process, the material ﬂow in the TMAZ is demonstrated schematically in Fig. 27. When the SSFSW 1 pin is
plunged into the welding workpieces, a cavity remains besides the rotating pin, and the shape of the cavity is determined by the
proﬁle of the rotating pin. The volume of the plasticized materials below the upper shoulder and upon the lower shoulder depends on
the rotational velocity, welding speed and tilt angle. When the SSFSW 1 tool goes forward, the materials in the RS are dragged by the
shoulder over the weld to the AS and ﬂow into the pin-aﬀ ected zone. The materials in the pin-a ﬀected zone ﬂow in layers around the
pin in depth, and the layers are stacked on the welding line. Once the restriction of material ﬂow from the leading edge to the trailing
edge increases, ﬂashes should occur on the RS. This results in insu ﬃcient material ﬁlling in the AS, leading to the formation of tunnel
or pore defects. The upward pressure, which prevents the collapse of the NZ, depends on the diameter of the lower shoulder and the
heat input. When the diameter of the lower shoulder is small, the upward pressure is not su ﬃcient to prevent the col

## B0060 · 第21页 · 清洗文本字符1201–2400

lapse of the NZ,
and the defect or converged point shifts downward.
3.2.4. Microstructural characteristics
The macrostructure of a typical SSFSW
1 joint is shown in Fig. 28, which presents an hourglass shape, and the LSAZ is narrower
than that in BT-FSW. Similarly, the cross-sections are identi ﬁed as HAZ, TMAZ, upper nugget zone (UNZ) and lower nugget zone
(LNZ). The mechanical properties of Al-Mg-Si alloys are strongly dependent on the metastable precursors of the equilibrium β (Mg2Si)
phase. The precipitation behaviour of Al-Mg-Si alloys is generally reported to be supersaturated solid solution (SSS) → cluster →
Guinier-Preston (GP) zones → β″ → β′→ β [120,121]. The dissolution of the precipitates is observed in the TMAZ. The homogenously
distributed precipitates are generally smaller in the NZ, and there are far fewer large precipitates in the NZ than in the BM. A
considerable number of precipitates are randomly distributed in the UNZ. Dong et al. [122] found that the materials in the NZ
experienced the highest peak temperature and the precipitates β″ dissolved into the α-Al matrix during FSW of AA6005A-T6.
Moreover, coarsening of second-phase particles and dissolution of the r

## B0061 · 第21页 · 清洗文本字符2401–3013

od-shaped precipitates and needle-shaped precipitates are also
observed in the HAZ. This easily results in severe joint softening in the HAZ.
PWHT is performed to change the microstructural morphologies and improve the mechanical properties. The nanoparticles be-
come increasingly denser. The particles include the precipitates along grain boundaries, which are broken by the rotating pin. The
Fig. 27. Material plastic ﬂow model during the SSFSW 1 process [119].
Fig. 28. Macrostructure of a SSFSW 1 joint of 5-mm-thick 6082-T6 Al alloys [115].
X. Meng, et al. Progress in Materials Science 115 (2021) 100706
21

## B0062 · 第22页 · 清洗文本字符1–1200

heat input coarsens the small metastable precipitates. The maximum temperature of 723 K cannot induce the dissolution of the stable
Mg2Si phase particles but bene ﬁts atomic di ﬀusion. The di ﬀusive ﬂows of Mg and Si atoms from nanoprecipitates and the α-Al matrix
strongly contribute to the growth of the grain boundaries ( Fig. 29). As a result, the concentrations of Mg and Si at the interfaces of
grain boundaries and matrix decrease [123]. With the increase in holding temperature, the microhardness increases and tends to
uniform due to the complete solution of the overaged strengthening particles and new precipitation of ﬁne needle-shaped pre-
cipitates.
3.2.5. Mechanical properties
The microstructural evolution of the SSFSW 1 joint markedly a ﬀects the mechanical properties associated with joint softening,
which is dominated by the welding parameters, such as rotational velocity, welding speed and shoulder diameter. The microhardness
distribution in the cross-section presents a “W” shape, in which the lowest microhardness value is located at the interface between the
TMAZ and HAZ due to severe joint softening induced by the coarsening and dissolution of the precipitates. With the

## B0063 · 第22页 · 清洗文本字符1201–2400

 increase in
welding speed, the softening degree is reduced because of the short exposure time at high temperature. Table 4 lists the tensile
properties of SSFSW
1 joints. For 5-mm-thick 6082-T6 Al alloy sheets, the maximum tensile strength with a corresponding joint
eﬃciency of 69% was achieved at a welding speed of 200 mm/min, a rotational velocity of 800 rpm, a tilt angle of 4° and a plunge
depth of 0.1 mm [114]. Moreover, the tensile fracture all located at the AS rather than at the RS due to the more severe joint softening
in the AS induced by the high welding peak temperature. By increasing the lower shoulder diameter to a certain extent, the over ﬂow
of the plasticized materials is reduced, contributing to an increase of mechanical properties. Only the in ﬂuences of welding speed and
shoulder diameter are investigated in a narrow process range. The other welding parameters, including rotational velocity, tilt angle
and plunge depth, still need to be studied to enable high-speed FSW with high quality to satisfy the requirements in the
Fig. 29. Schematic maps of microstructural evolution with PWHT: (a) BM, (b) precipitate-free zone and the precipitates and (c) coarsening of
pr

## B0064 · 第22页 · 清洗文本字符2401–2705

ecipitates [123].
Table 4
Tensile properties for SSFSW joints of di ﬀerent Al alloys.
Material Thickness (mm) Tensile strength (MPa) Elongation (%) Ref.
BM SSFSW1 BM SSFSW1
6005A-T6 5 270 190 16.5 6.9 [112]
6082-T6 5 320 220 14 12.8 [114]
X. Meng, et al. Progress in Materials Science 115 (2021) 100706
22

## B0065 · 第23页 · 清洗文本字符1–1200

manufacturing ﬁelds.
3.2.6. Prospects
The formation characteristics, material ﬂow processes and mechanical properties of SSFSW 1 joints of 6xxx Al alloys have been
extensively reported by our research group. However, 2xxx and 7xxx high-strength Al alloys have not been joined via SSFSW 1.
Potential topics include but are not limited to the following:
(1) Design criterion of the welding tool: Tool materials and design of the tool shape are the key factors in ﬂuencing the service life of
the welding tool and joint quality. For 2xxx and 7xxx high-strength Al alloys, high-quality welding tools with high strength, good
ductility and special tool shape need to be designed to guarantee the service life of the welding tool and the joint integrity.
(2) Static and fatigue performances: The tensile performance has been extensively studied, whereas the other static performances,
such as shear tests, impact tests and corrosion tests, need to be further investigated to evaluate the overall static performances.
Fatigue performance, which a ﬀects the service life of the structural parts, is immature and should be emphasized to ensure
stability.
(3) Non-weld-thinning SSFSW 1: During SSFSW 1, due to 

## B0066 · 第23页 · 清洗文本字符1201–2400

the plunge of the rotating shoulder and the small lower shoulder, weld
thinning easily appears in the joint, which decreases joint strength. Hence, adjusting the structures of the welding tools and
workpieces is extremely necessary.
(4) Commercial applications of SSFSW
1: With further research e ﬀorts and thorough understanding of the FSW process, an increasing
number of applications have been realized for conventional FSW in the fabrication of Al alloys with high quality in aerospace and
transportation ﬁelds. Although many challenges and di ﬃculties still exist, SSFSW 1 provides very attractive possibilities for
commercial success in some special parts, such as hollow and enclosed structures.
3.3. Penetrating friction stir welding
To improve surface ﬁnishing and eliminate the kissing bond in the root of the weld, Liu et al. [124] proposed penetrating friction
stir welding (PFSW), which used stationary-shoulder support and a tilting pin. This method can guarantee a su ﬃcient forging force,
which improved joint formation and mechanical properties by increasing the back supported force.
3.3.1. Principle
Fig. 30 shows a schematic of the PFSW process, which consists of a slide, a pedes

## B0067 · 第23页 · 清洗文本字符2401–3600

tal, a stationary shoulder and a mounting
platform including two separate segments. The slide realizes relative motion between the welding workpieces and the stationary
shoulder. The plasticized materials under the rotating shoulder are supported by the stationary shoulder. To guarantee the complete
penetration of the rotating pin, a blind hole is made in the centre of the stationary shoulder. The two separate parts of the mounting
platform are placed beside the slide with the purpose of ﬁxing the sheets. Before the PFSW process, the slide and the mounting
platform need to be fastened to the workbench. The relative positions of these components are shown in Fig. 30a. The tilt angle of the
rotating tool is kept constant, as illustrated in Fig. 30b. Under a pseudo-steady state, the cross-sectional view of softened materials
surrounding the rotating pin tool is depicted in Fig. 30c [124].
3.3.2. Joint formation
Fig. 31 depicts the upper and lower surface appearances of a typical PFSW joint, in which no grooves or other visible defects are
observed. The upper surface of the PFSW joint is similar to that in conventional FSW, and the width is equal to the diameter of the
rotating shoulde

## B0068 · 第23页 · 清洗文本字符3601–3953

r. The lower surface presents good surface ﬁnishing due to the relative motion between the welding workpieces and
Fig. 30. Schematics of the PFSW process: (a) equipment and relative positions, (b) lateral view parallel to the welding direction and (c) local cross-
sectional view [124].
X. Meng, et al. Progress in Materials Science 115 (2021) 100706
23

## B0069 · 第24页 · 清洗文本字符1–1200

the stationary shoulder, which indicates that the plasticized materials in the NZ are successfully supported by the stationary shoulder.
The macrostructure in the cross-section of the PFSW joint di ﬀers from that in conventional FSW joint, presenting an hourglass
shape that is obviously asymmetric along the thickness direction, as shown in Fig. 32. The upper and lower materials in the NZ are
subjected to di ﬀerent deformation and heat exposure during the PFSW process, resulting in the formation of the asymmetric
hourglass shape. Furthermore, the NZ is divided into the SAZ, PAZ and stationary shoulder a ﬀected zone (SSAZ). The SSAZ is a typical
feature of a PFSW joint. Moreover, no kissing bond defect is detected in the root, which indicates that the continuous oxide ﬁlm in a
conventional FSW joint can be successfully destroyed when the welding workpieces are completely penetrated by the rotating pin
during the PFSW process.
Fig. 31. Surface appearances of a typical PFSW joint: (a) upper and (b) lower surfaces [124].
Fig. 32. Microstructures of 2219-T6 Al alloys in (a –d) a PFSW joint and (e –g) a conventional FSW joint [125].
X. Meng, et al. Progress in Materials Science 115 (2021)

## B0070 · 第24页 · 清洗文本字符1201–1210

 100706
24

## B0071 · 第25页 · 清洗文本字符1–1200

3.3.3. Mechanical properties
Fig. 33 illustrates the mechanical properties of the PFSW joints. The tensile strength and elongation of the PFSW joint reached
354 MPa and 7.5%, respectively, which were approximately 79.2% and 58.6% of those in the BM (447 MPa and 12.8%) [125].B y
comparison, the tensile strength and elongation of the conventional FSW joint at the same welding speed of 300 mm/min were
317 MPa and 3.1%, respectively, which were lower than those of the PFSW joint. It is concluded that the PFSW e ﬀectively realizes
back support from the stationary shoulder and then eliminates the kissing bond, improving mechanical properties.
3.3.4. Prospects
PFSW has been used to successfully join 2219-T6 Al alloys, wherein back support was realized and a sound joint with a smooth
surface was obtained. This method can reduce the softening degree and eliminate weld thinning of the joint, thereby improving
mechanical properties. PFSW has the potential to join fuel tanks in rockets. The structural complexity of the welding tool restricts its
broader adoption, including applications in hollow or enclosed structures with narrow spaces.
4. Non-weld-thinning friction stir welding
Regardless of

## B0072 · 第25页 · 清洗文本字符1201–2400

 conventional FSW [65] or its derived welding technologies [126,127], weld thinning always forms at the joints and
easily results in the strength loss. This is because that a rotating shoulder plunges into the welding workpieces to a certain thickness
(≥0.05 mm, which is determined by the thickness of the workpieces) to produce intense frictional heat and result in the over ﬂow of
the plasticized materials. The plunge of the rotating shoulder cannot be neglected, and weld thinning cannot be avoided, as shown in
Fig. 34 . With wide applications of conventional FSW in manufacturing ﬁelds, such as aerospace, railway and automobile industries,
the negative problems caused by weld thinning have been progressively visualized [128]. First, the formation of weld thinning always
produces ﬂash defects and deteriorates the surface ﬁnishing and integrity. Second, weld thinning is prone to decrease the area of
eﬀective load bearing [129]. Kumar et al. [130] stated that when the plunge of the rotating shoulder increased to a certain extent,
weld thinning markedly increased, which easily caused joint fracture in the weak region of the weld, drastically deteriorating the
mechanical properties. Thi

## B0073 · 第25页 · 清洗文本字符2401–3269

rd, the acute edge induced by weld thinning usually forms between the BM and the NZ. Although me-
chanical properties of the joint with weld thinning can satisfy the service requirements, the acute edge still becomes a potential safety
hazard during service. Under the action of load, the crack source is prone to form at the acute edge, which further reduces the anti-
fatigue properties and service life [131,132]. Especially in some ﬁelds that need a long service period, the acute edge of the
Fig. 33. Comparison of mechanical properties between PFSW and conventional FSW joints of 5-mm-thick 2219-T6 Al alloy plates [125].
Fig. 34. Weld thinning of a typical FSW joint (the value of weld thinning ( ΔT) is de ﬁned by the di ﬀerence between the weld thickness (T weld) and
the BM thickness (T BM)).
X. Meng, et al. Progress in Materials Science 115 (2021) 100706
25

## B0074 · 第26页 · 清洗文本字符1–1200

workpieces must be avoided. Even if the acute edge can be burnished and transformed into a smooth transition, the potential safety
hazard cannot be eliminated completely. Last, accurate welding and conformal welding concepts are widely mentioned and focused,
which mean strict requirements for the appearance dimension of the structural parts without weld thinning. Hence, weld thinning is a
substantial obstacle to achieving high-quality FSW joints.
Especially in military manufacturing ﬁelds, mechanical properties of the joints are not the sole criterion to evaluate the FSW joint
quality. With the increasing requirements of joint quality, the FSW joint not only needs excellent mechanical properties but also
requires superior surface integrity and outstanding service reliability. How to reduce or eliminate weld thinning and then achieve
high-quality FSW joints is a key to expand FSW technological applications. To reduce or eliminate the weld thinning of the FSW joint
and improve joint quality, researchers have performed extensive investigations from the viewpoints of the design in both of welding
tool and workpiece structures as well as the assisted processes. The used welding technolo

## B0075 · 第26页 · 清洗文本字符1201–2400

gies to reduce or eliminate weld thinning
mainly consist of three categories. The ﬁrst technology category seeks to prevent the over ﬂow of plasticized materials, which
comprises stationary shoulder FSW (SSFSW 2) or non-rotating shoulder assisted FSW (NRSA-FSW). The second technology category
seeks to avoid the loss of plasticized materials, which is characterized by MPD-FSW or zero-plunge-depth FSW. The last technology
category seeks to increase the additional materials to compensate for the loss of plasticized materials under the premise of adequate
frictional heat and material ﬂow, which comprises additive FSW (surface compensation FSW, T-plate assisted FSW and in-situ additive
FSW) and reductive FSW.
4.1. Stationary shoulder friction stir welding
According to the previously presented information, weld thinning is attributed to the plunge of the rotating shoulder that provides
as u ﬃcient forging force on the materials of the NZ. The frictional heat generated by the rotating shoulder always results in weld
overheating, which deteriorates mechanical performance. Moreover, the generated frictional heat is useless for materials with low
thermal conductivity, such as Ti alloys [21,1

## B0076 · 第26页 · 清洗文本字符2401–3600

33] and polymers [134–136]. SSFSW 2 or NRSA-FSW, a solid-state joining technology
derived from conventional FSW by TWI, has been extensively studied in the scienti ﬁc community and applied in industry, which has
achieved satisfactory results for butt-, lap- and T-type joints [137]. SSFSW 2 is deemed to be the next generation FSW technology by
the European aeronautic defence and space company (EADS) [138]. Compared with conventional FSW, SSFSW 2 has many ad-
vantages, which are detailed hereafter:
1) A smooth joint surface is bene ﬁcial to reducing surface machining after FSW and improving fatigue properties.
2) Low heat input decreases the width of the HAZ, and the temperature distribution along the thickness direction is uniform.
3) Stationary shoulder can transform the tensile stress in conventional joints into compressive stress, reducing the residual stress and
welding distortion.
4) Quasi-non-weld-thinning increases the e ﬀective area of load bearing.
5) SSFSW
2 has the advantage of joining materials with low thermal conductivity and welding T joints or corner joints.
6) SSFSW 2 can realize the ﬁlling of materials and provide a technical method for exploring additive manufactu

## B0077 · 第26页 · 清洗文本字符3601–3824

ring FSW.
7) SSFSW 2 reduces the torque and advancing resistance, which is helpful to the development of robotic FSW.
Fig. 35. Illustration of SSFSW 2 [137].
X. Meng, et al. Progress in Materials Science 115 (2021) 100706
26

## B0078 · 第27页 · 清洗文本字符1–1200

In this chapter, welding tools, process parameters, material compatibilities, technical development, microstructural evolution and
mechanical properties of SSFSW 2 joints are comprehensively reviewed. Additionally, the advantages, limitations and industrial
applications of SSFSW 2 are neutrally discussed, laying the theoretical foundation for expanding the industrial manufacturing ﬁelds of
SSFSW2.
4.1.1. Principle
SSFSW2 is a novel solid-state welding method, whose welding tool consists of a stationary shoulder and a rotating pin, as shown in
Fig. 35 [137] . During SSFSW 2, the rotating pin plunges into the workpieces, while the stationary shoulder tightly contacts the top
surface of the workpieces without a plunge depth. The welding workpieces can be heated and stirred by the thermo-mechanical
eﬀects induced by the rotating pin alone, which is di ﬀerent from that of conventional FSW. Under the enclosed chamber, which is
composed of the stationary shoulder, rotating pin, surrounding hard materials and backing plate, the over ﬂow of the plasticized
materials is prevented, thereby achieving a sound non-weld-thinning joint.
The heat generation mechanism during SSFSW 2 is very di ﬀeren

## B0079 · 第27页 · 清洗文本字符1201–2400

t from that during conventional FSW, which further inﬂ uences
joint surface integrity and microstructural characteristics. During conventional FSW, approximately 70 –80% of the main heat gen-
eration is produced by the friction between the rotating shoulder and the welding workpieces, whereas 20 –30% of the heat gen-
eration is from the frictional heat induced by the rotating pin and the plastic deformation heat. Due to the relatively high heat input
on the surface of the workpieces, the materials are easier to be softened and plasticized, and then over ﬂow from the weld, causing
weld thinning. For SSFSW 2, the primary heat input is produced by the rotating pin with either no or low heat generation provided by
the rotating shoulder. SSFSW 2 eﬀectively reduces the softening degree of the materials on the surface of the workpieces and is
beneﬁcial to reducing or eliminating weld thinning. Moreover, for FSW of thick plates, when the heat generation and material ﬂow
induced by the rotating pin are optimized to guarantee structural integrity during conventional FSW, surface overheating forms and
deteriorates the joint performance. SSFSW
2 can produce a uniform temperature distribution a

## B0080 · 第27页 · 清洗文本字符2401–3378

long the thickness direction and at-
tribute to homogeneous microstructures, thereby improving mechanical properties. During conventional FSW, the translation of the
rotating shoulder generally produces some ﬂashes and regular semi-circular shoulder marks on the surface, as shown in Fig. 36a. The
smoother surface results from the sliding e ﬀect of a stationary shoulder across the weld surface ( Fig. 36 b). The roughness in the
SSFSW
2 joint is markedly reduced by over an order of magnitude compared with that in the conventional joint ( Fig. 36c), whereas the
weld thinning in the SSFSW 2 joint was also substantially reduced from ~1 mm to less than 0.2 mm ( Fig. 36d) [139].
Fig. 36. Comparison of the surface quality with both processes: surface displacement maps of (a) conventional FSW and (b) SSFSW 2; (c) surface
roughness (Ra) and (d) local displacement relative to the original sheet surface [139].
X. Meng, et al. Progress in Materials Science 115 (2021) 100706
27

## B0081 · 第28页 · 清洗文本字符1–1200

4.1.2. Welding tools
During SSFSW 2, the rotating pin is the key factor of frictional heat and material transfer, which is primarily responsible for
achieving high-quality joints. First, the rotating pin squeezes the plasticized materials and is subjected to bending force and torque,
which requires the tool materials to have high strength, stability, ductility and anti-fatigue properties at high temperature. Second,
the wear resistance is another important factor to guarantee welding stability due to the severe friction between the rotating pin and
the workpieces. Third, to improve the material ﬂow around the surface of the rotating pin, the tool materials demand good ma-
chinability so that the surface morphologies of the rotating pin can be carved, such as threads and facets. Last, an important aspect is
the gap between the stationary shoulder and the rotating pin. During SSFSW
2, the viscoplastic materials under the forging e ﬀects are
easily squeezed into the gap, which result in weld thinning induced by the loss of plasticized materials or even the fracture of the
rotating pin for long-term work conditions. This problem is the main di ﬃculty facing SSFSW
2, which should be sol

## B0082 · 第28页 · 清洗文本字符1201–2400

ved urgently in the
industrial manufacturing ﬁelds.
TWI ﬁrst designed an SSFSW 2 system for Ti alloys, as shown in Fig. 37, which mainly consisted of a stationary shoulder (10), a
rotating pin (11), an inert gas protection system (13 –15) and water cooling jackets (4) [140]. Water cooling jackets can protect the
safety of welding equipment due to high heat generation induced by the high strength of Ti alloys, whereas inert gas protection can
avoid oxides and nitrides. These tools signi ﬁcantly increase the complexity of the SSFSW 2 system. To reduce or eliminate tool wear
and increase the homogeneity of microstructures, a tapered rotating pin and a stationary shoulder are made of W-Re alloys and WC
materials, respectively. The gap between the stationary shoulder and the rotating pin has not been reported. Russell et al. [141] also
proposed additive manufacturing of Ti parts by multiple SSFSW
2 processes using both 1D and 2D welding paths, as displayed in
Fig. 38. Brassington et al. [142] also stated that the new development of SSFSW 2 tools was considered as a step change in the process
evolution, in which the low heat input and smooth surface pro ﬁle could have the potential to jo

## B0083 · 第28页 · 清洗文本字符2401–3600

in Ti propellant tanks. EADS de-
veloped a robotic SSFSW 2 approach for Al alloys called Delta-N [138]. The welding system was signi ﬁcantly simpli ﬁed without the
gas protection or cooling device used for Al alloy butt joints, which only contained a stationary shoulder and a rotating tool, as shown
in Fig. 39 . The robotic SSFSW
2 approach successfully manufactured a 3D space structure.
Liu et al. [6] and Ji et al. [144] used SSFSW 2 to join AA2219-T8 and AA6005A-T6, respectively, wherein the rotating tools
consisted of a small rotating shoulder and a rotating pin, as shown in Fig. 40. Here, the stationary shoulder only assisted the surface
formation of joints. Due to the small rotating shoulder, this method can only be used for butt or lap welds, and it is di ﬃcult to join
corner or complex structural parts.
The heat generation during FSW depends on the strength and hardness of the workpieces. The higher the strength and hardness,
the higher the heat generation, the better the material ﬂow. Due to the higher strength and hardness of metals, such as Ti alloys and
Al alloys, relatively higher heat generation can be produced. Thermoplastic polymers or polymer matrix composites have 

## B0084 · 第28页 · 清洗文本字符3601–4616

relatively
low strength and hardness, making it di ﬃcult to generate su ﬃcient frictional heat and material ﬂow. Moreover, the ﬂuidity of the
thermoplastic polymer is good, which easily over ﬂows from the NZ, causing groove defects or weld thinning [146]. A modi ﬁed
SSFSW
2 called stationary shoe FSW is proposed, whose stationary tool is rectangular rather than circular to guarantee joint integrity,
as shown in Fig. 41. A closed-loop thermo-controller was responsible for supplying additional heating to the workpieces and slowing
the cooling rates of the materials, which has realized the high-quality joining of polymers, such as polypropylene (PP) [147], ac-
rylonitrile butadiene styrene (ABS) [110] and high-density polyethylene (HDPE) [135].
In addition to butt joints, SSFSW 2 also has the feasibility and potential to fabricate T or corner joints [149–152], which avoids the
Fig. 37. A cross-sectional view of the SSFSW 2 assembly [143].
X. Meng, et al. Progress in Materials Science 115 (2021) 100706
28

## B0085 · 第29页 · 清洗文本字符1–1200

problems of severe weld thinning and lap defects, such as cold lap or kissing bond defects during conventional FSW of lap structures
in T joints [153–155]. Schematic diagrams of the SSFSW 2 equipment for the T joints are shown in Figs. 42 and 43, containing non-
additive and additive processes. The stationary shoulder is machined into a corner structure similar to the angle of the corner joints,
which can ensure the plasticized materials in the enclosed chamber and then avoid the over ﬂow of materials. The weld thinning in
the skin and the lap defects between the skin and stringer are completely eliminated, overcoming the limitations of conventional FSW
in the T-type or corner joints. Moreover, the ﬁlling materials can be added into the transition between the skin and the stringer, which
is called additive SSFSW
2; this approach reduces the stress concentrations at the corner and then e ﬀectively improves the static and
fatigue properties. Both additive and non-additive SSFSW 2 joints exhibit satisfactory joint coe ﬃcients.
4.1.3. Material compatibilities
Table 5 highlights the recent progress of SSFSW 2 in chronological order with a summary of research ﬁndings, in which one can
no

## B0086 · 第29页 · 清洗文本字符1201–1743

te that the publication rate in this area has steadily increased since 2004 [150]. SSFSW2, which is characterized by several factors,
including uniform temperature distribution, non-weld-thinning, and smooth surface, has been successfully used to join Ti alloys,
Fig. 38. Additive manufacturing by SSFSW 2 [141].
Fig. 39. Robotic SSFSW 2 by EADS: (a) welding equipment and (b) stationary shoulder [138].
Fig. 40. Design of the SSFSW 2 tool: (a) model and (b) photograph [145].
X. Meng, et al. Progress in Materials Science 115 (2021) 100706
29

## B0087 · 第30页 · 清洗文本字符1–1200

steels [151], coppers, Al alloys (especially high-strength Al alloys (2xxx [6] and 7xxx [156]) that cannot be welded by conventional
fusion welding) and thermoplastic polymers [110]. Moreover, the other advantages induced by the stationary shoulder are re-
markable and have also been used to join dissimilar materials in butt and lap joints, such as Al/Mg alloys [157,158] and Al/polymers
[159]. Aiming at materials with low thermal conductivity, SSFSW 2 produces a more uniform temperature distribution along the
thickness direction and is ﬁrstly developed to join Ti alloys [143]. Al alloys, including the 2xxx, 6xxx and 7xxx series, have been most
commonly used and extensively studied from the viewpoints of welding parameters and design of welding tools [6,144,160]. This is
hardly surprising, considering that these materials are widely used in the industrial sectors because of their excellent properties
[161]. Additionally, with the increasing demands of light weight, thermoplastic polymers and polymer matrix composites, SSFSW 2
has also attracted extensive attention for these materials. Due to the good ﬂowability, the weld thinning phenomenon easily appears
due to the over ﬂow of the 

## B0088 · 第30页 · 清洗文本字符1201–2086

plasticized materials during conventional FSW [146]. Moreover, the extremely low thermal conductivity of
the polymer (compared with that of Al alloys) always results in a non-uniform temperature distribution and overheating of materials
at the top surface of the joint. Strand [162] ﬁrstly employed stationary shoe FSW, named SSFSW
2, to join PP and achieved remarkable
results. Subsequently, Mostafapour et al. [148] proposed a stationary shoe with a heating system to preheat the materials in front of
Fig. 41. Heat-assisted SSFSW 2: (a) stationary shoe and (b) schematic of the designed ﬁxture for heat-assisted SSFSW 2 [148].
Fig. 42. Schematics: (a) welding process and (b) tool package for an additive T joint [149].
Fig. 43. Illustrations of stationary shoulders: (a) non-additive and (b) additive SSFSW 2 [149].
X. Meng, et al. Progress in Materials Science 115 (2021) 100706
30

## B0089 · 第31页 · 清洗文本字符1–1200

the rotating tool, further improving the surface quality and mechanical properties of the joints. Huang et al. [159] also reported that
the stationary shoulder improved the surface ﬁnishing of short carbon ﬁbre-reinforced polyether ether ketone (SCF/PEEK)/AA2060-
T8 hybrid joint and that the maximum tensile shear strength of 33 MPa was higher than that produced by the state-of-the-art
techniques. Additionally, SSFSW 2 has been used to create high-quality dissimilar joints of Al/Mg alloys. Compared with conventional
FSW, SSFSW 2 has a lower peak temperature and simpler material ﬂow driven by the rotating pin, which can e ﬀectively reduce the
IMCs and the cold lap defect. Ji et al. [80,163] ﬁrst noted that SSFSW 2 could not only reduce the peak temperature and pin adhesion
but also improve the joint formation and material mixing, thereby enhancing mechanical properties. They also combined SSFSW 2
with ultrasonication to join dissimilar Al/Mg alloys and eliminated pin adhesion, producing a maximum tensile strength of 152 MPa
[158,164,165]. During friction stir lap welding (FSLW), the material ﬂow behaviour is dominated by two modes: rotating pin af-
fecting the hook and rotating shoul

## B0090 · 第31页 · 清洗文本字符1201–2400

der controlling the cold lap [166,167]. The application of SSFSW 2 in FSLW of similar or dissimilar
materials signi ﬁcantly reduces lap defects and improves mechanical properties [168–170].
4.1.4. Microstructural characteristics
Because the shoulder is static, the material ﬂow and heat generation are signi ﬁcantly reduced, thereby decreasing the
Table 5
SSFSW2 in chronological order with focus/ ﬁndings.
Authors (Ref.) Year Materials Focus/ﬁndings
Russell et al. [143] 2007 Ti-6Al-4V SSFSW2 was ﬁrst developed by TWI primarily to improve FSW of Ti-based alloys.
Russell et al. [141] 2008 Ti-6Al-4V Additive manufacturing of Ti parts by SSFSW 2 processes performed using both 1D and 2D
welding.
Ahmed et al. [171] 2011 AA6082-T6 Plastic deformation in the through thickness direction was dominated by the pin in SSFSW 2.
Li et al. [145] 2013 AA2219-T6 SSFSW 2 prevented the plasticized materials from escaping from the NZ and eliminated ﬂash
defects and weld thinning, achieving a tensile strength of 307 MPa.
Liu et al. [6] 2013 AA2219-T6 Microstructure and weld formation were dominated by the rotating pin and small concave
shoulder.
Li et al. [172] 2014 AA6061-T6 AA6061-T6 SSFSW 2 joint had na

## B0091 · 第31页 · 清洗文本字符2401–3600

rrower TMAZ and HAZ, the microstructures were more
symmetrical and homogeneous, and the maximum tensile strength was 77.3% of that of the BM.
Ji et al. [144] 2014 AA6005-T6 The width of SAZ was small. The tensile strength and elongation of the joint reached 82% and
65% of those of the BM.
Wu et al. [139] 2015 AA7050-T7651 The cold surface temperature dramatically decreased the normal workpiece thickness and can
lead to “speed cracking ” similar to that found in extrusion under hotter welding conditions.
Ji et al. [163] 2016 AA6061-T6/AZ31B Excellent material mixing happened and IMCs were reduced due to heat sink from stationary
shoulder.
Sun et al. [173] 2017 AA7010-T7651 A considerably smaller thermal ﬁeld was developed with SSFSW 2, which reduced the size of the
region of inhomogeneous compression created by the local temperature rise ahead of the tool.
Sun et al. [174] 2018 AA7050 The longitudinal residual stress distributions from all three techniques showed good agreement
within the uncertainty limits. A high tensile residual stress ﬁeld (~170 MPa) was found in the
NZ.
Barbini et al. [175] 2018 AA2024/AA7050 SSFSW 2 decreased both the welding area and the di ﬀusion at the inte

## B0092 · 第31页 · 清洗文本字符3601–4800

rface of the two alloys.
Meng et al. [165] 2018 AA6061-T6/AZ31B Stationary shoulder coupled with ultrasonic improved the surface formation of Al/Mg joint and
broke the IMCs into pieces, thereby increasing mechanical properties.
Regensburg et al. [176] 2018 AW1050 H14/CW024A
R240
SSFSW2 was applied to produce 2-mm-thick EN AW1050/CW024A lap joints with minimized
intermixing at the interface, lap defects and signi ﬁcant IMCs.
Huang et al. [159] 2018 SCF/PEEK and AA2060-
T8
Stationary shoulder enhanced the surface ﬁnishing, and the maximum tensile shear strength of
33 MPa was higher than that achieved by the-state-of-the-art technology.
Strand [162] 2004 PP Stationary shoe FSW was ﬁrst proposed to join thermoplastic PP.
Mostafapour et al. [177] 2012 HDPE HDPE could be welded at a high shoulder temperature and rotational velocity and a low welding
speed. Tool coating improved mechanical properties and surface qualities.
Kiss et al. [178] 2012 PETG A stationary shoe without a heating system was used to join amorphous PETG, which was
diﬃcult to be welded using conventional tools. The rotating pin could break and randomly
distribute spherulite.
Bagheri et al. [179] 2013 ABS A high rotatio

## B0093 · 第31页 · 清洗文本字符4801–6000

nal velocity and shoe temperature and a low welding speed improved welding
quality.
Rahbarpour et al. [180] 2014 Wood/plastic FSW of wood/polymer composites by a stationary shoe with a heating system was performed to
eliminate voids and poor mixing. The maximum tensile strength of the joint was 92.95% of that
of the BM.
Mendes et al. [181] 2014 ABS A high-quality joint was obtained for a tool temperature of 115 °C, an axial force greater than 1.5
kN, a rotational velocity higher than 1250 rpm and a low welding speed of 50 – 100 mm/min.
Eslami et al. [136] 2015 PP/PC One of the main challenges was to prevent material over ﬂow inside the shoulder, which caused
shoulder failure, especially in long joints. A Te ﬂon polymeric stationary shoe was the best
option.
Kiss and Czigány [182] 2015 Glass ﬁbre-reinforced PP SSFSW 2 realized the homogenization and interlocking of ﬁbres. A screwed pin with eight teeth
reduced the length of ﬁbres, thereby decreasing mechanical properties.
Mostafapour et al. [148] 2016 Nylon 6 Nylon 6 was joined via heat-assisted SSFSW 2 with an external heat source. A high-quality joint
with over 98% of the base strength was obtained.
Eslami et al. [183] 2018 HMHDPE

## B0094 · 第31页 · 清洗文本字符6001–6206

 The vertical positioning of the tool was responsible for the axial force, thereby providing both
the forging pressure and frictional heat.
X. Meng, et al. Progress in Materials Science 115 (2021) 100706
31

## B0095 · 第32页 · 清洗文本字符1–1200

inhomogeneity degree of microstructures in the through-thickness direction. The primary frictional heat is generated around the
rotating pin, further a ﬀecting the microstructural evolution, which presents signi ﬁcant diﬀerences relative to conventional FSW. The
NZ in the conventional FSW joint presents an irregular shape, and the TMAZ in the conventional FSW joint exhibits asymmetry. These
ﬁndings are attributed to the di ﬀerences in shear stress and material ﬂow on the AS and RS [66]. The NZ in the SSFSW
2 joint is similar
to the shape of the rotating pin because the shoulder is static, and the width of the SAZ in this joint is far lower than that in a
conventional FSW joint. In fact, the microstructural evolution is closely connected with the welding thermal cycle that depends on the
thermal and mechanical properties of the welding workpieces. In this chapter, three kinds of typical materials are emphasized: Ti
alloys with low thermal conductivity and high strength, Al alloys with high thermal conductivity and medium strength, and ther-
moplastic polymers with low thermal conductivity and low strength.
4.1.4.1. Ti alloys . Ti alloys, due to their high speci ﬁc strength and good 

## B0096 · 第32页 · 清洗文本字符1201–2400

corrosion resistance, have been the ﬁrst choice for the next
generation of jet engines in the aerospace industry. FSW of Ti alloys is the primary focus of researchers. Due to low thermal
conductivity, a large temperature gradient along the thickness direction easily results in inhomogeneous microstructures or tearing
defects in the NZ, reducing mechanical properties [137,184]. A back-heat-assisted FSW method was proposed to improve the uniform
temperature distribution and eliminate tearing defects [133,184], which always required heating equipment. SSFSW
2 arises at a
historic moment to improve the homogeneous distribution of microstructures and phases. Based on the characteristics of Ti alloys, the
FSW joint is mainly divided into three distinct zones: NZ, TMAZ and HAZ, as shown in Fig. 44. Some researchers have stated that no
TMAZ occurred in the SSFSW
2 joints of Ti alloys [185], whereas scholars claimed that a narrow TMAZ existed when observing an
obvious microstructural evolution due to the limited plastic deformation and heat input [186,187]. The microstructural evolution in
the TMAZ and HAZ is primarily a ﬀected by the microstructures of the BM. The microstructure in the NZ 

## B0097 · 第32页 · 清洗文本字符2401–3600

is a result of processing
conditions, tool geometry, cooling rates and material compositions.
The microstructural evolution of Ti alloys involves transformation, nucleation, and growth of the α and β phases in the BM. Ti-
6Al-4V, a kind of Ti alloy, is the most extensively studied Ti alloy due to its extensive industrial applications. Fig. 45 shows a
schematic of the microstructural evolution of Ti-6Al-4V during FSW, which is divided into the welding stage and cooling stage. When
the peak temperature in the NZ is above the β-transus temperature, the BM is destroyed and DRX occurs in the welding stage. Then,
ﬁne, equiaxed and transformed β phases are achieved at the end of the welding stage. In the cooling stage, the materials in both the
upper and lower surfaces of the NZ su ﬀer from fast cooling, and small grain boundary α phases are formed. At the end, smaller
lamellar α + β phases within the prior β grains are obtained. Due to low thermal conductivity, the materials in the middle region of
NZ undergo longer high-temperature exposure times. The slower cooling process is attributed to the larger lamellar α + β phases
within the prior β grains in the end. In the HAZ, the temperatur

## B0098 · 第32页 · 清洗文本字符3601–4800

e is below the β-transus temperature. However, the heat cycle still
causes grain coarsening, leading to an α → β transus. In the cooling stage, β → α + β occurs; hence, bimodal microstructures, which is
characterized by primary coarser α grains and lamellar α + β phases within prior β grains, can be observed. In the welding stage,
after being broken by the rotating tool, a higher temperature but below the β-transus can be obtained at the NZ top. Hence, some α →
β occurs. Upon cooling, β → lamellar α + β occurs; hence, small lamellar structures can be obtained. In the middle and bottom
regions of NZ, the temperatures are far below the β-transus temperature. The stirring action plays a more important role, and only
ﬁne and equiaxed grains can be observed. Reducing the temperature gradient can be bene ﬁcial to achieving uniformly distributed
microstructures by SSFSW
2.
4.1.4.2. Al alloys . Al alloys are classi ﬁed into precipitation-strengthened alloys and solid-solution-strengthened alloys. Precipitation-
strengthened Al alloys, such as 2xxx, 6xxx and 7xxx Al alloys, are the most investigated materials by SSFSW 2 due to their increasing
demands and extensive applications in railway a

## B0099 · 第32页 · 清洗文本字符4801–5799

nd aerospace ﬁelds [188]. It is known that the peak temperature during FSW can
approach ~0.8 Tm or even 0.95 Tm, which is higher than the solution temperature of many precipitation-strengthened Al alloys [189].
The welding heat cycle and mechanical stirring in ﬂuence the evolution of the grain size, dislocations and especially precipitates,
which further in ﬂuence the subsequent mechanical properties. The thermo-mechanical behaviours simultaneously a ﬀect the joint
formation. As shown in Fig. 46, the SAZ is signi ﬁcantly reduced or even eliminated due to the stationary shoulder, and the widths of
the TMAZ and HAZ are decreased due to the reduced heat input on the top surface of the joint compared with that in the conventional
FSW joint. For the sound SSFSW 2 joint of the precipitation-strengthened Al alloys, the fracture location of the joints easily occurs at
Fig. 44. Macrostructure of a Ti-6Al-4V SSFSW 2 joint [137].
X. Meng, et al. Progress in Materials Science 115 (2021) 100706
32

## B0100 · 第33页 · 清洗文本字符1–1200

the HAZ with the severest softening degree. Therefore, the microstructural evolution in the HAZ directly determines the global
mechanical properties of the SSFSW 2 joints.
For the typical age-hardened 2xxx Al-Cu-(Mg) Al alloys, the evolution sequence of precipitates is as follows: SSS → GP(I) → GP
(II) → metastable phase θ″ → metastable phase θ′ → stable phase θ (Al2Cu). In 6xxx Al-Mg-Si Al alloys, Mg and Si are the major
alloying elements, contributing to precipitation strengthening. The precipitation sequence is as follows: SSS → clusters → initial β″ →
(pre-β″/needle-shaped β″ precipitate) → (rod-shaped precipitates β′/lath-shaped β′ precipitates/U1, U2) → (β-Mg2Si/Si). In the 7xxx
Al-Zn-Mg-(Cu) Al alloys, the precipitation sequence is as follows: SSS → metastable phase η′→ stable phase η [190–192]. The BM
consists of a large number of uniformly distributed ﬁne precipitates (approximately 5 nm in size) and some larger dispersoids. Li et al.
[156] reported that the distribution and quantity of dispersoids in the HAZ are similar to those in the BM. However, the precipitates
in the HAZ are larger than those in the BM. In the NZ, ﬁne precipitates are absent, and the dispersoids are 

## B0101 · 第33页 · 清洗文本字符1201–1856

much larger than those in
the BM. Liu et al. [6,125,145] examined the microstructural evolution of SSFSW of 2219-T6 Al alloys. The thermal cycle drives
metastable phases (GP zones and θ″) to transform to θ′ and θ phases and then inhibits the growth of recrystallized grains in the NZ.
The microhardness is increased by the formation of θ′ phases, but the coarsening of θ′ phsases explicitly causes a reduction in the
Fig. 45. Diagrammatic sketch of microstructural evolution during FSW of Ti-6Al-4V alloys [133].
Fig. 46. Macrostructures: (a) SSFSW 2 and (b) conventional FSW joints [172].
X. Meng, et al. Progress in Materials Science 115 (2021) 100706
33

## B0102 · 第34页 · 清洗文本字符1–1200

microhardness of Al-Cu alloys. Sun et al. [193] also stated that the needle-like precipitates grew and transformed into short rod-like
precipitates as a result of the welding thermal sycle in the HAZ, while the NZ was the only one that showed a large GP zone
dissolution peak and a high β″ precipitation peak.
4.1.4.3. Thermoplastic polymers . Thermoplastic polymers were ﬁrstly joined via SSFSW 2 by Strand [162], whose cross-sectional
macrostructure is shown in Fig. 47. The SSFSW 2 joint is separated into BM, NZ, TMAZ and bottom disturbance. Due to the extremely
low thermal conductivity, no HAZ appears in the SSFSW 2 joints of polymers. The NZ is characterized by onion rings and a relatively
narrow TMAZ. A typical defect occurs near the bottom disturbance due to insu ﬃcient stirring and low thermal conductivity and
becomes the weakest region during the tensile test, which can be eliminated by double-pass FSW [194,195]. Kiss and Czigány [178]
stated that stirring action of the rotating pin could break and randomly distribute spherulite. Additionally, for ﬁbre-reinforced
thermoplastic composites, the main di ﬃculty is the lack of continuity between the ﬁbres in the BM and NZ. Moreover,

## B0103 · 第34页 · 清洗文本字符1201–2400

 Kiss and
Czigány [182] performed SSFSW 1 of glass ﬁbre-reinforced composites and reported that this method could realize the
homogenization and interlocking of the ﬁbres, as indicated in Fig. 48. The fracture surface showed that ﬁbres are extracted from
the NZ, indicating interlocking with each other inside the NZ.
Gao et al. [197] performed di ﬀerential scanning calorimetry (DSC) for di ﬀerent regions of the PE joint and analysed the crys-
tallization behaviour induced by the uneven temperature distribution with the following formula:
=×W H
H
Δ
Δ 100%c
m
m
0 (7)
where HΔ m is the melting enthalpy of the sample and HΔ m
0 is the melting enthalpy of perfectly crystalline PE, for which the value is
293 J/g. The crystalline contents of the BM, HAZ, TMAZ and NZ were 54.5%, 54.0%, 51.1% and 48.2%, respectively ( Fig. 49). There
is no obvious HAZ due to the low thermal conductivity. The crystallinity of the TMAZ and NZ was signiﬁ cantly reduced due to the low
cooling rates.
4.1.5. Process development
During SSFSW 2, heat generation and material ﬂow are mainly provided by the rotating pin, which are completely di ﬀerent from
those in conventional FSW. The heat generation provided by the 

## B0104 · 第34页 · 清洗文本字符2401–3600

rotating pin during conventional FSW is only 20 –30% of the total
heat input. The optimum welding parameters during conventional FSW that can be bene ﬁcial to obtaining excellent joints may not be
suitable for SSFSW 2 due to insu ﬃcient frictional heat and material ﬂow resulting from the loss of frictional heat generated by the
rotating shoulder. There are obvious di ﬀerences in welding parameters between conventional FSW and SSFSW 2. Moreover, SSFSW 2
can also prevent the plasticized materials from over ﬂowing from the weld at extremely high heat inputs during conventional FSW and
broaden the welding parameter windows. According to the theories of heat generation during FSW [198–200], heat input is closely
correlated with base properties of workpieces (yield strength, hardness, etc.), welding parameters (welding speed, rotational velocity,
plunge depth, etc.) and equipment parameters (shoulder or pin diameter, pin morphology, etc.). Table 6 lists the optimum welding
parameter windows for SSFSW 2 of di ﬀerent materials with di ﬀerent thermal and mechanical properties.
For materials (Ti, Ti alloys, etc.) with high yield strength and low thermal conductivity, the relatively low rotat

## B0105 · 第34页 · 清洗文本字符3601–4690

ional velocity and
welding speed are feasible. Russell et al. [143] stated that sound joints could be achieved at rotational velocities of 400 –500 rpm and
welding speeds of 60– 80 mm/min during SSFSW 2 of Ti-6Al-4V alloys. Maltin et al. [151] also stated that defect-free SSFSW 2 joints of
steels can be produced at a rotational velocity of 200 rpm and a welding speed of 120 or 140 mm/min. Aiming at Cu or Cu alloys with
high thermal conductivity [202], the frictional heat quickly transfers from the weld to the surrounding materials, and then results in
welding defects, which always demand high heat input (high rotational velocity or low welding speed). Wei et al. [150] stated that Cu
sheets with a thickness of 0.85 mm were successfully joined using a rotational velocity of 3000 rpm, a welding speed of 300 mm/min
and a Z-direction force of 6 kN, in which the specially high welding speed was used to avoid the distortion of the ultra-thin sheets. No
Fig. 47. Macrostructure of a typical SSFSW 2 joint of PP [196].
X. Meng, et al. Progress in Materials Science 115 (2021) 100706
34

## B0106 · 第35页 · 清洗文本字符1–1022

Fig. 48. Welded zone in ﬁbre-reinforced composites with a thermoplastic matrix: (a) non-intermeshing ﬁbres and (b) intermeshing ﬁbres at the
interface and (c) borderline between the NZ and the BM and (d) the fracture surface [182].
Fig. 49. DSC curves of a PE FSW joint: (a) BM, (b) HAZ, (c) TMAZ and (d) NZ [197].
Table 6
Optimum welding parameter windows for SSFSW 2 of di ﬀerent materials.
Materials Joint type Rotational velocity (rpm) Welding speed (mm/min) Preheating temperature (°C) Ref.
Ti6Al4V Butt 400– 500 60– 80 [143]
Steel Butt 200 120 – 140 [151]
AA2219-T6 Butt 600 – 900 100 [201]
AA6005A-T6 Butt 2000 300 – 600 [144]
AA6061-T6 Butt 750 – 1500 100 [172]
AA7050-T7651 Butt 1500 100 – 400 [139]
ABS Butt ≥1250 ≤100 115 [110]
HDPE Butt 1400 25 100 [135]
Nylon 6 Butt 630 20 150 [148]
PP Butt 1080 51 160 [162]
AA6061-T6/AZ31B Butt 1000 60 [158]
SCF/PEEK/AA2060-T8 Lap 1600 30 [159]
AA6082-T6 Lap 2000 840 [150]
Pure copper Butt 3000 300 [150]
X. Meng, et al. Progress in Materials Science 115 (2021) 100706
35

## B0107 · 第36页 · 清洗文本字符1–1200

remarkable wear was observed on the tool pin or stationary shoulder.
For Al alloys, Liu et al. [201] reported that sound joints were only obtained at a rotational velocity of 800 rpm in conventional
FSW, whereas SSFSW 2 could produce defect-free joints in a wider range of rotational velocities of 600 –900 rpm at a constant welding
speed of 100 mm/min for AA2219-T6. Wu et al. [139] compared conventional FSW with SSFSW 2 of AA7050-T7651 based on the
same size rotating pin and a welding speed of 400 mm/min. The optimum rotational velocities in conventional FSW and SSFSW 2 were
700 rpm and 1500 rpm, respectively. SSFSW 2 generated a ~30% lower heat input than conventional FSW, which achieved a narrow
HAZ. Ji et al. [144] stated that a sound joint could be attained over a wide welding speed range, from 300 mm/min to 600 mm/min,
based on a small rotating shoulder and a constant rotational velocity of 2000 rpm during SSFSW 2 of AA6005A-T6. Li et al. [172]
indicated that tensile properties for SSFSW 2 joints of AA6061-T6 were nearly una ﬀected by rotational velocities of 750– 1500 rpm at a
constant welding speed of 100 mm/min, whereas increasing the welding speed from 100 to 300 mm/min mar

## B0108 · 第36页 · 清洗文本字符1201–2400

kedly increased the
tensile properties at a constant rotational velocity of 1500 rpm. The maximum joint e ﬃciency of 77.3% (256 MPa) was achieved
under welding parameters of 1500 rpm and 300 mm/min. To attain sound SSFSW 2 Al alloy butt joints with high strength, the
rotational velocities of 500– 2000 rpm and the welding speeds of 50 –600 mm/min are appropriate.
For polymer materials (thermoplastic polymers or polymer matrix composites) with extremely low yield strength and thermal
conductivity [203,204],i ti sd i ﬃcult to transfer heat input to preheat the materials at the front of the rotating tool. Higher heat input
(high rotational velocity and low welding speed) or a secondary heat source is required to attain sound joints. Mendes et al. [110]
stated that high strength e ﬃciency was achieved only when a high rotational velocity and a high axial force were used during SSFSW 2
without a heating system in 6-mm-thick ABS sheets. Rotational velocity and axial force values above a certain threshold were
required to produce defect-free joints. A high-quality joint was obtained for a tool shoulder temperature of 115 °C, an axial force
higher than 1.5 kN, rotational velocities greater 

## B0109 · 第36页 · 清洗文本字符2401–3600

than 1250 rpm and low traverse speed ranging between 50 and 100 mm/min [181].
Azarsa et al. [135] performed SSFSW
2 with HDPE and stated that a combination of high rotational velocity and low welding speed
increased ﬂexural strength by reducing the sizes of defects. The optimum welding parameters to achieve maximum ﬂexural strength
were a rotational velocity of 1400 rpm, a welding speed of 25 mm/min and a shoulder temperature of 100 °C. Aydin et al. [205]
adopted backing preheating at 50 °C to join a 4-mm-thick ultrahigh molecular weight PE (UHMW-PE) sheet and then improved joint
formation due to a uniform temperature gradient through the thickness direction. Vijendra et al. [206] stated that induction heating
enabled materials to be plasticized in a short time and to be easily stirred. The optimum conditions for the maximum joint strength
were a tool pin temperature of 45 °C, a welding speed of 50 mm/min and a rotational velocity of 2000 rpm.
Additionally, aiming at the SSFSW
2 of dissimilar materials, the welding parameters depend on the materials or joining types (butt
or lap joints). For dissimilar materials with severe interfacial reactions, mechanical interlocking and metallu

## B0110 · 第36页 · 清洗文本字符3601–4654

rgical bonding are
attributed to the joint strength. Meng and his co-workers [158,164,165] stated that a rotational velocity of 1000 rpm could be
responsible for the su ﬃcient heat input, while a low welding speed of 60 mm/min could provide much more stirring time to improve
the mechanical interlocking for SSFSW 2 of Al and Mg alloys. A high welding speed higher than 60 mm/min easily resulted in welding
defects, which can be further increased to 80 mm/min assisted by ultrasonication [207]. When using a lap con ﬁguration of polymer
Fig. 50. Mechanical properties and strength coe ﬃcient (%) of SSFSW 2 in the current research and published open literature and current research.
(In sequence: AA2219-T6 [201], AA2050-T3 [188], AA6082-T6 [150], AA7050-T7651 [139], DH36 steel [151], AA6082-T6 [151], AA6061-T6/
AZ31B [164], SCF/PEEK/AA2060-T8 [159], AA7075-T651 [156], AA6061-T6 [213], AA6005A-T6 [144], AA6061-T6/AZ31B [158],P P [147],
Nylon 6 [148], HDPE [177], Wood-plastic [180]).
X. Meng, et al. Progress in Materials Science 115 (2021) 100706
36

## B0111 · 第37页 · 清洗文本字符1–1200

at the upper and metal at the lower, the selection of welding parameters should be in accord with the joining of polymers, which
needs relatively lower welding speeds lower than 50 mm/min without a secondary heating system. For lap joints of similar or
dissimilar materials, the process variations are di ﬀerent from those of butt joints, whose rotational velocity is relatively lower
[169,208] and welding speed is slightly higher due to the original interface in butt joints disappearing in the upper sheet of lap
welding.
4.1.6. Mechanical properties
SSFSW2 not only inherits the advantages including low peak temperature, small residual stress and distortion, simple process and
non-pollution of conventional FSW, but also generates a concentrated heat input, reducing the joint softening degree and sub-
stantially improving static mechanical properties. Fig. 50 shows the mechanical properties of SSFSW 2 joints. Wu et al. [139] com-
pared the mechanical properties between SSFSW 2 and conventional FSW of AA7050-T7651. SSFSW 2 provided an approximately 30%
lower heat input and 20– 40 MPa higher yield and tensile strength than those of conventional FSW joints, which were attributed to the
co

## B0112 · 第37页 · 清洗文本字符1201–2400

mpatible deformation induced by uniform thickness properties. Huang et al. [159] established a radar chart to describe the re-
lationships between weld thinning, microstructural characteristics and mechanical properties ( Fig. 51). They stated that SSFSW 2
could control the microstructural evolution and subsequently a ﬀect mechanical properties, which were better than those of the state-
of-the-art techniques. The microstructure, surface stress state and stress concentration were investigated at the fatigue crack initiation
sites. The stress concentration determines the fracture location, and the surface microstructure and surface stress state in ﬂuence the
fatigue properties. SSFSW 2 can reduce the residual stress to a certain extent since the stationary shoulder exerts residual compressive
stress on the materials on the top surface, which is bene ﬁcial to improving fatigue performances. Jayaraman et al. [209] indicated
that FSW increased the high-cycle fatigue endurance of Al alloys by 80% due to a deep surface layer of compressive residual stress by
low plasticity burnishing. Huang et al. [210–212] proposed in-situ rolling FSW and fabricated ultra ﬁne grains and a compressive
re

## B0113 · 第37页 · 清洗文本字符2401–3600

sidual stress layer on the surface of the joint, improving the corrosion resistance and reducing residual stress and distortion. The
surface of the SSFSW
2 joint was characterized by ultra ﬁne grains, which evidently enhanced the fatigue properties [149]. Li et al.
[149] also stated that the stress concentration at the internal corner for additive SSFSW 2 joints was evidently lower than that for non-
additive joints due to the additional materials ﬁlling into the corner, as shown in Fig. 52. EADS [138] also applied SSFSW 2 in the
complex 3D structural window frame of an aircraft and stated that no failure occurred after 140,000 cycles, indicating excellent
fatigue properties.
4.1.7. Prospects
SSFSW
2 has been used to join many kinds of materials with varied thicknesses, such as Al alloys, Ti alloys, steels and polymers.
Many outstanding advantages have been applied in the manufacturing ﬁelds of aerospace and transportation, such as smooth surface,
low residual stress and distortion, and high joint quality. However, some areas need to be addressed, which are detailed hereafter:
(1) Long service welding tool: During SSFSW
2, the plasticized materials easily over ﬂow into the gap betw

## B0114 · 第37页 · 清洗文本字符3601–4061

een the stationary shoulder
and the rotating tool, which results in the overheating of the rotating pin and then acutely deteriorates the service life. A tool
coating technology shall be developed to improve the heat insulation and wear resistance, increasing the service life of the
rotating tool.
Fig. 51. Radar chart of the microstructural characteristics versus mechanical properties [159].
X. Meng, et al. Progress in Materials Science 115 (2021) 100706
37

## B0115 · 第38页 · 清洗文本字符1–1200

(2) SSFSW 2 of metal matrix composites (MMCs): Initial tool wear can also proceed without an optimized shape at high wear rates.
The tool wear in FSW of MMCs is attributed to particle erosion and abrasion from the reinforcements during rotating and
translational vortex ﬂow. In addition to the excessive cost e ﬀect of tool wear, the contamination of the weld by debris from the
worn tool is of considerable concern. Premature failure due to the brittleness and high tool cost is the challenge encountered with
these materials.
(3) SSFSW
2 of polymer matrix composites and between these composites and metals: SSFSW 2 has the remarkable advantage and
feasibility to join polymer matrix composites with low thermal conductivity and strength due to the focused heat source and
assisted heating. Moreover, SSFSW 2 has the potential to join dissimilar or monolithic materials.
(4) High corrosion and wear resistance of SSFSW 2 joints: Although SSFSW 2 can achieve high-quality joints, the corrosion and wear
resistances are reduced due to the dissolution, coarsening and reprecipitation of the strengthening phases, especially in the 2xxx
and 7xxx Al alloys. In addition to depositing particles, such as 

## B0116 · 第38页 · 清洗文本字符1201–2400

pure Al, Al 2O3, SiC p, multi-wall carbon nanotubes or graphene
hybrids with surface friction stir processing (FSP) or cold spraying, may become further hotspots to improve the wear and
corrosion resistance.
4.2. Zero-plunge-depth friction stir welding
The welding tool is the foundation of FSW, playing signi ﬁcant roles in microstructures, defects and mechanical properties. During
conventional FSW, the welding tool always contains a shoulder and a pin, which can realize high-quality welding under a tilt angle.
The application of the shoulder plunge depth during FSW is the intrinsic reason for the occurrence of weld thinning. It can be inferred
that weld thinning can be eliminated with a zero plunge depth, thereby avoiding the loss of plasticized materials. Based on this
concept, a novel zero-plunge-depth FSW was proposed by Zhang et al. [214,215] and our workgroup [216].
4.2.1. Principle
Zhang et al. [214,215] developed the novel non-weld-thinning FSW (NWT-FSW), which could be performed at a zero shoulder
plunge depth, as shown in Fig. 53. The weld thinning phenomenon is e ﬀectively eliminated without adding or removing any ma-
terials before or after welding, and without other ass

## B0117 · 第38页 · 清洗文本字符2401–3351

isted shoulder tools. A concave geometrical feature is utilized on the bottom
surface of the rotating shoulder. The concavity is designed to provide a reservoir of pin sheared materials. Scrolls are among the most
useful geometrical features for developing an inwardly directed traction force under the rotating shoulder during FSW. Three equally
spaced scrolls are machined on the concave shoulder. During NWT-FSW, the concave shoulder only slightly contacts the workpieces
and forms an enclosed chamber, which avoid plasticized materials over ﬂowing from the weld. Welding heat input and material
transfer are mainly provided by the rotating pin rather than the rotating shoulder, which ensure the sound joint without weld
Fig. 52. S–N curves for additive and non-additive T joints produced by SSFSW 2 [149].
Fig. 53. Schematic views: (a) NWT-FSW and (b) conventional FSW [214,217].
X. Meng, et al. Progress in Materials Science 115 (2021) 100706
38

## B0118 · 第39页 · 清洗文本字符1–1200

thinning.
Although the NWT-FSW proposed by Zhang et al. [214] can eliminate weld thinning, the zero tilt angle narrowed the welding
process window due to the small forge e ﬀects induced by the rotating shoulder. Our research group at Harbin Institute of Technology
proposed a novel FSW method named “single welding and double forming ” MPD-FSW, which overcome the conventional inherent
issues wherein the plunge of the rotating shoulder at a tilt angle made it di ﬃcult to achieve non-weld-thinning joints [216]. This
welding tool was designed to be detachable, as shown in Fig. 54, which was composed of an outer rotating shoulder, an inner rotating
shoulder and a rotating pin. The plunge depths of the inner and outer rotating shoulders could be changed by controlling the relative
height between the outer and inner shoulders. The concave shoulder morphology is specially designed to increase the forging and
gathering eﬀects on the plasticized materials, thereby improving the joint formation. During welding, the inner rotating shoulder and
pin plunge into the workpieces to a certain depth, which are responsible for the “single welding ”, and then ensure the joint inner
integrity. Without th

## B0119 · 第39页 · 清洗文本字符1201–2400

e plunge depth, the outer rotating shoulder only slightly contacts with the workpieces and was attributed to
“double forming ”, which further rolls the plasticized materials on the surface and subsurface. The ﬂash defects are eliminated, and
weld thinning is avoided. Moreover, the rational choice of the rotating pin is essential to increase the stirring e ﬀect and heat
generation due to the decrease in heat generation induced by the relatively smaller inner rotating shoulder. A tapered threaded pin
with three facets was designed to improve the material ﬂow behaviour.
4.2.2. Formation mechanism
Fig. 55 shows the surface formation of MPD-FSW joints. The surface appearance is divided into two a ﬀected zones: the outer
rotating shoulder a ﬀected zone, and the inner rotating tool a ﬀected zone. The plunge depth of the inner rotating shoulder is larger
than that of the outer rotating shoulder, which corresponds to the subzone.
The MPD-FSW process was mainly separated into “single welding ” and “double forming ”. During welding, the inner rotating
shoulder and pin plunged into the workpieces and generated frictional heat and deformation heat, which further attributed to the
transfer of th

## B0120 · 第39页 · 清洗文本字符2401–3600

e plasticized materials, and then a metallurgical bond was achieved. The heat generation of the “single welding ” was
completely from the frictional heat between the inner rotating tool and the workpieces. Furthermore, the outer concave shoulder
slightly contacted the workpieces and formed an enclosed chamber, which restricted the over ﬂow of the plasticized materials that
were squeezed from the inner rotating shoulder a ﬀected zone. With the rotation and advancement of the outer rotating shoulder, the
plasticized materials from the inner rotating tool a ﬀected zone were re ﬁlled into the weld thinning location induced by the plunge of
the inner rotating shoulder, thereby achieving non-weld-thinning joints ( Fig. 56 ). The outer rotating shoulder only squeezed and
forged the plasticized materials, which caused the total heat generation of the MPD-FSW to be lower than that of conventional FSW.
No-weld-thinning appeared in the MPD-FSW joints.
In addition to heat generation, the material ﬂow behaviour could be separated into three types. The ﬁrst type was the layer ﬂow
induced by the welding speed, in which the plasticized materials around the rotating tool ﬂowed backward as the tool 

## B0121 · 第39页 · 清洗文本字符3601–4800

advanced. The
second type was the rotation ﬂow induced by the rotating welding tool via friction, during which the ﬂow rate gradually decreased as
distance
from the centre of the welding tool increased. The last prominent type was the ﬂow induced by the rotating pin, which made
the plasticized materials near the subsurface of the pin ﬂow downward and then upward away from the pin. In particular, the special
design of the pin morphologies, such as threads and facets, can signi ﬁcantly improve this ﬂow.
An illustration of the material ﬂow behaviour induced by the novel welding tool is displayed in Fig. 57 [218] . During the MPD-
FSW process, the material ﬂow rate was divided into vshear and vnormal due to the presence of the three facets on the rotating pin. The
vshear mainly provided shear force to improve material transfer, whereas the vnormal signiﬁcantly pushed the plasticized materials and
further promoted the material ﬂow rate, as shown in Fig. 57a and b. Under the relatively lower peak temperature induced by the
inner small rotating shoulder, the improved material ﬂow rate e ﬀectively avoided the macroscopic welding defects and further
enhanced the material transfer rate throu

## B0122 · 第39页 · 清洗文本字符4801–5274

gh the thickness direction. The plasticized materials ﬂowed downward to the bottom near
the pin surface (marked by red arrows in Fig. 57 b) and then ﬂowed upward away from the pin surface (marked by blue arrows in
Fig. 57 b). As shown in Fig. 57 c, the partially plasticized materials easily ﬂowed out of the NZ due to the small shoulder diameter
Fig. 54. Schematics of (a) MPD-FSW and (b) conventional FSW.
X. Meng, et al. Progress in Materials Science 115 (2021) 100706
39

## B0123 · 第40页 · 清洗文本字符1–1200

when the outer rotating shoulder was not employed (marked by green arrows in Fig. 57c). Moreover, the outer rotating shoulder
contacted the rotating tool in the clearance ﬁt, which can preheat the over ﬂowed materials and provide a downward pressure. This
pressure can prevent the plasticized materials from over ﬂowing from the weld and re ﬁll these materials into the NZ, as shown in
Fig. 57d. Hence, favourable surface integrity without weld thinning can be achieved.
4.2.3. Microstructural characteristics
The microstructure of an MPD-FSW joint is shown in Fig. 58 . The morphology is mainly divided into the outer SAZ, inner SAZ,
TMAZ, HAZ and NZ. During welding, the plunge depth of the outer shoulder was only 0.05 mm and that of the inner shoulder was
0.15 mm, which caused the outer SAZ to be located only at the subsurface of the workpieces. In the top, the grains were the smallest
in the whole joint, implying that this zone experienced severe plastic deformation at high strain rates. After being subjected to the
rotating pin, the upper part of the weld underwent additional deformation by the rotating tool shoulder. Huang et al. [210,211] also
stated that a plunge depth of 0.05 mm of

## B0124 · 第40页 · 清洗文本字符1201–2104

 rolling balls could fabricate a gradient surface layer on Al alloys, thereby improving the
microhardness on the subsurface. Apparently, the grain structures for each NZ layer of the NWT-FSW joint exhibited di ﬀerent sizes
from those of conventional FSW joints. Furthermore, the grains of both joints presented di ﬀerent distributed characteristics along the
thickness direction, as shown in Fig. 59. First, the grain size of the NWT-FSW joint was smaller than that of the conventional FSW
Fig. 55. Surface morphologies of MPD-FSW and conventional joints: schematics of surface appearances in (a) MPD-FSW and (b) conventional joints,
3D morphologies at the AS of (c) MPD-FSW and (d) conventional joints, and 3D morphologies at the RS of (e) MPD-FSW and (f) conventional joints.
Fig. 56. Variations in the heights of the di ﬀerent joints.
X. Meng, et al. Progress in Materials Science 115 (2021) 100706
40

## B0125 · 第41页 · 清洗文本字符1–1200

joint at each layer of the NZ. Second, the grain size of the conventional FSW joint gradually decreased from the upper to lower parts
of the NZ, as commonly observed in the conventional FSW joints of other Al alloys [219,220]. For the NWT-FSW joint, the grain size
was nearly uniform along the thickness direction. Compared with conventional FSW, the thermal and mechanical e ﬀects of the
rotating shoulder on NWT-FSW or MPD-FSW joints were weakened and became more uniform along the thickness direction.
4.2.4. Mechanical properties
The decreased heat input during zero-plunge-depth FSW (compared with that in conventional FSW) was obtained due to the loss
of frictional heat generated by the rotating shoulder, which was the intrinsic reason for grain re ﬁnement and the reduction in the
SAZ. These useful microstructural evolutions further narrowed the softening regions and degree, which provided the higher me-
chanical properties of the NWT-FSW joint. The maximum tensile strength of the optimized joint reached 218 MPa, whereas the
maximum elongation of 24.3% was comparable with that of base 5052 Al alloys [214], as shown in Fig. 60a. Additionally, the e ﬀect
of the outer rotating shoulder 

## B0126 · 第41页 · 清洗文本字符1201–2400

and welding parameters on the tensile properties of the MPD-FSW is shown in Fig. 60b. The addition of
the outer rotating shoulder provided signi ﬁcantly higher tensile strength than that provided by only the inner shoulder. Moreover,
when the rotational velocity was 600 rpm, the tensile properties ﬁrst increased and then decreased as the welding speed varied from
100 mm/min to 600 mm/min. The maximum tensile strength of the AA6082-T4 joint reached 231 MPa, which was equivalent to
90.8% of the BM [216].
4.2.5. Prospects
The novel design of the welding tool and process can eliminate weld thinning and obtain high-quality joints, providing technical
support for the high requirements of joint integrity. The innovative welding concept is bene ﬁcial to reducing the welding temperature
and reﬁning the grain size, thereby improving the mechanical properties. Moreover, the detachable welding tool is simpler than the
stationary shoulder tool system and had more potentials in the industrial manufacturing ﬁelds. Some aspects remain to be addressed,
as detailed hereafter:
Fig. 57. Material ﬂow and velocity distributions during FSW with controlled shape and performance: velocity distributions in 

## B0127 · 第41页 · 清洗文本字符2401–2631

the (a) horizontal
section and (b) vertical section; material ﬂow in (c) conventional FSW and (d) MPD-FSW [218].
Fig. 58. Macrostructure of a typical MPD-FSW joint.
X. Meng, et al. Progress in Materials Science 115 (2021) 100706
41

## B0128 · 第42页 · 清洗文本字符1–1200

(1) For di ﬀerent kinds of materials with di ﬀerent thicknesses, the design criterion of the welding tools needs to be established from
the viewpoints of joint formation, defect elimination and control of microstructures and mechanical properties.
(2) The design of the MPD-FSW tool can potentially be combined with the lower shoulder in BT-FSW or SSFSW 2, realizing non-weld-
thinning of hollow or enclosed structures, subsequently expanding the industrial applications.
(3) Technical and fundamental issues need to be elucidated, including the design of the welding tool or structure, heat generation,
material ﬂow behaviour, microstructural evolution and mechanical properties.
(4) Hybrid joining processes, such as electricity-assisted FSW, heat-assisted FSW, ultrasonic-assisted FSW and underwater FSW, can
be combined with advanced NWT-FSW to simultaneously improve the microstructure and mechanical properties by utilizing their
individual advantages.
4.3. Additive friction stir welding
In addition to the methods that prevent or avoid the over ﬂow of the plasticized materials, under the condition of a su ﬃcient
forging force, additive FSW can solve these issues through the introduction of

## B0129 · 第42页 · 清洗文本字符1201–1466

 additional materials.
Fig. 59. Grain structures of the NZ: (a –c) upper, middle and lower parts of the conventional FSW joint and (d –f) upper, middle and lower parts of the
NWT-FSW joint [219,220].
X. Meng, et al. Progress in Materials Science 115 (2021) 100706
42

## B0130 · 第43页 · 清洗文本字符1–334

Fig. 60. Tensile properties of zero-plunge-depth FSW joints: (a) AA5052 [214] and (b) AA6082-T4.
Fig. 61. Schematic and microstructure of the HYB process: (a) schematic and (b) macrostructure [221].
Fig. 62. Schematics of (a) additive FSW [230] and (b) reductive FSW.
X. Meng, et al. Progress in Materials Science 115 (2021) 100706
43

## B0131 · 第44页 · 清洗文本字符1–1200

4.3.1. Friction adstir welding
Sandnes et al. [221] proposed a hybrid metal extrusion and bonding (HYB) process by adding ﬁller materials and introducing
plastic deformation. During this process, an extruder head was clamped against the welding workpieces. The welding workpieces
were separated from each other so that an I-groove formed between them. The diameter of the rotating pin was slightly larger than
the width of the groove to ensure complete contact between the sidewalls of the groove and the pin, as indicated in Fig. 61. During
the rotation and advancement of the pin, the materials along with the oxide layer on the groove sidewalls were stirred and mixed as
they ﬂowed downward into the groove and consolidated behind the pin. A sound joint with a thickness of NZ greater than the
thickness of BM was obtained. Typically, the peak temperature in the groove between the welding workpieces is between 350 °C and
400 °C, which is below the peak temperature reported for FSW; this lower temperature is bene ﬁcial to reducing the joint softening
and improving joint quality. Li et al. [222,223] employed cold spraying with FSW joints to improve corrosion resistance, in which
weld thinning

## B0132 · 第44页 · 清洗文本字符1201–2400

 was eliminated by the addition of pure Al or Al
2O3 particles. Partial weak bonding easily formed at the interface
between the coating and the workpieces; meanwhile, cold spraying equipment is relatively expensive. Huang et al. [224] applied for
a patent called in-situ additive FSW to solve the weld thinning problem, in which a banding wire was introduced into the surface of
the welding workpieces by a wire feed system and a locating guide rail that made the banding wire tightly contact the welded
workpieces. Under the thermo-mechanical e ﬀects, the banding wire and the welding workpieces could be joined, and weld thinning
was avoided. Moreover, the type of banding wire could be changed according to the surface requirements, such as wear and corrosion
resistances, thereby creating a stronger interface than that produced with cold spraying [225]. However, note that the joining
between the banding wire and the workpieces involved a butt-lap interface, which easily led to lap welding defects, such as hook or
cold lap defects [169,226].
4.3.2. Compensation friction stir welding
Mika [16], Meng et al. [227] and Wen et al. [228] introduced additional solid-state materials to the joint r

## B0133 · 第44页 · 清洗文本字符2401–3600

egion along the welding
line during FSW of butt workpieces, which were named surface compensation FSW (SCFSW) or level compensation FSW (LCFSW), as
shown in Fig. 62a. The achieved joints had a larger cross-sectional thickness than conventional joints. After FSW, the materials in the
upper surface higher than the planar surface of the base workpieces were machined, producing a non-weld-thinning joint. Although
the weld thinning problem was solved, its disadvantages were also obvious. First, the addition and removal of materials before and
after welding made the FSW process relatively complicate, reducing the welding e ﬃciency. Second, many workpieces require three-
dimensional contours. When FSW was utilized to join complex three-dimensional structures, it was di ﬃcult to add materials to the
joint region. This method presented a relatively narrow application. Third, the upper part of the joint generally possessed more
superior mechanical properties than the middle and lower parts of FSW joints, such as pure Al or 2219-O Al alloys [219,229]. Even
though weld thinning could be eliminated, the mechanical properties are more prone to deterioration due to the removal of materials
from t

## B0134 · 第44页 · 清洗文本字符3601–4800

he upper part of the joints. The opposite reductive FSW was also proposed, which was similar to additive FSW, wherein the
thickness of the whole workpieces was higher than the thickness of the preset weld. After FSW, the materials higher than the top
surface of the weld were removed, and the stress concentration caused by the weld thinning was avoided. Alternatively, before FSW,
the abundant materials besides the weld were milled and formed a boss, which was further joined by FSW as in additive FSW.
Although this method could eliminate weld thinning, the resource waste was very severe, and the operating procedure was more
complex.
Zhao et al. [231] proposed a FSW method for eliminating weld thinning by an additional T-plate to simplify the procedures in
SCFSW that required a complex extrusion process to fabricate a convex welding line. During welding, the T-plate was placed at the
interface between the both workpieces, which made the surface of the weld higher than the surface of the workpieces. The lateral
force ensured the T-plate was static. The frictional heat produced by the shoulder was attributed to the joining between the ﬂange and
the materials on the top surface of the we

## B0135 · 第44页 · 清洗文本字符4801–6000

lding workpieces, while the thermo-mechanical behaviours improved the welding of the
web and the materials on the vertical surface of the workpieces, thereby eliminating weld thinning. Because the joining between the
ﬂange and the top surface of the welding workpieces only depended on the thermal conduction from the heat generation of the
shoulder, the thickness of the ﬂange was limited to less than 2 mm in thickness [232–234]. Moreover, the ultra-thin ﬂange was easily
deformed due to high frictional heat, resulting in poor joint integrity. Additionally, both of the joining interfaces between the ﬂange
and the web appeared at the butt joint [235,236], which always required a higher heat input to ensure good joint formation.
Otherwise, the joining di ﬃculties were greater due to the insu ﬃcient material ﬂow induced by low heat input. Ji et al. [213] also
stated that a sound joint could be achieved at a low welding speed and a high rotational velocity when an additional ﬁller was
introduced at the butt interface. The extremely high heat input was prone to severe joint softening, consequentially deteriorating the
joint strength.
5. Friction stir-based remanufacturing
Metallic material

## B0136 · 第44页 · 清洗文本字符6001–6954

s have been extensively applied in several manufacturing ﬁelds, including aerospace, railway, and shipping
transportation, which have drawn increasing attention to the development of welding techniques. Conventional fusion techniques,
due to coarse grains, hot cracks and pore defects, have di ﬃculty in obtaining high-quality welding joints. FSW is a mature solid-state
joining technique involving temperature, mechanics and metallurgy and their interactions. FSW has the advantages of low tem-
peratures, high-quality joints, small residual stress and distortion, and no pollution, which can e ﬀectively avoid the problems as-
sociated
with conventional fusion welding. When performed with inappropriate welding tools, process parameters or technological
conditions, welding defects easily form and deteriorate the mechanical properties. Moreover, aiming at some structural parts after
X. Meng, et al. Progress in Materials Science 115 (2021) 100706
44

## B0137 · 第45页 · 清洗文本字符1–1200

long service, corrosion, wear and other severe environments are prone to causing defects, which are detrimental to the service life of
the parts, as described hereafter [237]:
(1) Failure of processes or procedures during part fabrication.
(2) In-service defects were missed during fabrication or grew during operation.
(3) Degradation of parts and components through unforeseen environmental factors or extended operation, such as corrosion and
wear.
(4) Damage resulting from incorrect use or external factors.
All the service lifetimes of these structural parts involve “manufacturing-servicing-scrapping” and then result in economic loss and
material waste, which are detrimental to the development of the recycling economy. Introducing a repairing process into the service
lifetime of the parts can enable recyclability, such as “manufacturing-servicing-scrapping-repairing”, which can signi ﬁcantly improve
material utilization, resource conservation, energy savings and emission reduction. Green remanufacturing, with the characteristics
of high e ﬃciency, low cost and little pollution, can restore and upgrade the properties of the parts via advanced welding techniques
[238–240]. It is nece

## B0138 · 第45页 · 清洗文本字符1201–2400

ssary to perform green remanufacturing techniques to enhance all service lifetimes. Solid-state green re-
manufacturing techniques, based on friction stir-based technologies, can achieve high-quality joints due to low temperature and
severe plastic deformation.
5.1. Principle and advantages
Friction stir repairing (FSR), based on the characteristics of FSW, involves temperature, mechanics, metallurgy and interactions,
which has the feasibility and potential to repair the damaged structural parts. During FSR, an unconsumable or semi-consumable tool
plunges into the workpieces to be repaired, and generates frictional heat and severe plastic deformation. Under the peak temperature
and material ﬂow, the defects can be repaired by ﬁlling with plasticized materials. Owing to the advantages, including low tem-
perature, high-quality joints, and little pollution, friction stir-based remanufacturing techniques have been extensively developed and
investigated, which are mainly divided into repetitive FSW and additive FSW. Fig. 63 shows the key factors a ﬀecting joint integrity
and quality, which consists of equipment parameters, welding tool parameters, and material properties. The welding t

## B0139 · 第45页 · 清洗文本字符2401–3600

ool and the
equipment parameters are mainly dependent on the mechanical properties of the workpieces, such as yield strength, ductility, and
hardness, which play signi ﬁcant in ﬂuences on plastic deformation [116]. High heat input is required for a high melting point or
constant-pressure speciﬁc heat materials, while materials with a low melting point or constant-pressure speci ﬁc heat need relatively
lower heat input [241]. The thermal properties of the workpieces primarily a ﬀect the welding peak temperature and thermal transfer.
For materials with high thermal conductivity that easily result in heat loss, high heat input is necessary to guarantee su ﬃcient heat
input, obtaining a sound joints [242]. In contrast, the thermal conductivity of polymers is lower than that of Al alloys, which makes it
diﬃcult to preheat the materials at the front of the rotating tool. Higher heat input is also required to attain sound joints. Reasonable
selections of these parameters are the key and prerequisite to achieve excellent repaired joints.
Compared with conventional fusion repairing techniques, FSR has many advantages.
(1) Low peak temperature can reduce the degree of grain coarsening, there

## B0140 · 第45页 · 清洗文本字符3601–3879

by improving mechanical properties.
(2) Low heat input and severe plastic deformation can eliminate the pore and crack defects associated with fusion welding tech-
niques.
Fig. 63. Process variables of FSR [196].
X. Meng, et al. Progress in Materials Science 115 (2021) 100706
45

## B0141 · 第46页 · 清洗文本字符1–1200

(3) Low residual stress and small distortion improve the structural integrity.
(4) A smooth surface avoids subsequent surface treatment, reducing the complexity of the manufacturing processes.
(5) Strong material compatibility: FSR can also realize the repairing of high-strength Al alloys, such as 2xxx and 7xxx alloys.
(6) FSR has the potential to repair the parts of dissimilar metals according to engineering requirements.
(7) FSW equipment extensively used in the automobile and aerospace industries, which is characterized by low cost and high energy
eﬃciency, has universal properties.
5.2. Types of FSW defects
During the FSW process, a rotating tool with a shoulder and a pin rotates and plunges into the welding workpieces, which can
produce frictional heat and material ﬂow due to the friction between the rotating tool and the welding workpieces. After completing
FSW, the rotating tool retracts, and then a keyhole forms at the end of the weld, which easily deteriorates mechanical properties
[243]. Moreover, other welding defects, such as cavities [244], tunnels [245], grooves [246] and kissing bonds [247], caused by
improper process parameters or technological conditions are also d

## B0142 · 第46页 · 清洗文本字符1201–2400

etrimental to mechanical performance [248]. Several char-
acteristic defects are identi ﬁed as the e ﬀect of either ﬂow or geometric. The ﬂow-related defects occur outside the acceptable
processing window with parameters that are considered either too hot or too cold [249], as shown in Fig. 64 . For example, a higher
welding heat input or a larger plunge depth easily forms ﬂash defects and then results in weld thinning and stress concentration. The
insuﬃcient material ﬂow induced by lower heat input leads to inner joint defects, such as cavities, tunnels and grooves. Khan et al.
[245] stated that the kissing bond and the tunnel defects were easily in ﬂuenced by the plunge depth and o ﬀset during FSW of 5083-
H116 and 6063-T6 Al alloys. Tao et al. [250] indicated that the fracture behaviour of FSW joints was strongly inﬂ uenced by the
kissing bond featuring cracks from the lack of root penetration. Kainuma et al. [92] and Zhou et al. [93] reported that the existence of
a kissing bond would seriously deteriorate the fatigue lifetimes of a joint in both low-cycle and high-cycle tests. Arici et al. [195]
stated that the FSW joints of polymers could be broken by hand due to low strength

## B0143 · 第46页 · 清洗文本字符2401–3600

 resulting from kissing bond defects. Tunnelling
and kissing bond defects are formed at pin o ﬀsets towards stronger materials at the AS and without o ﬀset due to insu ﬃcient mixing.
Without proper treatment or design, the ﬂashes on the surface may cause signi ﬁcant problems in terms of stress concentrations,
corrosion and surface ﬁnish [251]. Moreover, the kissing bond defect severely a ﬀects the mechanical properties of the welded joints
compared with the tunnel defect. When the gap between the welding workpieces induced by the extrusion e ﬀect during the FSW
process or accumulation of some manufacturing errors of large structures is mismatched, the kissing bond and the lack of root
penetration are easily formed. Shultz et al. [252] found that increasing the gap width decreased the attainable maximum joint
eﬃciency, while increasing the welding tilt angle was bene ﬁcial to increasing the joint e ﬃciency to a certain degree, but the weld
thinning was severe. It is di ﬃcult
to obtain defect-free joints if the gap is too wide. Wanjara et al. [253] reported that when the
thickness of the 6061 Al alloy was 3.18 mm, a gap greater than 0.5 mm resulted in the formation of cavity defects 

## B0144 · 第46页 · 清洗文本字符3601–4800

in FSW joints,
which was determined to be the critical limit for practical application using serial industrial robots. Yang et al. [254] demonstrated
that a gap between the workpieces reduced the e ﬀective area of the cross-section around the gap and led to an unsuitable welds.
According to the characteristics and types of welding defects, they can be divided into global and local defects. The detailed features,
deﬁnitions and causes of these defects are listed in Table 7.
Table 8 lists the recent progress for solid-state repairing of welding defects or structural inner defects. The main research objects
are focused on lightweight metals, such as Al alloys and Mg alloys, among which the 2xxx, 6xxx and 7xxx series are the most common
Al alloys in aerospace and railways, and AZ31 is the most typical alloy. FSR has special advantages for these lightweight metals.
Moreover, the FSR of high melting point materials is rare, and few studies are associated with high melting point alloys, which are
only 316L stainless steel and CuNi 70/30. This is because the wear of the FSW tool is the critical issue for harder metals with high
melting temperatures [256,257] or MMCs [258,259], which is cha

## B0145 · 第46页 · 清洗文本字符4801–5237

racterized by the deformation and reduction in the pin diameter
and morphology. According to results of Rai et al. [143], plastic deformation, abrasion, di ﬀusion and reaction between the en-
vironment and the tool materials were the major wear mechanisms that occurred in FSW tools. The welding tool requires higher
Fig. 64. Forming conditions of several defects [249].
X. Meng, et al. Progress in Materials Science 115 (2021) 100706
46

## B0146 · 第47页 · 清洗文本字符1–1200

mechanical properties at high peak temperatures, such as high compressive yield strength, good strength, dimensional stability, creep
resistance and good thermal fatigue strength [22,260,261]. Moreover, these materials are usually expensive and di ﬃcult to be
machined, which are detrimental to the economic bene ﬁts and repairing ability. It follows that FSR can be used for many kinds of
light alloys and has strong material compatibilities for the main welding or repairing damaged defects in structural parts. From
Table 8, it can be concluded that the strength coe ﬃcients of the FSR joints all reach 80% of the optimum welding joints or BM,
indicating the high-quality repairing. The above-mentioned welding defects or exogenous source-induced defects are prone to causing
micro cracks which propagate and severely reduce the load bearing capacity and service life. Scholars in the scienti ﬁc community and
industry have performed extensive investigations in this area. According to the characteristics of the defects, the repairing process is
mainly composed of defect detection, location, geometrization, and repairing. In this section, highly e ﬃcient and high-quality solid-
state repairing

## B0147 · 第47页 · 清洗文本字符1201–2400

 is reviewed, which provides technical support and references for the repair of metallic structural parts.
Table 7
Typical defects appearing at the FSW joints.
Defect Typical view Deﬁnition Possible causes
Keyhole [248]
A hole matching the shape of the rotating pin A hole left by the retraction of the rotating pin
Flash [251]
Excessive overﬂow of materials on top surface
leaving a corrugated or ribbonlike e ﬀect
along the RS or AS
Excessive forge load or plunge depth;
Excessively hot weld; Smaller shoulder
diameter
Tunnel [255]
Internal cavity along the welding direction Insu ﬃcient material ﬂow; Improper welding
tool; Over ﬂow of materials;Smaller plunge
depth
Weld thinning [214]
The thickness of NZ is lower than that of the
BM
Larger plunge depth; Over ﬂow of materials;
Improper back support
Groove [213]
A continuous dented surface characterized by
insuﬃcient ﬁll with plasticized materials
Insuﬃcient material ﬂow; Improper back
support; Insuﬃcient forge pressure; Over ﬂow of
materials
Cavity [160]
Incomplete joining induced by insu ﬃcient
consolidated and forged materials at the RS
Lower heat input; Excessive travel speed;
Insuﬃcient material ﬂow; Improper welding
tool
Lack of ro

## B0148 · 第47页 · 清洗文本字符2401–2620

ot penetration
[162]
Incomplete joining at the back area of butt
plate
Shorter pin length; Smaller plunge depth;Larger
ﬁtting gap or manufacturing errors
X. Meng, et al.
Progress in Materials Science 115 (2021) 100706
47

## B0149 · 第48页 · 清洗文本字符1–1200

Table 8
Research progress in FSR of materials with main defects and their repairing techniques.
Materials T (mm) Type of defects Repairing methods Optimum parameters Maximum tensile strength/
load
Ref.
Al-Cu alloy 3 Shrinkage Repetitive FSR w = 900 rpm; v = 150 mm/min; PD = 0.1 mm; T = 2.5° 301.6 MPa [262]
Al-Zn-Mg alloy 6 Tunnel Repetitive FSR w = 800 rpm; v = 300 mm/min; F = 9 kN 207.4 MPa [263]
304L steel 12 Cavity (gap) FSR w = 250 rpm; v = 100 mm/min [264]
AA6061-T6 3.2 Flashes Friction stir spot welding w = 3000 rpm; v = 0.2 mm/s; DT = 0.5 s 4678 N [251]
AA2219-T87 6 Kissing bond Repetitive FSR w = 600 rpm; v = 200 mm/min; PD = 0.2 mm; T = 3° 248 MPa [265]
AA2219-T87 6 Cavity Repetitive FSR w = 800 rpm; v = 400 mm/min; PD = 0.3 mm; T = 3° 235 MPa [265]
AA2219-T6 7 Groove O ﬀset FSR w = 600 rpm; v = 200 mm/min; F = 4.6 kN; T = 2.5° 335 MPa [266]
AA2219-T6 7.5 Groove Gas tungsten arc welding (GTAW) + FSW GTAW: I = 200 A; v = 120 mm/min
FSW: w = 600 rpm; v = 200 mm/min; F = 4.6 kN; T = 2.5°
305 BM [267]
AA6061-T6 4 Gap Vertical compensation FSW (VCFSW) w = 2000 rpm; v = 50 mm/min; P = 0.1 mm; T = 2.5° 214 MPa [213]
AA7N01-T4 4 Gap VCFSW w = 2000 rpm; v = 50 mm/min; P = 0.1 mm; T

## B0150 · 第48页 · 清洗文本字符1201–2400

 = 2.5° 295.7 [268]
AA2024/AA7075 3.5 Gap VCFSW w = 2000 rpm; v = 20 mm/min; P = 0.2 mm; T = 2.5°; FD = 1.5 mm 307.2 MPa [269]
AA2219-T6 7.8 Keyhole Filling friction stir welding (FFSW) FFSW: w = 800 rpm; PD = 0.1 mm; T = 2.5°
FSP: w = 800 rpm; v = 200 mm/min; PD = 0.1 mm; T = 2.5°
179.6 MPa [270]
AA2219-T87 10 Through hole Friction plug welding (FPW) w = 7500 rpm; AF = 50 kN; F = 60 kN; Push amount = 5 mm; FT = 5 s 329 MPa [271]
AA2195-T8 6.35 Through hole FPW w = 4250 rpm; A style plug with a shank diameter of 19.1 mm 342 MPa [272]
AA5456 7.5 Keyhole FFSW w = 400 rpm; v = 50 mm/min 91% of defect joint [273]
316L steel 10 Keyhole FFSW FFSW: w = 1500 rpm; F = 35 kN; DT = 9 s 92% of BM [274]
316L steel 10 Keyhole Self-re ﬁlling FSW SRFSW1-4: w = 1200 rpm; F = 30 kN; DT = 5 s;
SRFSW5-8: w = 1500 rpm; F = 30 kN; DT = 5 s;
643 MPa [275]
API X52 steel 16 Blind hole Friction taper plug welding (FTPW) w = 7500 rpm; F = 35 kN; FT = 5 s; F = 40 kN Equal to BM [276]
API 5L X65 steel 30 Blind hole FTPW w = 7000 rpm; F = 50 kN; FT = 5 s; F = 40 kN; B = 14 mm Equal to BM [277]
CuNi 70/30 3.13 Corrosion hole Repetitive FSR w = 1200 rpm; v = 12.7 mm/min; T = 3° 339.4 MPa [278]
AZ31B 4 Keyhole Act

## B0151 · 第48页 · 清洗文本字符2401–3400

ive-passive ﬁlling friction stir repairing (A-
PFFSR)
w = 1300 rpm; v = 1 mm/min; T = 2.5°; DT = 5 s 189.7 MPa [243]
AA7N01-T4 4 Keyhole A-PFFSR w = 1600 rpm; v = 2 mm/min; T = 2.5°; DT = 5 s 311.1 MPa [279]
AZ31B
1.5 Circular hole Drilling- ﬁlling FSR (DFFSR) w = 1600 rpm; T = 2.5°; DT = 20 s; PD = 0.4 mm 217 MPa [280,281]
AA6061-T6 4.8 Through hole Reﬁ ll friction stir spot welding (RFSSW) w = 2290 rpm; PS = 1.93 mm/s; F = 16 kN 213 MPa [282]
AA2198–T851 3 Through hole RFSSW w = 1000 rpm; PS = 0.85 mm/s; PD = 2.9 mm 78% [283]
AA7075-T761 6 Through hole RFSSW w = 1500 –2100 rpm; PS = 0.7 –1 mm/s; DT = 2, 4, and 6 s 425 MPa [284]
Note: Thickness: T (mm); Rotational velocity: w (rpm); Welding speed: v (mm/min); Plunge depth: PD (mm); Forging force: F (kN); Tilt angle: T (°); Dwelling time: DT (s); Current: I (A); Filler width: FD
(mm); Axial force: AF (kN); Forging time: FT (s); Plunge speed: PS (mm/s); Burn-o ﬀ: B (mm).
X. Meng, et al. Progress in Materials Science 115 (2021) 100706
48

## B0152 · 第49页 · 清洗文本字符1–1200

5.3. Repetitive friction stir remanufacturing
The global defects mainly contain surface peeling, grooves, tunnels, kissing bond, lack of root penetration, surface damage and
long cracks induced by the exogenous source. The above defects always appear along a certain direction, curve and depth, which are
primarily repaired by repetitive friction stir remanufacturing technologies.
A concept of combining friction stir spot welding and end milling was proposed to remove ﬂashes simultaneously. The removal
process of ﬂashes in general has little e ﬀect on the mechanical properties of friction stir spot welds, except under very low indentation
rates [251]. Li et al. [263] employed repetitive FSW to reduce or eliminate the tunnel defect of Al-Zn-Mg alloy FSW joints and then
avoided the stress concentrations, in which the grain size in the repaired region was reduced compared with that in the original NZ.
The maximum tensile strength of the repaired joint reached 180.2% higher than that of the original joint with the tunnel defects.
Zhou et al. [265] also used repetitive FSW to repair the lack of root penetration and cavity defects in AA2219-T87 FSW joints. To
repair the surface groove and 

## B0153 · 第49页 · 清洗文本字符1201–2400

tunnel defects, Liu et al. [266] proposed o ﬀset FSW to eliminate groove defects in 7.5-mm-thick
AA2219 FSW joints, and the o ﬀset was used so that the repairing pin was at the location of the defect rather than at the welding
centreline. They stated that the o ﬀset FSR could e ﬀectively eliminate the cavity defect and an obvious aggregation of the hard-brittle
phase Al 2Cu associated with the symmetrical FSR, as shown in Fig. 65 . A high-quality joint repaired by o ﬀset FSR with a tensile
strength of 335 MPa was achieved and fractured near the interface between the NZ and the TMAZ, presenting ductile fracture
characterized by large dimples. Subsequently, Liu et al. [267] employed tungsten inert gas welding (TIG) and FSW to remove large
groove defects that cannot be eliminated by repetitive FSW, in which a high tensile strength equivalent to 70% of that of the BM was
achieved and the fracture feature of the repaired joint was partially plastic and partially brittle. Arici et al. [194,195] expounded that
the lack of root penetration induced by the low thermal conductivity of medium-density polyethylene (MDPE) was eliminated by
double-pass FSW, whereas weld thinning was increased. Sa

## B0154 · 第49页 · 清洗文本字符2401–3600

eedy et al. [285] also repaired the lack of root penetration of FSWed HDPE
joints by double-pass FSW and then stated that its joint strength was twice that achieved by single-pass FSW. Cabibbo et al. [286]
welded AA6082 sheets by double-pass FSW to eliminate kissing bond, in which the second pass was performed on the other side of
the sheets. Compared to conventional FSW, the grains and precipitates in the TMAZ of double-pass FSW joints were coarser due to a
twice overlapping heat input, thereby leading to poor tensile properties. Although double-pass FSW can solve the lack of root
penetration, the surface formation is poor, and weld thinning is serious. Furthermore, the welding process still needs to be further
optimized. Widener et al. [287] demonstrated that SSFSW
2 with a high rotational velocity can be performed in thin-gauge Al alloys
with relatively low process forces, making smaller portable devices possible for repairing applications and achieving high-quality
repaired joints without weld thinning.
In addition, when the welding or exogenous defects are relatively large, they easily result in the loss of extremely mass materials,
such as large tunnel and groove defects and 

## B0155 · 第49页 · 清洗文本字符3601–4800

gap defects induced by either the extrusion e ﬀect during the FSW process or the
accumulation of some manufacturing errors of large structures that are mismatched. Introducing additional ﬁlling materials into
these locations is extremely essential. Ji et al. [213,268,288] proposed VCFSW technique to repair these defects and then selected the
gap defect as the main research object, as shown in Fig. 66 . Additional compensation materials were added to these defects, which
were homogeneous materials similar to the workpieces to be repaired. During VCFSW, the rotating tool simultaneously rotated,
stirred and mixed the welding workpieces and the compensation materials, realizing high-strength solid-state repairing of defects
with large sizes for 6061-T6 and 7 N01 Al alloys, respectively. Moreover, they expounded that employing materials with low melting
points and high strength easily achieved high arrangement repairing of materials with high melting points, such as the workpieces to
Fig. 65. Morphologies of the initial joints with groove defects and their repaired joints: (a) initial, (b) o ﬀset FSR and (c) symmetrical FSR joints [42].
X. Meng, et al. Progress in Materials Science 115 

## B0156 · 第49页 · 清洗文本字符4801–4816

(2021) 100706
49

## B0157 · 第50页 · 清洗文本字符1–1123

be welded AA6061-T6 and the compensation materials AA2024-T4 [213]. Two vortex-like structures appeared in the SAZ and PAZ,
which was similar to the “onion ring” pattern reported in the literature [289]. The forming mechanism of “onion ring” patterns was
formed due to loads from both the external and the internal screws at each rotation [290–292]. The formation of the “onion ring ”
pattern markedly improved the mechanical interlocking and metallurgical bonding, enhancing the mechanical properties. Abu-Okail
et al. [269] stated that the quality of the joints welded by VCFSW depended on the ability of compensation materials to ﬁll in and mix
with the BM through VCFSW. Sandnes et al. [221] used the HYB process to eliminate the insu ﬃcient material feeding induced by the
lack of ﬁller materials when strict base plate and pro ﬁle tolerances were required.
Fig. 66. Schematic of VCFSW [213].
Fig. 67. Keyhole closure technique of TIG ﬁller wire welding with subsequent FSP: (a) TIG ﬁller wire welding, (b) FSP and (c) completion of keyhole
repairing.
X. Meng, et al. Progress in Materials Science 115 (2021) 100706
50

## B0158 · 第51页 · 清洗文本字符1–1200

To eliminate the potential defects and severe joint softening induced by conventional fusion welding and the back-supported body
that is needed in additive ﬁlling FSW, a hybrid between TIG welding and pinless FSP is proposed by our workgroup, as shown in
Fig. 67. TIG welding is responsible for the weld reinforcement in the welding line, eliminating possible defects at the ending stage.
Here, a “multi-strand welding wire ” technique is used, and the shape and performance control of the ﬁlling joints can be realized by
several factors, including the composition design, diameter selection, and wire assembly modes. Subsequently, a pinless tool with a
special shoulder morphology and diameter is used to modify the microstructure produced by TIG welding, which transforms the
coarse casting microstructures into ﬁne and equiaxed forging microstructures, eliminating fusion defects and strengthening the
repaired joints. Additionally, by regulating the shoulder topology (shoulder diameter, morphology and angle) and processing
parameters (plunge depth/force, rotational velocity, processing speed and tilt angle), the microstructures and mechanical properties
can be optimized, which realize the e

## B0159 · 第51页 · 清洗文本字符1201–2400

xcellent repairing of volume defects.
For materials that have higher melting points than Al alloys, few studies exist due to the high cost and wear of the rotating tool.
Mukherjee and Ghosh [278] combined laser-assisted direct metal deposition with FSW to repair corrosion holes in a CuNi 70/30
alloy. This additive FSW process allowed for site-speci ﬁc ﬁlling and repairing of the harmful features in laser-assisted direct metal
deposition microstructures, including porosity, large grain size, residual stress and solute segregation. Gunter et al. [264] employed
FSW to repair crack defects in 304L stainless steel using a PCBN/W-Re tool, as shown in Fig. 68. Through this process, it was possible
to heal a crack that began narrow and then progressively grew up to a width of 2 mm.
During FSW, the material intersecting the path of the pin deformed in a similar manner. As the pin approached, the materials were
initially compressed, rotated around the pin, and ﬁnally deposited behind the pin at the same transverse position as its beginning
(Fig. 69 ). The typical microstructural evolution of stainless steel during the deformation process could be presented through a
microstructural analysis 

## B0160 · 第51页 · 清洗文本字符2401–3600

along the centre of the weld path. The ﬁnal microstructure in the NZ was a result of DRX and some grain
growth. FSW of 304L stainless steel resulted in similar levels of dislocation density, as shown in Fig. 70 .
For the solid-state repairing methods, the materials around the repairing interfaces experienced severe thermo-mechanical be-
haviours, which further resulted in the formation of chemical and mechanical bonds at the repairing interfaces. The microstructural
evolution and interfacial behaviour signi ﬁcantly in ﬂuenced the mechanical properties. The macrostructure of the FSW welds was
closely related to the workpiece materials, tool design, and o ﬀset, as well as welding variables and setup. Good metallurgical bonding
may reduce the presence of defects at the repairing interface, while complex mechanical bonding promotes better stress distribution
during loading and a more complex crack propagation path [294].
Investigating the interfacial microstructures and healing of the repairing interfaces can provide important references and tech-
nical support for the regulation and control of mechanical properties. Current knowledge on the interface characteristics and mi-
crostructu

## B0161 · 第51页 · 清洗文本字符3601–4800

ral evolution of the repaired joint is presented in this section. During the FSR process, the materials in the repairing zone
always experienced high peak temperatures and high strain rates, and then DRX occurred, which further resulted in grain re ﬁnement
or phase transformation. Moreover, severe plastic deformation can improve the mechanical mixing between the ﬁlling materials and
the workpieces. Ji et al. [262] stated that the casting structure in Al-Cu casting alloy was transformed into ﬁne and equiaxed grains
due to DRX, thereby improving mechanical properties.
The main aim behind solid-state repairing is to improve the mechanical properties, corrosion and wear resistance of joints. The
mechanical properties mainly include microhardness, tensile strength, yield strength and elongation in addition to impact and fatigue
strength. Various strengthening mechanisms contribute to the enhancement of mechanical properties. Parameter optimization and
optimal welding setup are essential to produce high-quality repaired joints. Estimation of the microhardness of the repaired joints
requires the consideration of contrary parameters, which further in ﬂuences the tensile properties. On the 

## B0162 · 第51页 · 清洗文本字符4801–5329

one hand, severe plastic
deformation reﬁnes the grain size and then increases the microhardness according to the Hall-Petch relation. On the other hand, high
temperatures easily result in annealing of materials [296]. Dislocation density and residual compressive stress are decreased in the
annealed materials, leading to a reduction in microhardness. The grain re ﬁnement e ﬀect dominates the annealing e ﬀect [297].
Fig. 68. FSR tool (70% PCBN/30% W-Re) [264].
X. Meng, et al. Progress in Materials Science 115 (2021) 100706
51

## B0163 · 第52页 · 清洗文本字符1–1200

Consequently, the grains are re ﬁned during FSR, which increases the microhardness values. Moreover, second-phase particle
strengthening is another main factor besides grain re ﬁnement contribution. It can be concluded that strengthening is a combined
eﬀect of grain re ﬁnement and strengthening phases [298]. For Al alloys and interstitial-free (IF) steel, the Hall-Petch relationship ﬁt
the data quite well. For commercially pure Ti, the relationship breaks down when the grain sizes are smaller than 6.4 μm, wherein the
measured microhardness is higher than that predicted by the Hall-Petch relationship. The lack of correlation to the Hall-Petch e ﬀect
for ﬁne Ti grains was attributed to the high dislocation density within the grains.
5.4. Additive friction stir remanufacturing
For local volume defects, such as keyhole, cavity and pitting defects, digging and geometrization are the essential procedures due
to the irregular distribution inside the parts, in which the loss of materials can be compensated by ﬁlling additional materials. In
recent years, a series of friction stir-based closure techniques are reported that attempt to transfer the advantages of FSR to closure
methods of volu

## B0164 · 第52页 · 清洗文本字符1201–2400

me defects. Additive FSR techniques mainly consist of FPW, FTPW, FFSW, and progressive FSW.
5.4.1. Friction plug welding
FPW is proposed to repair keyhole defects, which has been widely reported by relevant researchers. FPW is primarily used by TWI
[299] and NASA Marshall Space Flight Center [300,301]. In this process, a taper plug is coaxially forced into a keyhole that has a
similar taper. The keyhole is ﬁlled with the taper plug by the friction between the taper plug and the surface of the hole. For the FPW
joints, post machining is essential to remove the redundant materials of the plug and the materials that ﬂow out of the weld.
According to the load pressure, FPW is divided into friction push plug welding and friction pull plug welding, as shown in Fig. 71
[42].
Friction push plug welding was ﬁrst introduced by Lockheed Martin to repair the defects of AA2195 FSW joints in 1995, replacing
manual TIG welding. Subsequently, Lockheed Martin, TWI and NASA optimized the welding parameters for a more robust process
[300–302]. Friction push plug welding has become an e ﬀective repairing method in rocket tanks. During welding, excessive force on
the taper plug pushes the plug into the

## B0165 · 第52页 · 清洗文本字符2401–3600

 hole, forming a compact joint. Friction push plug welding has many advantages characterized
by (1) a plug unit located in front of the workpieces and withdrawing compressive stress and (2) a wide process window, high
welding stability and quali ﬁed welding rate. This method is unsuitable for enclosed structures because the rigid backing plate has to
withstand a great welding force. The published references have reported that a larger plug diameter in relation to the hole diameter is
much more eﬀective in repairing defects. The main process parameters a ﬀecting the friction push plug welding process and its welded
joints are rotational velocity, axial force, forging force, push amount, forging time and plug morphology. A tapered plug can make the
ﬂow direction change instantly from the upper surface to the lower surface of the sheet. Metz et al. [272,303] studied the micro-
structures, hardness and fatigue properties of 2195-T8 FPW welds. A typical weld can be classi ﬁed into six regions ( Fig. 72): plug
metal, plug thermo-mechanically a ﬀected zone, plug recrystallized zone (PRZ), TMAZ, HAZ and BM. The hardness variations in these
zones may control the fatigue behaviour of the joi

## B0166 · 第52页 · 清洗文本字符3601–4323

nts. The TMAZ that is close to the bonding interface is the weakest location of the
joint due to the dissolution of precipitates and the redistribution of constituent particles. The repaired joints sustained reductions in
both the tensile properties and the fatigue life when compared with the FSW joints. The reduction in fatigue life is most likely due to
the complication of the weld geometry, the interacting HAZ and the strength mismatch between the BM, the FSW joint and the plug
Fig. 69. Pin-driven material ﬂow around the tool: (a) schematic of FSP performed on crack-free stainless steel and (b) schematic of FSP performed
along a crack [264,293].
X. Meng, et al. Progress in Materials Science 115 (2021) 100706
52

## B0167 · 第53页 · 清洗文本字符1–784

materials [272].
Michael Lange et al. [305] studied the bending, tensile and thermal characterization of AA2024-T3 plug welds. Defect-free joints
were successfully achieved with optimized parameters. At the beginning of the tensile stress application (t ≤ 20 s), the joint was
under the elastic deformation stage, exhibiting uniform elastic strain across the plug joint ( Fig. 73).
When the global strain reached 0.18% (t = 35 s), the strain concentration could be examined initially near the TMAZ. A slight
plastic deformation occurred in the HAZ but was not obvious in the BM. With conducting the tensile process, the stress showed a fast
Fig. 70. Grain structure evolution in 304L stainless steel during FSW [295].
X. Meng, et al. Progress in Materials Science 115 (2021) 100706
53

## B0168 · 第54页 · 清洗文本字符1–1162

and linear increase accompanied by a slow extension of the plastic deformation zone. When the global strain reached 0.86%, yield
occurred in the joint with necking. When the global strain reached 5.08%, the joint fractured with a local strain of 6.8% in the TMAZ.
By optimizing the design of joint geometry, the maximum tensile strength of the repaired joint of AA2219-T87 reached 329 MPa,
which is approximately 72.3% of that of the BM [271].
Friction pull plug welding was proposed and patented by Paula Hartley and Riki Takeshita from Lockheed Martin [42]. It was
originally received as a key technique for the external tank of the space shuttle and the keyhole in BT-FSW [307], as indicated in
Fig. 74 [308] . The welding equipment of friction pull plug welding is located on one side of the workpieces, which requires a simple
ﬁxture without rigid backing plates, indicating that friction pull plug welding is more suitable for enclosed complicated structures
Fig. 71. Schematics of FPW: (a) friction push plug welding and (b) friction pull plug welding [42].
Fig. 72. A typical weld [304].
X. Meng, et al. Progress in Materials Science 115 (2021) 100706
54

## B0169 · 第55页 · 清洗文本字符1–1200

than friction push plug welding. The narrower process window in the friction push plug welding results in lower joint quality and less
welding stability than that in the friction push plug welding. The friction pull plug welding process was applied to 4-mm-thick
AA2219. By appropriate selection of the welding parameters and joint con ﬁguration, the tensile strength reached 330 MPa or above,
which was equal to or even greater than that of the FSW joints.
5.4.2. Friction taper plug welding
As a new and promising solid-state repairing technique, FTPW was proposed and has been widely investigated, which has the
feasibility and potential to repair underwater metal structures, pipes and thick section materials or seam thick plates or components
[309,310]. Pauly and Nicholas [311,312] deﬁned that FTPW was a hole ﬁlling process that involved drilling a blind hole and then
forcing a consumable plug into the hole coaxially, similar to FPW. A schematic of the FTPW process is shown in Fig. 75. Synergistic
eﬀects between frictional heat and forging force led to the plug materials to be softened and ﬂow continuously, and then the blind
hole could be ﬁlled. After completing the plug consumption p

## B0170 · 第55页 · 清洗文本字符1201–1957

rocess, another axial forging force was applied immediately to forge the
materials in the weld [313]. FTPW joints were mostly fabricated in underwater wet conditions, and the repairing interfaces exhibit
as-forged microstructures without hydrogen-induced cold cracks [314–316]. Characteristics of the basic welding parameters have
been described in previous investigations and are reviewed in Meyer and Ambroziak ’s works [317,318].
Thorough insight into material ﬂow and heat generation in di ﬀerent welding conditions is of practical importance for the
Fig. 73. Strain maps of a plug joint at di ﬀerent times during a tensile test [306].
Fig. 74. Friction pull plug weld operations [308].
X. Meng, et al. Progress in Materials Science 115 (2021) 100706
55

## B0171 · 第56页 · 清洗文本字符1–1200

comprehension and elimination of welding defects. Yin et al. [277] showed the typical plug material ﬂow behaviour with the
variation in weld torque during the FTPW process, which contained a heat-dominated phase (HDP), heat-shear transition phase
(HSTP) and shear dominated phase (SDP), as shown in Fig. 76. The HDP was deﬁ ned as the time between the start of the weld and the
point where substantial plastic shear occurred, which resulted in a substantial drop in peak torque. In the SDP, the torque stabilized at
a considerably lower plateau level for the remainder of the weld. Under the severe heat dissipation caused by both cold workpieces
and the water environment, a stable temperature ﬁeld and heat input could hardly be established. The plug material ﬂow was not
suﬃcient to ﬁll the hole, further forming e ﬀective bonding with the hole sidewall. Nevertheless, at the end of HDP, a certain amount
of plasticized material accumulated at the plug frictional plane and pressed to the gap between the plug and BM at the start of HSTP.
This “pressing behaviour” was reﬂected by the drop in weld torque and demonstrated by the Ni tracer since a signi ﬁcant amount of Ni
was removed from the cent

## B0172 · 第56页 · 清洗文本字符1201–2400

re over a relatively larger area, especially under higher axial force. As the SDP began, a regular plug
consumption process that was dominated by regular shear o ﬀ of the plug and deposition was established. The weld torque was
maintained at a quasi-stable level that was smaller than that in the other phases. Considering the severe heat dissipation and poor
material ﬂow at the HDP and HSTP, increasing material ﬂow and the heat input during both phases was believed to be practical to
eliminate root defects. Moreover, the material ﬂow in the SDP was uniform and extensive. This should be the reason why incomplete
ﬁlling defects never occur at the sidewall when the axial force is su ﬃcient (higher than 20 kN).
The main process parameters a ﬀecting the FTPW process and its welded joints are rotational velocity, axial force, forging force,
push amount, forging time, burn-o ﬀ and plug morphology. Meyer and co-workers [317] found that the bonding qualities and
properties of FTPW welds were signi ﬁcantly in ﬂuenced by the weld geometry, rotational velocity, and axial force. However, the
inﬂuences of the forging force and forging time were less substantial. Hattingh et al. [316] found that f

## B0173 · 第56页 · 清洗文本字符2401–3017

or AISI 4140 steel, a maximum
tensile strength of 94% of that of the BM could be obtained with the following parameter combination: 6000 rpm rotational velocity,
11.7 kN axial force and 9.0 mm burn-o ﬀ. The measured tensile strength and ductility were nearly equivalent to those of the BM owing
to the overmatching of the welds. In Charpy impact tests, the properties would match the requirements of the standard for marine
Fig. 75. Schematic of the FTPW process [319].
Fig. 76. Relationship between material ﬂow behaviour and torque variation [277].
X. Meng, et al. Progress in Materials Science 115 (2021) 100706
56

## B0174 · 第57页 · 清洗文本字符1–1200

applications [317]. Chludzinski et al. [320] found that the fracture toughness of the weld was much lower than that of the BM. The
varied axial forces could rarely in ﬂuence the fracture toughness. Cui et al. [321] determined that a lack of bonding and incomplete
ﬁlling defects were found, which easily formed under the combination of low rotational velocity and low welding force. High-quality
joints were obtained at rotational velocities up to 7000 rpm and welding forces ranging from 25 to 40 kN. It can be concluded that
superior FTPW joints can be achieved by regulating and controlling the welding parameters. A high rotational velocity and a larger
axial force than conventional FSW are necessary.
5.4.3. Filling friction stir welding
Huang et al. [248,270,322] proposed FFSW to repair similar keyhole volume defects, as shown in Fig. 77. The FFSW process was
performed in three main steps: friction stage, stirring stage, and joining stage. First, the FFSW depends on a friction process, where a
semi-consumable bit contacts the wall of the keyhole, rubs against the inner surface of the keyhole and self-cleans the bonding
surfaces (removal of oxidation). Second, a stirring step, where th

## B0175 · 第57页 · 清洗文本字符1201–2400

e semi-consumable bit is plunged into the keyhole and the rotating
shoulder made of steel contacts the upper surface of the workpieces, generates frictional heating at the interface between the bit and
the wall of the keyhole. The materials surrounding the keyhole and the bit are plasticized and stirred, while severe plastic de-
formation and ﬂow of the plasticized materials occur. The joining step follows, while the bit and the materials surrounding the
keyhole are heated by frictional heat. With the combined functions of softening and torque, the joining bit is sheared and fractured at
the corner of the shoulder, becoming the ﬁller material to repair the keyhole.
Figs. 78 and 79 show detailed images of the FFSW tool and joints. The welding tool is composed of a semi-consumable bit and a
steel shoulder ( Fig. 78).
The keyhole defect can be successfully ﬁlled (Fig. 79). In the following FSP, a non-consumable tool consisting of a pinless shoulder
provides mechanical mixing and plastic deformation. Moreover, the ﬂash around the ﬁlled keyhole was abraded and stirred. The
semi-consumable bit and materials surrounding the keyhole have been metallurgically bonded very well. A classical f

## B0176 · 第57页 · 清洗文本字符2401–3600

ormation of the
elliptical ‘‘onion ring ’’ structure parallel to the interface formed in the transition between the ﬁlling zone (FZ) and the TMAZ [248].
Mechanical interlocking is also the main bonding mechanism in dissimilar FSW joints that rely on forming a complicated geometry at
the bonding interface to enhance mechanical strength. During the FFSW process, as the bit keeps inserting downward into the
keyhole, the bit head begins to contact the zigzag structures on the keyhole surface. Material deformation and ﬁerce attrition
occurred at the contact region. Additionally, some of the super ﬁcial bit materials were stripped o ﬀ and fell down into the bottom of
the keyhole, resulting from the relatively lower hardness (96 HV) and the keyhole friction. As a result of the features of the FFSW tool,
the materials at the bottom of the FZ experienced relatively gentle stirring and insu ﬃcient heating, especially compared with the NZ,
and defects such as cavities and ﬂaws are easily formed at the interlayer or interface between two adjacent layers. These problems can
be solved by regulating and controlling the welding parameters in the FFSW.
The main process parameters in the FFSW proces

## B0177 · 第57页 · 清洗文本字符3601–4800

s are rotational velocity, plunge speed and bit conicity degree for semi-con-
sumable bits, though other variables such as welding speed, shoulder diameter, tilt angle, deep indentation depth for the rotating
shoulder, and plate conditions may also in ﬂuence the repair quality. The length of the bit should be 2 –5 mm higher than the depth of
the keyhole, which can guarantee su ﬃcient ﬁlling of the keyhole. The bit conicity degree is always lower than that of the keyhole
defects. Behmand et al. [273] discussed that an unsuitable geometry caused incorrect contact at the pin/exit hole faying surface,
while su ﬃcient friction and stirring were not attained. A low plunge speed is bene ﬁcial to su ﬃcient plastic deformation at the
repairing interface and improves metallurgical bonding. Moreover, the harder the semi-consumable bit is, the more severe the plastic
deformation in the repairing interface and the higher the joint quality. Huang et al. [322] reported that when employing an AA2219
bit to repair the keyhole defect in AA2219 FSW joints, the average ultimate tensile strength and elongation were 172 MPa and
11.22%,
which corresponded to 90% and 82% of those of the base weld without 

## B0178 · 第57页 · 清洗文本字符4801–5525

defects, respectively. Huang et al. [248,270] also
repaired the keyhole defect of AA2219-T6 FSW joints by choosing an AA7075-T6 bit whose hardness was higher than the workpieces
to be repaired. The maximum ultimate tensile strength and elongation of the FFSW joint were 179.6 MPa and 13.7%, which cor-
responded to 96.6% and 99% of those of the original defect-free FSW joint, respectively [248]. Behmand et al. [273] applied FFSW to
repair a 6.5-mm-deep exit hole in AA5456 FSW lap joints. The failure load on the coupons with the re ﬁlled keyhole reached 91% of
Fig. 77. Schematics of FFSW: (a) plunging stage, (b) repairing stage and (c) retreating stage.
X. Meng, et al. Progress in Materials Science 115 (2021) 100706
57

## B0179 · 第58页 · 清洗文本字符1–1200

that of a corresponding defect-free FSW joint. It can be concluded that quasi-equivalent mechanical performances without weld
defects have been achieved by the FFSW joints with excellent interface and mechanical properties. Based on the technical advantage
of FFSW, Yan et al. [323] successfully joined ABS sheets and stated that high joint strength was achieved when using a large plug
diameter, a moderate plug length and a blind hole depth. In contrast, spot welds with small plug diameters, excessive plug lengths or
large blind hole depths exhibited pores and cavities in the vicinity of the joining interface.
Zhou et al. [274] reported that void defects were formed at the bottom of the re ﬁlled original conical keyholes for all the tool
design and process parameters used for 316L stainless steel. A re ﬁlled joint with a defect-free interface could be obtained on the
modiﬁed spherical keyhole using the corresponding ﬁlling tool under processing parameters of 35 kN, 1500 rpm and 9 s. The
microstructures surrounding the interface and in the re ﬁlled zone were signi ﬁcantly re ﬁned for all the re ﬁlled joints. Tensile test
results showed that the tensile specimen fractured at the BM. Th

## B0180 · 第58页 · 清洗文本字符1201–1602

e relative tensile strength and elongation were 105% and 92% of
Fig. 78. Features of the FFSW tool: (a) steel shoulder, (b) AA7075 bit and (c) assembled semi-consumable FFSW tool [248].
Fig. 79. Detailed images of FFSW: (a) keyhole defects, (b) repaired keyhole, (c) repaired keyhole after FSP and (d) repaired keyhole after SFE [248].
X. Meng, et al. Progress in Materials Science 115 (2021) 100706
58

## B0181 · 第59页 · 清洗文本字符1–1200

those of the as-received plate, respectively. Zhang et al. [324] modiﬁed the FFSW method using a pinless tool and a T-shaped ﬁller bit
to reduce the setup time for replacement of the tool between the ﬁlling and reprocessing operations. For a cylindrical bit, the failure
loads were sensitive to the in-situ friction time. When the in-situ friction time exceeded 5 s, the ﬁlled samples exhibited favourable
failure loads. They sealed keyholes left by FSW in 4.7-mm-thick AA1060 sheets. To eliminate voids in the lower portion of the joint, a
Zn brazing foil was preset in the keyhole. The ultimate tensile strength of the keyhole closure welds reached 67.3% of the BM strength
[324]. Until now, FFSW has been shown to repair keyholes left by a conical FSW tool, for which the geometry of the ﬁller bit must be
adapted and has not yet been applied to through holes. Moreover, FFSW is still in its infancy, and further investigations are necessary
for its evaluation and application in manufacturing ﬁelds.
For dissimilar materials without metallurgical reactions, our research group proposed friction-based ﬁlling stacking joining
(FFSJ), which is similar to the principle of FFSW, to ﬁll the keyholes 

## B0182 · 第59页 · 清洗文本字符1201–2400

of polymer and metal FSLW joints, as shown in Fig. 80 [325]. The
FFSJ was completed by ﬁlling a prefabricated hole with an additional ﬁlling stud. An excellent FFSJ joint was successfully achieved
under the combined e ﬀects of frictional heat and thermo-mechanical behaviour at the interface between the ﬁlling stud and the
polymer sheet. Intimate contact formed at the interface between the ﬁlling stud, the polymer and the metal, and the metal hole was
completely ﬁlled with the stud. The maximum tensile shear strength of 13 MPa for the FFSJ was comparable to that produced by
state-of-the-art welding. The fracture location of the FFSJ joint is located at the joining interface between the ﬁlling stud and the re-
solidiﬁed polymer sheet.
5.4.4. Progressive friction stir welding
Progressive FSW is di ﬀerent from the other ﬁlling FSW methods employing a consumable bit, whose principle is that the materials
surrounding the keyhole are used to ﬁll the volume defects and reduce the depth of the keyhole. To improve the ﬁlling of the volume
defect completely, an additional ﬁlling piece is necessary.
Pinless FSW is a solid-state joining technique based on the material transfer induced by severe

## B0183 · 第59页 · 清洗文本字符2401–3326

 plastic deformation that can realize
the high-quality joining of thin sheets lower than 2 mm [326–328]. Based on the concept of friction-induced plastic ﬂow, the keyhole
of FSW joints in thin-walled sheets could be repaired. The main factors a ﬀecting the joint strength are shoulder morphology,
Fig. 80. Schematic of the FFSJ process: (a) positioning of the ﬁlling stud in the prefabricated hole; (b) rotation and plunge of the rotating tool and
the ﬁlling stud; (c) the ﬁlling stud approaches the polymer sheet while the ﬁlling stud and polymer sheet are melted near the joining interface; (d)
the rotating tool stops plunging and continues rotating for 1 s, then the tool stops rotating and the molten polymer begins to solidify; (e) the rotating
tool retracts and the molten polymer continues to solidify; and (f) the hybrid FFSJ joint is achieved [325].
X. Meng, et al. Progress in Materials Science 115 (2021) 100706
59

## B0184 · 第60页 · 清洗文本字符1–1200

rotational velocity, plunge depth and dwelling time. Venukumar et al. [329] reported that a convex shoulder tool was better than a
concave shoulder tool due to the complete elimination of insu ﬃcient reﬁlling. Sajet et al. [330] reported that rotational velocity has
the strongest e ﬀect on welding strength. Dwelling time has a minimum e ﬀect on the strength and maximum displacement of con-
ventional joints and nearly no e ﬀect on re ﬁlled joints. The order of importance for parameters that a ﬀect conventional joints is
rotational velocity > tool plunge depth > dwelling time. Huang et al. [280] proposed a DFFSR technique to repair the volume
defects in lightweight AZ31B Mg alloy with an additional ﬁlling plug and a pinless tool. An optimized joint with a maximum tensile
strength of 217 MPa was produced, which fractured at the TMAZ rather than at the interface between the ﬁller and the BM. Niu et al.
[281] employed a non-rotating shoulder to assist the PFFSR and then obtained a uniform microhardness distribution along the whole
repaired region. However, the e ﬀective depth of the pinless FSW is limited to 2 mm or even smaller.
Self-reﬁlling friction stir welding (SRFSW) was proposed 

## B0185 · 第60页 · 清洗文本字符1201–2400

by Zhou et al. [275] to seal the keyhole left by FSW in stainless steel, as
shown in Fig. 81 . This multistage process used a series of non-consumable tools with gradual changes in pin geometry and size.
Similar to the results of Ji et al. [243], based on the constancy of the material volume, a narrow and deep keyhole was ﬁlled and
changed to a wide and shallow exit hole remaining at the surface due to the lack of ﬁller materials. SRFSW is not applicable to
through holes and has not been veri ﬁed to work in Al alloys. This approach can also avoid preparing a speci ﬁc tapered through hole
in a plate, such as that required in the FPW/FTPW processes, thereby providing better adaptability for the actual working conditions.
Based on the advantages of SRFSW [275] and pinless FSW [280], Ji et al. [243,279] proposed the A-PFFSR method to ﬁll keyhole-
based volume defects based on a series of non-consumable pinless tools and additional ﬁller materials. A schematic diagram of the A-
PFFSR process is shown in Fig. 82. The A-PFFSR process was divided into two parts: active ﬁlling (AF) and passive ﬁlling (PF). The
keyhole could be repaired in several steps using di ﬀerent pinless rotating tools

## B0186 · 第60页 · 清洗文本字符2401–3600

 with di ﬀerent diameters. The keyhole in the AF
process was ﬁlled with the materials surrounding the keyhole. The additional ﬁller materials used in the PF process were the same as
those used in the BM process. The diameter of the additional ﬁller materials was the same as that of the rotating tool used in the last
step, and the height was higher than the depth of the un ﬁlled keyhole. During the AF and PF processes, the ﬁller materials were
heated and plasticized by frictional heat generated by the pinless tool. Under the stirring e ﬀect of the rotating tool, su ﬃcient material
ﬂow behaviour can be produced, which can e ﬀectively ﬁll the keyhole. In addition, the forging force provided by the rotating tool
was beneﬁcial to solid-state bonding between both ﬁlling layers. Signi ﬁcantly, to repair keyholes successfully and obtain high-quality
joints, the optimum selections of the welding parameters (rotational velocity, plunge depth, tilt angle, plunge depth) and other
variables (shoulder diameter and morphology and the ﬁlling piece size) were very important. Ji and his co-workers [233] stated that
a six-spiral- ﬂute shoulder was designed to improve the material ﬂow and eliminate th

## B0187 · 第60页 · 清洗文本字符3601–4800

e interfacial defects, in which six-spiral ﬂutes
were distributed across a greater proportion of the shoulder. During the PF process, to obtain surface formation and reduce or even
eliminate the possibility of kissing bonds, the pinless rotating tool moved forward along the welding direction after dwelling for 5 s.
They reported that the tensile strength and elongation of the repaired joint reached 189.7 MPa and 7.6% at a constant rotational
velocity of 1300 rpm and a plunge speed of 1 mm/min, which correspond to 96.3% and 98% of those of the defect-free FSW joint,
respectively. The diminished plastic deformability after repairing the FSW keyhole in the 4-mm-thick AZ31B Mg alloy sheet occurred
due to the limitation of the number of slip systems of the hexagonal close packed crystal lattice. The mechanical properties of the A-
PFFSR joints increased as the rotational velocity increased from 1000 rpm to 1600 rpm. When the rotational velocity was 1600 rpm
and the constant plunge speed was 2 mm/min, the tensile strength and elongation of the repaired joint reached maximum values of
311.1 MPa and 7.6%, which correspond to 82.1% and 95.8% of those of the defect-free FSW joint, respective

## B0188 · 第60页 · 清洗文本字符4801–5175

ly. It can be concluded
that the solid-state repairing techniques, the severe plastic deformation and low peak temperature occur in the repairing interface,
which can improve the interfacial bonding, and then achieve the repaired joints with quasi-equivalent strengths.
Fig. 81. New technique of SRFSW [275].
X. Meng, et al. Progress in Materials Science 115 (2021) 100706
60

## B0189 · 第61页 · 清洗文本字符1–1200

5.4.5. Re ﬁll friction stir spot welding
RFSSW, a solid-state spot welding process invented and patented by Helmholtz-Zentrum Geesthacht [331], was developed as an
alternative to riveting or conventional fusion welding techniques to fabricate similar or dissimilar material joints, such as Al/Al alloys
[332–335], Mg/Mg alloys [336], Al/Mg alloys [337], polymers/polymers [134,338,339] and polymers/metals [340–342]. The
RFSSW tool consists of a clamping ring, a sleeve, and a pin, as shown in Fig. 83 [33] . The clamping ring does not rotate during
welding. The main function of the clamping ring is to keep the sheets tightly joined and prevent the plasticized materials from
escaping. The clamping ring always has a large diameter. The main components stirring the materials are the pin and the sleeve.
Hence, both the pin and the sleeve have threads on their outer surfaces ( Fig. 83). A clearance ﬁt is used when assembling the three
components to avoid their direct connections. The RFSSW process is mainly divided into four steps. In the initial step, the front
surface of the rotating tool parts initially contacts the surface of the plate, generating frictional heat. In the second step, the

## B0190 · 第61页 · 清洗文本字符1201–2400

 sleeve
plunges downward, displacing the materials that ﬂow into the cavity underneath the retracting pin. In the third step, the pin moves
downward and the sleeve retracts, pushing the softened materials back into the weld. In the ﬁnal step, the tool retracts from the
workpieces, leaving the plug and surrounding workpieces joined.
The main parameters controlling microstructures and subsequent mechanical properties are the pin morphology, rotational ve-
locity, plunge speed and heat treatment for precipitation-hardened Al alloys. Defect-free joints were fabricated using a modi ﬁed tool
with three grooves or notches in the tool sleeve, which improved metallurgical bonding, material intermixing and mechanical
interlocking at the interface compared with the standard sleeve with a ﬂat surface, as shown in Fig. 84 [332] . With increasing tool
wear, more materials are pressed into the gaps between the tool parts. This leads to larger required torques and forces and higher
temperatures [343]. Based on numerical simulations, Ji et al. [344] studied the eﬀects of welding tool morphology on heat generation
and material ﬂow, as shown in Fig. 85. They found that a large sleeve diameter increas

## B0191 · 第61页 · 清洗文本字符2401–3095

ed the heat input and joining area, while an
extremely high heat input was detrimental to the joint quality. The groove on the sleeve improved the material ﬂow behaviour. The
threaded groove on the sleeve walls or the unclosed groove on the sleeve bottom is more suitable for increasing the ﬂow velocity
along the vertical direction.
Fig. 82. Schematics and joint formations of the A-PFFSR process: schematics of the (a) ﬁrst AF, (b) second AF, (c) PF and (d) completion of A-PFFSR;
joint formations of the (e) keyhole, (f) after ﬁrst AF, (g) after second AF and (h) after PF [243].
Fig. 83. RFSSW keyhole closure process [282].
X. Meng, et al. Progress in Materials Science 115 (2021) 100706
61

## B0192 · 第62页 · 清洗文本字符1–1200

Reimann et al. [282] employed RFSSW and a plug as ﬁller materials to seal through holes in 6-mm-thick AA6061-T6 workpieces.
The RFSSW joints reached 68% and 55% of the ultimate tensile strength and yield strength of the BM, respectively. Later, Reimann
et al. [283] applied RFSSW for termination hole closure in BT-FSW joints in 3-mm-thick AA2198-T8 workpieces. The mechanical
performance of the closed hole is similar to that of the RFSSW keyhole closure welds in the base metal. Coeﬃ cient of 67% for
hardness, 57% for yield strength and 78% for ultimate tensile strength were achieved. They also ﬁlled the through hole of an AA7075-
T761 workpiece by RFSSW [284]. Reimann and co-workers [282–284] stated that post-weld natural ageing was shown to be highly
signiﬁcant for the mechanical properties. During ageing, the strength increased from 58% to 70% of the BM hardness in the area of
lowest hardness in the HAZ and from 46% to 55% of the yield strength of the BM. The post-weld natural ageing stabilized after
4 weeks [284]. Keyhole closure using RFSSW was demonstrated as a universal through-hole closure method that o ﬀers advantages
such as defect-free welds and superior surface appearance 

## B0193 · 第62页 · 清洗文本字符1201–2400

on both sides of the weld. Fox et al. [345] developed a pre-cracking
procedure to provide simulated fatigue cracks on which repairing could be performed by depositing AA2024 powders using cold
spraying to ﬁll the pre-cracks. Good repairing was also characterized and showed the improvement in fatigue life over cracks by
SSFSW
2.
Additionally, this method does not require any surface preparation before or after the welding process and seals the keyhole in a
single-step process. This method is not suitable for closed structures due to the need to install a rigid backing bar that has to withstand
a large welding force. Some cross-sections of the RFSSW joints show cracks in the lower parts of the NZ, which initiated from the
oxide remnants of the interface between the plug and surrounding workpieces. Moreover, the common defects are lack of mixing,
incomplete reﬁlling [346], voids [347] and tearing [348] at the TMAZ/NZ interface. Liu et al. [349] introduced ultrasonic oscillation
into the RFSSW process to join AA5A06 and stated that lateral ultrasonic oscillation was more e ﬀective in improving the tensile
strength of the joint.
Fig. 84. Low-magniﬁcation overviews of unwelded and welded

## B0194 · 第62页 · 清洗文本字符2401–2949

 samples: (a) unwelded cross-section with extruded plug and surrounding workpieces
and (b) typical appearance of the welded sample [284].
Fig. 85. Tool models in the simulation process: (a) regular tool, (b) tool with a smooth surface, (c) tool with a large-diameter sleeve, (d) tool with a
smaller groove width, (e) tool with a groove on the inner sleeve surface, (f) tool with concentric circles on the sleeve bottom and (g) tool with a
scrolled groove on the sleeve bottom [344].
X. Meng, et al. Progress in Materials Science 115 (2021) 100706
62

## B0195 · 第63页 · 清洗文本字符1–1200

5.4.6. Prospects
Friction stir-based remanufacturing, a high-e ﬃciency and green joining technique based on low frictional heat and severe plastic
deformation, has great potential for high-quality repairing of metallic material. However, some issues need to be addressed.
(1) Aiming at the typical defect repairing of the outer environment or complex structural parts, the portable and multiple-degree-of-
freedom FSW robot combined with FSR will certainly be a research hotspot. Recently, robotic FSW systems have been utilized in
various industrial applications.
(2) Although FSR has the outstanding advantages to repair light materials of Al alloys and Mg alloys, it should be developed into the
production of high melting materials, such as steels, Ti or Ti-based alloys and MMCs.
(3) FSR integrates advanced manufacturing processes such as additive manufacturing to obtain variants such as friction stir additive
manufacturing and additive friction stir, resulting in landmark accomplishments towards the goal of innovative and modern
prototyping/tooling/manufacturing engineering applications. It is challenging to extend its applications to include tubes, in
particular small-diameter tubes, a

## B0196 · 第63页 · 清洗文本字符1201–2400

nd other complex geometries.
6. Conclusions and outlooks
In this review, the latest progress and rapidly growing knowledge involving the inherent issues and their control strategies for
conventional FSW, with particular emphases on the technical development of self-supported FSW, non-weld-thinning FSW and
frictional stir-based remanufacturing, were reviewed and summarized.
The back support problem during conventional FSW has been successfully solved by BT-FSW and SSFSW
1. By optimizing the
welding tools and process parameters in BT-FSW, acceptable results were obtained in the joining of 2xxx and 6xxx Al alloys and
partial Mg alloys. Moreover, the adjustable-gap or adaptive-gap BT-FSW, counterrotating shoulder and stationary shoulder BT-FSW
were developed to enhance joint integrity and quality. Aiming at the narrow space and the preset holes in BT-FSW joints, SSFSW 1
with a convex lower shoulder was invented, which could directly plunge into the welding workpieces without preset holes, and
successfully join 6xxx Al alloys. The design criterion of the welding tool and formation mechanism were established and expounded
to improve structural integrity. Additionally, the lower surface ﬁ

## B0197 · 第63页 · 清洗文本字符2401–3600

nishing was further improved by PFSW. Some issues in the self-
supported FSW were the voids and JLRs, which may be addressed by the tool design with improved material ﬂow and process
parameters.
The solution methods of weld-thinning were mainly divided into three categories. The ﬁrst method aimed to prevent the over ﬂow
of the plasticized materials in the weld: SSFSW
2. The second method aimed to avoid the over ﬂow of the plasticized materials: zero-
plunge-depth FSW, NWT-FSW and MPD-FSW. The last method aimed to add materials into the weld by assisted devices (hybrid metal
extrusion and bonding, cold spraying and in-situ additive FSW) or processes (SCFSW and T-plate assisted FSW). Extensive research has
focused on SSFSW 2, which has achieved good joint integrity without weld thinning and with excellent mechanical properties for Ti
alloys, Al alloys and thermoplastic polymers. SSFSW 2 has also been applied to the aerospace and railway manufacturing ﬁelds. One of
the key issues in SSFSW 2 is tool wear or fracture induced by the over ﬂowing materials between the stationary shoulder and the
rotating tool, which can be addressed via tool coating or rational structural design. Zero-plun

## B0198 · 第63页 · 清洗文本字符3601–4800

ge-depth FSW was invented to avoid tool
fracture, reduce the softening degree and improve the mechanical properties. The narrow parameter window restricted its further
application, which may be handled by the tool design. Moreover, the solid-state joining mechanism should be further revealed and
provide technical support for microstructural adjustment and property improvement.
The typical defects and causes in FSW joints or other damaged structural parts in complex and harsh environments during
engineering applications were concluded. Recent progress in solid-state remanufacturing techniques based on FSW was reviewed,
which provided signi ﬁcant reference values for improving the properties, high-quality repairing and practical engineering applica-
tions. Friction stir-based remanufacturing techniques were divided into repetitive (conventional FSW and pinless FSW) and additive
(FPW, FTPW, FFSW and so on) remanufacturing. Repetitive friction stir remanufacturing, characterized by unconsumable welding
tools, was suitable to repair defects with a certain length and thickness, such as surface peeling, grooves, and cracks in low melting
point materials. This technique could also repair h

## B0199 · 第63页 · 清洗文本字符4801–6000

igh melting point materials; however, this approach is expensive and requires
special welding tools to avoid tool wear. Additive friction stir remanufacturing, featuring consumable or semi-consumable welding
tools, is applicable to local volume defects with the loss of materials, such as keyholes, cavities and pitting defects. The consumable
tool has the potential to repair the materials with high melting point or low melting point, as the tool directly acted as the ﬁlling
materials for repairing defects, thereby avoiding tool wear.
To date, inherent issues have been solved by advanced manufacturing technologies. It should be emphasized that there are still
several challenges to be approached before industry can proceed with these new strategies.
(1) Solid-state joining mechanism and numerical simulation of the whole process of FSW
FSW is a highly intricate process comprising several nonlinear physical phenomena. These phenomena include severe plastic
deformation, heat generation, turbulent ﬂow, mechanical shearing, DRX, and interfacial interaction. Multiple parameters greatly
change the results of the joints. It is nearly impossible to analyse the isolated inﬂ uences through exper

## B0200 · 第63页 · 清洗文本字符6001–6398

iments only. FSW is an
interesting subject, for which numerical simulations and experiments are integral. The key issue is to apply the numerical method to
guide the design of the experiments and achieve process-structure-microstructure-property relationships. Nonetheless, there are still
several challenges that must be overcome:
X. Meng, et al. Progress in Materials Science 115 (2021) 100706
63

## B0201 · 第64页 · 清洗文本字符1–1200

1) Systematic integration of the process-structure-microstructure-property relationships.
2) Tool design based on reliability evaluation and failure analysis.
3) Multiscale numerical study from atoms to joints.
4) Multiphase ﬂow behaviour and interfacial rapid di ﬀusion of dissimilar joints.
5) Modelling of dynamic recovery and DRX considering severe plastic deformation.
6) Boundary ﬂow mechanism driven by frictional shearing based on molecular dynamics.
7) Dislocation multiplication and annihilation behaviours induced by severe plastic deformation.
(2) High reliability and anti-fatigue joining
In published articles, satisfactory mechanical properties of advancing FSW joints have been achieved. To push FSW from the
laboratory into industry, the improvement of wear and corrosion resistance must be thoroughly considered in the future to satisfy the
application requirements in aerospace and automobile. Functional gradient coatings (composites and nano-grains) have the notable
advantage in wear and corrosion resistance, which can satisfy the requirements of highly reliable and anti-fatigue joining. The current
challenges in fabricating functionally gradient coatings are microstructural

## B0202 · 第64页 · 清洗文本字符1201–2400

 adjustments with assisted equipment and related process
parameters. There are still some key issues to be solved, which are detailed hereafter:
1) Develop portable assisted equipment with the advantages of low cost, simple operation and high e ﬃciency to extend industrial
applications.
2) Select reasonable coating materials according to the requirements of wear or corrosion resistance.
3) Optimize the process parameters and material types to achieve reliable bonding between the coating and the substrate and
satisfactory properties of the coatings.
4) Understand the bonding mechanism between the coating and the substrates, such as metallurgical bonding, mechanical inter-
locking and adhesion.
(3) Quasi-equal strength remanufacturing
Friction stir-based remanufacturing is a solid-state and e ﬀective technique to repair structural defects that provides better me-
chanical properties than other fusion repairing methods. A necessary geometrizatiio process for di ﬀerent types of defects in the
laboratory increases the complexity of remanufacturing and restricts the repairing quality and industrial applications. Direct solid-
state additive repairing based on powders with strengthening e

## B0203 · 第64页 · 清洗文本字符2401–3600

 ﬀects has the potential to further expand friction stir-based re-
manufacturing. Additive friction stir deposition is a fast, scalable and solid-state process characterized by re ﬁned microstructures and
ﬂexible options for feed materials. The direct deposition method has the advantages of nanostructured grains in powder metallurgy
and fast di ﬀusion induced by severe plastic deformation, signi ﬁcantly improving mechanical performances. Moreover, some
strengthening phases, such as ceramic particles or whiskers, carbon nanotubes, and graphene nanoplatelets, can be deposited to
improve mechanical, thermal or electronic properties. Some key problems remain to be solved.
1) Seek economical high-strength powders and strengthening phases as additive materials and fabrication methods for composite
powders.
2) Optimize the process parameters, including the morphology and size of high-strength powders and strengthening phases, the
equipment parameters to control microstructural evolution and the subsequent mechanical properties.
3) Understand the deposition growth, interfacial bonding and strengthening mechanisms; establish a relationship between the
process-microstructure-joint performanc

## B0204 · 第64页 · 清洗文本字符3601–4800

e (mechanical, corrosion, thermal and electronic).
4) Combining assisted processes (arc, laser or ultrasonic) with solid-state additive repairing, where thermal energy bene ﬁts the
softening of high-strength materials or low thermal conductivity materials, such as Ti alloys, high-entropy alloys and polymers,
and vibration energy improves atom di ﬀusion at the repair interface.
(4) Detection, standardization and expanding applications
FSW has been widely used in industrial manufacturing ﬁelds, where welding defects inevitably appear in the weld and subse-
quently aﬀect the service life. Although many methods have been developed to solve this problem, quantitative evaluations of defect
types and corresponding repairing techniques are lacking. It is of vital importance to establish standards for detecting and repairing of
welding defects to realize point-to-point repairing. Many non-destructive tests have been developed to characterize di ﬀerent volume
welding defects, such as an eddy current inspection, ultrasonic non-destructive testing and evaluation techniques, acoustic emission,
X-ray, magnetic methods, and ultrasound-excited infrared thermography. Some important issues remain to

## B0205 · 第64页 · 清洗文本字符4801–5499

 be addressed.
1) Detect and characterize the kissing bond defects or unsatisfactory microstructures quantitatively.
2) Reveal the e ﬀects of process parameters and external environmental conditions on defect formation, microstructures and me-
chanical properties.
3) Establish a database containing the defect types (shape and size) in many kinds of materials with varied thickness and the
corresponding repairing techniques based on the experiments and numerical simulations.
(5) Robotic and intelligent FSW
The inherent issues of conventional FSW have been addressed by a series of innovative control strategies in linear or two-
X. Meng, et al. Progress in Materials Science 115 (2021) 100706
64

## B0206 · 第65页 · 清洗文本字符1–1200

dimensional structures by gantry FSW equipment, which has di ﬃculties in satisfying the requirements for three-dimensional
structural parts. Recently, robotic FSW equipment and techniques have become candidates to replace conventional FSW due to the
relatively high ﬂexibility and complex motion track, which can realize the welding of complex structural parts. Robotic FSW, which
can operate in a large welding space and o ﬀer multi-mode control, can signi ﬁcantly improve production e ﬃciency and quality;
hence, this technique has been used to create door structures in the Mazda RX8 and hatches in helicopters. Some important key issues
need to be addressed.
1) Develop overloading industrial robotic FSW equipment with high rigidity to improve weldable thickness and ensure the con-
sistency between the actual and simulated welding tracks.
2) Integrate the controlling modes of robotic FSW to regulate several factors, including pressure, temperature, weld tracking, and
laser positioning.
3) Study the e ﬀect of welding parameters (pressure, temperature, weld tracking, and laser positioning) on the welding track and pose
through interdependent feedback to realize the accuracy control of the

## B0207 · 第65页 · 清洗文本字符1201–2400

 welding track.
4) Combine new FSW technologies (self-supported FSW, NWT-FSW and friction stir-based remanufacturing) with robotic FSW to
realize ﬂexible manufacturing of structures.
5) Introduce an assisted heating source to decrease the material stress for the accuracy control of the welding track.
Successfully addressing these important inherent issues will have large impact on FSW/P science and technology for a wide range
of technological applications.
Declaration of Competing Interest
The authors declare that they have no known competing ﬁnancial interests or personal relationships that could have appeared to
inﬂuence the work reported in this paper.
Acknowledgements
The work was jointly supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (No. 51575132).
References
[1] Magalhães VM, Leitão C, Rodrigues DM. Friction stir welding industrialisation and research status. Sci Technol Weld Join 2018;23:400 –9. https://doi.org/10.
1080/13621718.2017.1403110.
[2] Thomas WM, Nicholas ED, Needham JC, Murch MG, Temple-Smith P, Dawes CJ. Friction stir butt welding; 1991. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-642-54607-5.
[3] Ma ZY. Friction stir processing technology: a review. Metall Ma

## B0208 · 第65页 · 清洗文本字符2401–3600

ter Trans A 2008;39:642 –58. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11661-007-9459-0.
[4] Mishra RS, Ma ZY. Friction stir welding and processing. Mater Sci Eng R Reports 2005;50:1 –78. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.mser.2005.07.001.
[5] Chen Y, Liu H, Feng J. Friction stir welding characteristics of di ﬀerent heat-treated-state 2219 aluminum alloy plates. Mater Sci Eng A 2006;420:21 –5. https://
doi.org/10.1016/j.msea.2006.01.029.
[6] Liu HJ, Li JQ, Duan WJ. Friction stir welding characteristics of 2219 –T6 aluminum alloy assisted by external non-rotational shoulder. Int J Adv Manuf Technol
2013;64:1685–94. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00170-012-4132-1.
[7] Zhang ZH, Li WY, Feng Y, Li JL, Chao YJ. Global anisotropic response of friction stir welded 2024 aluminum sheets. Acta Mater 2015;92:117 –25. https://doi.
org/10.1016/j.actamat.2015.03.054.
[8] Zhou C, Yang X, Luan G. Fatigue properties of friction stir welds in Al 5083 alloy. Scr Mater 2005;53:1187 –91. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scriptamat.2005.07.
016.
[9] Lombard H, Hattingh DG, Steuwer A, James MN. Optimising FSW process parameters to minimise defects and maximise fatigue life in 5083– H321 aluminium
alloy. Eng Fract Mech 2008;75:341 –54. https:

## B0209 · 第65页 · 清洗文本字符3601–4800

//doi.org/10.1016/j.engfracmech.2007.01.026.
[10] Hirata T, Oguri T, Hagino H, Tanaka T, Chung SW, Takigawa Y, et al. In ﬂuence of friction stir welding parameters on grain size and formability in 5083
aluminum alloy. Mater Sci Eng A 2007;456:344 –9. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.msea.2006.12.079.
[11] Shi L, Wu CS, Gao S, Padhy GK. Modi ﬁed constitutive equation for use in modeling the ultrasonic vibration enhanced friction stir welding process. Scr Mater
2016;119:21–6. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scriptamat.2016.03.023.
[12] Maggiolini E, Tovo R, Susmel L, James MN, Hattingh DG. Crack path and fracture analysis in FSW of small diameter 6082 –T6 aluminium tubes under
tension–torsion loading. Int J Fatigue 2016;92:478 –87. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijfatigue.2016.02.043.
[13] Ma ZY, Mishra RS, Mahoney MW. Superplastic deformation behaviour of friction stir processed 7075Al alloy. Acta Mater 2002;50:4419 –30. https://doi.org/10.
1016/S1359-6454(02)00278-1.
[14] Kawashima T, Sano T, Hirose A, Tsutsumi S, Masaki K, Arakawa K, et al. Femtosecond laser peening of friction stir welded 7075– T73 aluminum alloys. J Mater
Process Technol 2018;262:111 –22. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jmatprotec.2018

## B0210 · 第65页 · 清洗文本字符4801–6000

.06.022.
[15] Bayazid SM, Farhangi H, Asgharzadeh H, Radan L, Ghahramani A, Mirhaji A. E ﬀect of cyclic solution treatment on microstructure and mechanical properties of
friction stir welded 7075 Al alloy. Mater Sci Eng A 2016;649:293 –300. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.msea.2015.10.010.
[16]
Ji SD, Jin YY, Yue YM, Gao SS, Huang YX, Wang L. E ﬀect of temperature on material transfer behavior at di ﬀerent stages of friction stir welded 7075 –T6
aluminum alloy. J Mater Sci Technol 2013;29:955 –60. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jmst.2013.05.018.
[17] Wang K, Shen Y, Yang X, Wang X, Xu K. Evaluation of microstructure and mechanical property of FSW welded MB3 magnesium alloy. J Iron Steel Res Int
2006;13:75–8. https://doi.org/10.1016/S1006-706X(06)60082-4.
[18] Singh K, Singh G, Singh H. Review on friction stir welding of magnesium alloys. J Magnes Alloy 2018;6:399 –416. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jma.2018.06.001.
[19] Pan F, Xu A, Deng D, Ye J, Jiang X, Tang A, et al. E ﬀects of friction stir welding on microstructure and mechanical properties of magnesium alloy Mg-5Al-3Sn.
Mater Des 2016;110:266 –74. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matdes.2016.07.146.
[20] Oliveira JP, Miranda RM, Braz Fernandes FM.

## B0211 · 第65页 · 清洗文本字符6001–6522

 Welding and joining of NiTi shape memory alloys: a review. Prog Mater Sci 2017;88:412 –66. https://doi.org/10.
1016/j.pmatsci.2017.04.008.
[21] Gangwar K, Ramulu M. Friction stir welding of titanium alloys: a review. Mater Des 2018;141:230 –55. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matdes.2017.12.033.
[22] Mironov S, Sato YS, Kokawa H. Friction-stir welding and processing of Ti-6Al-4V titanium alloy: a review. J Mater Sci Technol 2017;34:58 –72. https://doi.org/
X. Meng, et al. Progress in Materials Science 115 (2021) 100706
65

## B0212 · 第66页 · 清洗文本字符1–1200

10.1016/j.jmst.2017.10.018.
[23] Shinde G, Gajghate S, Dabeer PS, Seemikeri CY. Low cost friction stir welding: a review. Mater Today Proc 2017;4:8901 –10. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matpr.
2017.07.241.
[24] Guan W, Shen Y, Yan Y, Guo R, Zhang W. Fabrication of ultra-thin copper foil pressure welding using FSW equipment. J Mater Process Technol
2018;251:343–9. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jmatprotec.2017.08.022.
[25] Heidarzadeh A, Laleh HM, Gerami H, Hosseinpour P, Shabestari MJ, Bahari R. The origin of di ﬀerent microstructural and strengthening mechanisms of copper
and brass in their dissimilar friction stir welded joint. Mater Sci Eng A 2018;735:336 –42. https://doi.org/10.1016/J.MSEA.2018.08.068.
[26] Liu FC, Hovanski Y, Miles MP, Sorensen CD, Nelson TW. A review of friction stir welding of steels: Tool, material ﬂow, microstructure, and properties. J Mater
Sci Technol 2017;34:39 –57. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jmst.2017.10.024.
[27] El-Batahgy AM, Miura T, Ueji R, Fujii H. Investigation into feasibility of FSW process for welding 1600MPa quenched and tempered steel. Mater Sci Eng A
2016;651:904–13. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.msea.2015.11.054.
[28] Zhang H, Wang D, Xue P, Wu LH, Ni 

## B0213 · 第66页 · 清洗文本字符1201–2400

DR, Xiao BL, et al. Achieving ultra-high strength friction stir welded joints of high nitrogen stainless steel by forced water
cooling. J Mater Sci Technol 2018;34:2183 –8. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jmst.2018.03.014.
[29] Lee SJ, Sun Y, Fujii H. Stacking-fault energy, mechanical twinning and strain hardening of Fe-18Mn-0.6C-(0, 1.5)Al twinning-induced plasticity steels during
friction stir welding. Acta Mater 2018;148:235 –48. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.actamat.2018.02.004.
[30] Banjare PN, Sahlot P, Arora A. An assisted heating tool design for FSW of thermoplastics. J Mater Process Technol 2017;239:83 –91. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.
jmatprotec.2016.07.035.
[31] Ratanathavorn W. Hybrid joining of aluminum to thermoplastics with friction stir welding engineering. KTH-Royal Institute of Technology; 2012 .
[32] Pramanik A, Basak AK, Dong Y, Sarker PK, Uddin MS, Littlefair G, et al. Joining of carbon ﬁbre reinforced polymer (CFRP) composites and aluminium alloys – a
review. Compos Part A Appl Sci Manuf 2017;101:1 –29. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.compositesa.2017.06.007.
[33] Shi H, Chen K, Liang Z, Dong F, Yu T, Dong X, et al. Intermetallic compounds in the banded structure and their e ﬀe

## B0214 · 第66页 · 清洗文本字符2401–3600

ct on mechanical properties of Al/Mg
dissimilar friction stir welding joints. J Mater Sci Technol 2017;33:359 –66. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jmst.2016.05.006.
[34] Liu L, Ren D, Liu F. A review of dissimilar welding techniques for magnesium alloys to aluminum alloys. Materials (Basel) 2014;7:3735 –57. https://doi.org/10.
3390/ma7053735.
[35] Kasai H, Morisada Y, Fujii H. Dissimilar FSW of immiscible materials: steel/magnesium. Mater Sci Eng A 2015;624:250 –5. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.msea.
2014.11.060.
[36] Zheng Q, Feng X, Shen Y, Huang G, Zhao P. Dissimilar friction stir welding of 6061 Al to 316 stainless steel using Zn as a ﬁller metal. J Alloys Compd
2016;686:693–701. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jallcom.2016.06.092.
[37] Thomä M, Wagner G, Straß B, Wolter B, Benfer S, Fürbeth W. Ultrasound enhanced friction stir welding of aluminum and steel: Process and properties of EN AW
6061/DC04-Joints. J Mater Sci Technol 2017;34:163 –72. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jmst.2017.10.022.
[38]
Huang Y, Lv Z, Wan L, Shen J, dos Santos JF. A new method of hybrid friction stir welding assisted by friction surfacing for joining dissimilar Ti/Al alloy. Mater
Lett 2017;207:172 –5. https://doi.org/10.1

## B0215 · 第66页 · 清洗文本字符3601–4800

016/j.matlet.2017.07.081.
[39] Choi JW, Liu H, Fujii H. Dissimilar friction stir welding of pure Ti and pure Al. Mater Sci Eng A 2018;730:168 –76. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.msea.2018.05.117.
[40] Eslami S, Tavares PJ, Moreira PMGP. Friction stir welding tooling for polymers: review and prospects. Int J Adv Manuf Technol 2017;89:1677 –90. https://doi.
org/10.1007/s00170-016-9205-0.
[41] Wu LH, Nagatsuka K, Nakata K. Achieving superior mechanical properties in friction lap joints of copper to carbon- ﬁber-reinforced plastic by tool o ﬀsetting. J
Mater Sci Technol 2018;34:1628 –37. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jmst.2018.04.015.
[42] Wang G, Zhao Y, Hao Y. Friction stir welding of high-strength aerospace aluminum alloy and application in rocket tank manufacturing. J Mater Sci Technol
2017;34:73–91. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jmst.2017.11.041.
[43] Space launch system: Tooling up to build the world ’s largest rocket; 2013. https://www.nasa.gov/centers/marshall/news/news/releases/2013/13-080.html.
[44] Schorr AA, Creech SD, Ogles M, David H. Space launch system spacecraft and payload elements: making progress toward ﬁrst launch. AIAA Sp; 2016:1 –14.
https://doi.org/10.2514/6.2016-5418.
[45] 

## B0216 · 第66页 · 清洗文本字符4801–6000

Burkey Martin. A (much) closer look at how we build SLS. Rocket NASA’ s Sp Launch Syst; 2016. https://blogs.nasa.gov/Rocketology/2016/06/02/a-much-
closer-look-at-how-we-build-sls/.
[46] Large-Scale Manufacturing: Advancing State-of-the-art. Mater Manuf; 2014. https://www.nasa.gov/sites/default/ﬁles/ﬁles/LargeScaleMfg.pdf.
[47] Trueba L, Torres MA, Johannes LB, Rybicki D. Process optimization in the self-reacting friction stir welding of aluminum 6061– T6. Int J Mater Form
2017:559–70. https://doi.org/10.1007/s12289-017-1365-4.
[48] Marie F, Alléhaux D, Esmiller B. Development of the bobbin tool technique on various aluminum alloys. In: 5th Int. Symp. Frict. stir Weld., Metz, France; 2004.
p. 39 –52.
[49] Li WY, Fu T, Hütsch L, Hilgert J, Wang FF, dos Santos JF, et al. E ﬀects of tool rotational and welding speed on microstructure and mechanical properties of
bobbin-tool friction-stir welded Mg AZ31. Mater Des 2014;64:714 –20. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matdes.2014.07.023.
[50] Thomas WM, Wiesner CS, Marks DJ, Staines DG. Conventional and bobbin friction stir welding of 12% chromium alloy steel using composite refractory tool
materials. Sci Technol Weld Join 2009;14:247 –53. https:/

## B0217 · 第66页 · 清洗文本字符6001–7200

/doi.org/10.1179/136217109X415893.
[51] Hilgert J, Santos JF, Huber N, Hilgert J, Santos JF, Huber N. Shear layer modelling for bobbin tool friction stir welding. Sci Technol Weld Join 2012;17:454 –9.
https://doi.org/10.1179/1362171812Y.0000000034.
[52] Chen S, Li H, Lu S, Ni R, Dong J. Temperature measurement and control of bobbin tool friction stir welding. Int J Adv Manuf Technol 2016;86:337 –46. https://
doi.org/10.1007/s00170-015-8116-9.
[53]
Sued MK, Pons D, Lavro ﬀ J, Wong EH. Design features for bobbin friction stir welding tools: Development of a conceptual model linking the underlying physics
to the production process. Mater Des 2014;54:632 –43. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matdes.2013.08.057.
[54] Pirizadeh M, Azdast T, Rash Ahmadi S, Mamaghani Shishavan S, Bagheri A. Friction stir welding of thermoplastics using a newly designed tool. Mater Des
2014;54:342–7. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matdes.2013.08.053.
[55] Wahid MA, Khan ZA, Siddiquee AN. Review on underwater friction stir welding: a variant of friction stir welding with great potential of improving joint
properties. Trans Nonferrous Met Soc China 2018;28:193 –219. https://doi.org/10.1016/S1003-6326(18)64653-9.
[56] Zho

## B0218 · 第66页 · 清洗文本字符7201–8400

u L, Li GH, Liu CL, Wang J, Huang YX, Feng JC, et al. E ﬀect of rotation speed on microstructure and mechanical properties of self-reacting friction stir
welded Al-Mg-Si alloy. Int J Adv Manuf Technol 2017;89:3509 –16. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00170-016-9318-5.
[57] A Group Sponsored Project. Assessment of bobbin friction stir welding for joining aluminium alloys. TWI; 2009:6. https://www.twi-global.com/news-events/
connect/2009/march-april-2009/assessment-of-bobbin-friction-stir-welding-for-joining-aluminium-alloys/.
[58] Carter R, Kirby Lawless. Gimballed shoulders for friction stir welding. NASA Tech Briefs; 2008:27 –8.
[59] Nunes AC. Counterrotating-shoulder mechanism for friction stir welding. Manuf Prototyp 2007:21 –2https://ntrs.nasa.gov/archive/nasa/casi.ntrs.nasa.gov/
20090041262.pdf.
[60] dos Santos JF, Hilgert J. Apparatus for sriction stir welding. US20120248174A1; 2012.
[61] Scupin P. Semi-stationary shoulder bobbin tool (S3BT): A new approach in high speed friction stir welding. Technischen Universität Hamburg; 2015.
[62] Goebel J, Martin R, Norman A, Jorge. F.dos Santos. Semi-stationary shoulder bobbin tool friction stir welding of AA2198-T851. J Mater Process Techno

## B0219 · 第66页 · 清洗文本字符8401–9013

l
2017;245:37–45.
[63] Hilgert J. Knowledge based process development of bobbin tool friction stir welding. Helmholtz-Zentrum Geesthacht; 2012.
[64] Tongne A, Desrayaud C, Jahazi M, Feulvarch E. On material ﬂow in friction stir welded Al alloys. J Mater Process Technol 2017;239:284 –96. https://doi.org/
10.1016/j.jmatprotec.2016.08.030.
[65] Nandan R, DebRoy T, Bhadeshia HKDH. Recent advances in friction-stir welding - process, weldment structure and properties. Prog Mater Sci
2008;53:980–1023. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.pmatsci.2008.05.001.
X. Meng, et al.
Progress in Materials Science 115 (2021) 100706
66

## B0220 · 第67页 · 清洗文本字符1–1200

[66] Huang Y, Wang Y, Wan L, Liu H, Shen J, dos Santos JF, et al. Material- ﬂow behavior during friction-stir welding of 6082 –T6 aluminum alloy. Int J Adv Manuf
Technol 2016;87:1115 –23. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00170-016-8603-7.
[67] Colligan K. Material ﬂow behavior during friction welding of aluminum. Weld J 1999;75:229 –37.
[68] Guerra M, Schmidt C, McClure JC, Murr LE, Nunes AC. Flow patterns during friction stir welding. Mater Charact 2002;49:95 –101.
[69] Schmidt HNB, Dickerson TL, Hattel JH. Material ﬂow in butt friction stir welds in AA2024-T3. Acta Mater 2006;54:1199 –209. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.
actamat.2005.10.052.
[70] Tamadon A, Pons D, Sued K, Clucas D. Formation mechanisms for entry and exit defects in bobbin friction stir welding. Metals (Basel) 2018;8:33. https://doi.
org/10.3390/met8010033.
[71] Schmidt HB, Hattel JH. Thermal modelling of friction stir welding. Scr Mater 2008;58:332 –7. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scriptamat.2007.10.008.
[72] Hilgert J, Schmidt HNB, Dos Santos JF, Huber N. Thermal models for bobbin tool friction stir welding. J Mater Process Technol 2011;211:197 –204. https://doi.
org/10.1016/j.jmatprotec.2010.09.006.
[73] Liu XM, Yao JS, Cai Y

## B0221 · 第67页 · 清洗文本字符1201–2400

, Meng H, Da Zou Z. Simulation on the temperature ﬁeld of bobbin tool friction stir welding of AA 2014 aluminium alloy. Appl Mech Mater
2013;433–435:2091–5. https://doi.org/10.4028/www.scientiﬁc.net/AMM.433-435.2091.
[74] Hilgert J, dos Santos JF, Huber N. Investigation of the material shear layer in bobbin tool friction stir welding. Frict. Stir Weld. Process. IV; 2011. p. 187 –93.
[75] Chen S, Lu A, Yang D, Lu S, Dong J, Dong C. Analysis on ﬂow pattern of bobbin tool friction stir welding for 6082 aluminum. In: Proc. 1st Int. Jt. Symp. Join.
Weld.; 2013. p. 353 –8. https://doi.org/10.1533/9781782421641.353.
[76] Fraser KA, St-Georges L, Kiss LI. Numerical simulation of bobbin tool friction stir welding. In: 10th Frict. Stir Weld. Symp., Beijing, China; 2014. p. 1 –15.
[77] Wen Q, Li WY, Gao YJ, Yang J, Wang FF. Numerical simulation and experimental investigation of band patterns in bobbin tool friction stir welding of aluminum
alloy. Int J Adv Manuf Technol 2018. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00170-018-2750-y.
[78] Zhang H, Wang M, Zhang X, Yang G. Microstructural characteristics and mechanical properties of bobbin tool friction stir welded 2A14-T6 aluminum alloy.
Mater Des 2015;65:55

## B0222 · 第67页 · 清洗文本字符2401–3600

9 –66. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matdes.2014.09.068.
[79] Liu HJ, Hou JC, Guo H. E ﬀect of welding speed on microstructure and mechanical properties of self-reacting friction stir welded 6061 –T6 aluminum alloy.
Mater Des 2013;50:872 –8. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matdes.2013.03.105.
[80] Ji S, Huang R, Meng X, Zhang L, Huang Y. Enhancing friction stir weldability of 6061 –T6 Al and AZ31B Mg alloys assisted by external non-rotational shoulder. J
Mater Eng Perform 2017;26:2359 –67. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11665-017-2640-8.
[81] Zhou L, Li GH, Zha GD, Shu FY, Liu HJ, Feng JC. E ﬀect of rotation speed on microstructure and mechanical properties of bobbin tool friction stir welded AZ61
magnesium alloy. Sci Technol Weld Join 2018;23:596 –605. https://doi.org/10.1080/13621718.2018.1432098.
[82] Padmanaban G, Balasubramanian V, Sarin Sundar JK. In ﬂuences of welding processes on microstructure, hardness, and tensile properties of AZ31B magnesium
alloy. J Mater Eng Perform 2010;19:155 –65. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11665-009-9389-7.
[83] Hou JC, Liu HJ, Zhao YQ. In ﬂuences of rotation speed on microstructures and mechanical properties of 6061 –T6 aluminum alloy joints fabricated by self-
re

## B0223 · 第67页 · 清洗文本字符3601–4800

acting friction stir welding tool. Int J Adv Manuf Technol 2014;73:1073 –9. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00170-014-5857-9.
[84] Wang FF, Li WY, Shen J, Hu SY, dos Santos JF. E ﬀect of tool rotational speed on the microstructure and mechanical properties of bobbin tool friction stir
welding of Al-Li alloy. Mater Des 2015;86:933 –40. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matdes.2015.07.096.
[85] Ion SE, Humphreys FJ, Whi SH. Dynamic recrystallisation and the development of microstructure during the high temperature deformation of magnesium. Acta
Metall 1982;30:1909 –19. https://doi.org/10.1016/0001-6160(82)90031-1.
[86] Park SHC, Sato YS, Kokawa H. E ﬀect of micro-texture on fracture location in friction stir weld of Mg alloy AZ61 during tensile test. Scr Mater 2003;49:161 –6.
https://doi.org/10.1016/S1359-6462(03)00210-0.
[87] Esmaily M, Mortazavi N, Osikowicz W, Hindsefelt H, Svensson JE, Halvarsson M, et al. Corrosion behaviour of friction stir-welded AA6005-T6 using a bobbin
tool. Corros Sci 2016;111:98 –109. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.corsci.2016.04.046.
[88] Threadgill PL, Ahmed MMZ, Martin JP, Perrett JG, Wynne BP. The use of bobbin tools for friction stir welding of aluminium alloys. Mater Sc

## B0224 · 第67页 · 清洗文本字符4801–6000

i Forum
2010;638–642:1179–84. https://doi.org/10.4028/www.scientiﬁc.net/MSF.638-642.1179.
[89] Xu WF, Luo YX, Fu MW. Microstructure evolution in the conventional single side and bobbin tool friction stir welding of thick rolled 7085– T7452 aluminum
alloy. Mater Charact 2018;138:48 –55. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matchar.2018.01.051.
[90] Sato YS, Kokawa H, Enomoto M, Jogan S. Microstructural evolution of 6063 aluminum during friction-stir welding. Metall Mater Trans A 1999;30:2429 –37.
https://doi.org/10.1007/s11661-999-0251-1.
[91] Esmaily M, Mortazavi N, Osikowicz W, Hindsefelt H, Svensson JE, Halvarsson M, et al. Bobbin and conventional friction stir welding of thick extruded AA6005-
T6 pro ﬁles. Mater Des 2016;108:114 –25. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matdes.2016.06.089.
[92] Kainuma S, Katsuki H, Iwai I, Kumagai M. Evaluation of fatigue strength of friction stir butt-welded aluminum alloy joints inclined to applied cyclic stress. Int J
Fatigue 2008;30:870 –6. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijfatigue.2007.06.007.
[93] Zhou C, Yang X, Luan G. E ﬀect of kissing bond on fatigue behavior of friction stir welds on Al 5083 alloy. J Mater Sci 2006;41:2771 –7. https://doi.org/10.1007/
s10853-00

## B0225 · 第67页 · 清洗文本字符6001–7200

6-6337-x.
[94]
Wang FF, Li WY, Shen J, Wen Q, dos Santos JF. Improving weld formability by a novel dual-rotation bobbin tool friction stir welding. J Mater Sci Technol
2018;34:135–9. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jmst.2017.11.001.
[95] Chen ZW, Pasang T, Qi Y. Shear ﬂow and formation of Nugget zone during friction stir welding of aluminium alloy 5083-O. Mater Sci Eng A 2008;474:312 –6.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.msea.2007.05.074.
[96] Yang C, Ni DR, Xue P, Xiao BL, Wang W, Wang KS, et al. A comparative research on bobbin tool and conventional friction stir welding of Al-Mg-Si alloy plates.
Mater Charact 2018;145:20 –8. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matchar.2018.08.027.
[97] Zhao Y, Wang C, Dong C. Microstructural characteristics and mechanical properties of water cooling bobbin-tool friction stir welded 6063 –T6 aluminum alloy.
MATEC Web Conf 2018;206:03002. https://doi.org/10.1051/matecconf/201820603002.
[98] Dalder ENC, Pastrnak JW, Engel J, Forrest RS, Kokko E, Ternan KM, et al. Bobbin-tool friction-stir welding of thick-walled aluminum alloy pressure eessels.
Weld J 2007:1 –17.
[99] Warsinski K, West M, Freeman J, Curtis T. Investigation of lazy S feature in self-reacting tool friction 

## B0226 · 第67页 · 清洗文本字符7201–8400

stir welds. Frict. Stir Weld. Process. VI 2011:171 –6.
https://doi.org/10.1002/9781118062302.ch21.
[100] Cao X, Jahazi M. E ﬀect of welding speed on the quality of friction stir welded butt joints of a magnesium alloy. Mater Des 2009;30:2033 –42. https://doi.org/10.
1016/j.matdes.2008.08.040.
[101] Skinner M, Edwards RL. Improvements to the FSW process using the self-reacting technology. Mater Sci Forum 2003;426 –432:2849–54. https://doi.org/10.
4028/www.scientiﬁc.net/MSF.426-432.2849.
[102] Oonne CD, Biallas G. Microstructure and mechanical properties of the aluminium alloy 6056 welded by friction stir welding techniques. Weld World
2006;50:98–106.
[103] Neumann T, Zettler R, Vilaça P, dos Santos JF, Quintino L. Analysis of self-reacting friction stir welds in a 2024-T351 alloy. Frict. Stir Weld. Process. IV,
Orlando, Florida; 2007.
[104] Adriana M, Obregon T. E ﬀect of process parameters on temperature distribution, microstructure, and mechanical properties of self-reacting friction stir welded
aluminum alloy 6061-T651. The University of Texas; 2011.
[105] Okamoto K, Sato A, Park SHC, Hirano S. Microstructure and mechanical properties of FSWed aluminum extrusion with bobbin Tools

## B0227 · 第67页 · 清洗文本字符8401–9095

. Mater Sci Forum
2012;706–709:990–5. https://doi.org/10.4028/www.scientiﬁc.net/MSF.706-709.990.
[106] Zhou L, Li GH, Liu CL, Wang J, Huang YX, Feng JC, et al. Microstructural characteristics and mechanical properties of Al –Mg–Si alloy self-reacting friction stir
welded joints. Sci Technol Weld Join 2017;22:438 –45. https://doi.org/10.1080/13621718.2016.1251733.
[107] Zhang J, Feng XS, Gao JS, Huang H, Ma ZQ, Guo LJ. E ﬀects of welding parameters and post-heat treatment on mechanical properties of friction stir welded
AA2195-T8 Al-Li alloy. J Mater Sci Technol 2018;34:219 –27. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jmst.2017.11.033.
X. Meng, et al. Progress in Materials Science 115 (2021) 100706
67

## B0228 · 第68页 · 清洗文本字符1–1200

[108] Shen Z, Yang X, Zhang Z, Cui L, Yin Y. Mechanical properties and failure mechanisms of friction stir spot welds of AA 6061 –T4 sheets. Mater Des
2013;49:181–91. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matdes.2013.01.066.
[109] Scialpi A, De Filippis LAC, Cavaliere P. In ﬂuence of shoulder geometry on microstructure and mechanical properties of friction stir welded 6082 aluminium
alloy. Mater Des 2007;28:1124 –9. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matdes.2006.01.031.
[110] Mendes N, Loureiro A, Martins C, Neto P, Pires JN. E ﬀect of friction stir welding parameters on morphology and strength of acrylonitrile butadiene styrene plate
welds. Mater Des 2014;58:457 –64. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matdes.2014.02.036.
[111] Wang FF, Li WY, Shen J, Zhang ZH, Li JL, Dos Santos JF. Global and local mechanical properties and microstructure of bobbin tool friction-stir-welded Al-Li
alloy. Sci Technol Weld Join 2016;21:479 –83. https://doi.org/10.1080/13621718.2015.1132128.
[112] Huang YX, Wan L, Lv SX, Feng JC. Novel design of tool for joining hollow extrusion by friction stir welding. Sci Technol Weld Join 2013;18:239 –46. https://doi.
org/10.1179/1362171812Y.0000000096.
[113] Wan L, Huang Y, Wang Y, Lv S, Feng

## B0229 · 第68页 · 清洗文本字符1201–2400

 J. Friction stir welding of aluminium hollow extrusion: weld formation and mechanical properties. Mater Sci Technol
2015;31:1433–42. https://doi.org/10.1179/1743284714Y.0000000721.
[114] Wan L, Huang Y, Guo W, Lv S, Feng J. Mechanical properties and microstructure of 6082 –T6 aluminum alloy joints by self-support friction stir welding. J Mater
Sci Technol 2014;30:1243 –50. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jmst.2014.04.009.
[115] Wan L, Huang Y, Lv Z, Lv S, Feng J. E ﬀect of self-support friction stir welding on microstructure and microhardness of 6082 –T6 aluminum alloy joint. Mater Des
2014;55:197–203. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matdes.2013.09.073.
[116] Balasubramanian V. Relationship between base metal properties and friction stir welding process parameters. Mater Sci Eng A 2008;480:397 –403. https://doi.
org/10.1016/j.msea.2007.07.048.
[117] Huang Y, Xie Y, Meng X, Lv Z, Cao J. Numerical design of high depth-to-width ratio friction stir welding. J Mater Process Technol 2018;252:233 –41. https://
doi.org/10.1016/j.jmatprotec.2017.09.029.
[118] Huang Y, Meng X, Wang Y, Xie Y, Zhou L. Joining of aluminum alloy and polymer via friction stir lap welding. J Mater Process Technol 2018;257:14

## B0230 · 第68页 · 清洗文本字符2401–3600

8 –54.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jmatprotec.2018.02.043.
[119] Huang Y, Wan L, Huang T, Lv Z, Zhou L, Feng J. The weld formation of self-support friction stir welds for aluminum hollow extrusion. Int J Adv Manuf Technol
2016;87:1067–75. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00170-016-8591-7.
[120] Edwards GA, Stiller K, Dunlop GL, Couper MJ. The precipitation sequence in Al-Mg-Si alloys. Acta Mater 1998;46:3893 –904. https://doi.org/10.1016/S1359-
6454(98)00059-7.
[121] Simar A, Bréchet Y, De Meester B, Denquin A, Gallais C, Pardoen T. Integrated modeling of friction stir welding of 6xxx series Al alloys: process, microstructure
and properties. Prog Mater Sci 2012;57:95 –183. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.pmatsci.2011.05.003.
[122] Dong P, Li H, Sun D, Gong W, Liu J. E ﬀects of welding speed on the microstructure and hardness in friction stir welding joints of 6005A –T6 aluminum alloy.
Mater Des 2013;45:524 –31. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matdes.2012.09.040.
[123] Huang YX, Wan L, Lv ZL, Lv SX, Zhou L, Feng JC. Microstructure and microhardness of aluminium alloy friction stir welds with heat treatment. Sci Technol
Weld Join 2016;21:638 –44. https://doi.org/10.1080/13621718.2016.1152748.
[124] Liu H,

## B0231 · 第68页 · 清洗文本字符3601–4800

 Hu Y, Wang H, Du S, Sekulic DP. Stationary shoulder supporting and tilting pin penetrating friction stir welding. J Mater Process Technol
2018;255:596–604. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jmatprotec.2018.01.010.
[125] Hu Y, Liu H, Li S, Du S, Sekulic DP. Improving mechanical properties of a joint through tilt probe penetrating friction stir welding. Mater Sci Eng A
2018;731:107–18. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.msea.2018.06.036.
[126] Wang BB, Chen FF, Liu F, Wang WG, Xue P, Ma ZY. Enhanced mechanical properties of friction stir welded 5083Al-H19 joints with additional water cooling. J
Mater Sci Technol 2017;33:1009 –14. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jmst.2017.01.016.
[127] Sree Sabari S, Malarvizhi S, Balasubramanian V. Characteristics of FSW and UWFSW joints of AA2519-T87 aluminium alloy: e ﬀect of tool rotation speed. J
Manuf Process 2016;22:278 –89. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jmapro.2016.03.014.
[128] Lin SB, Zhao YH, Wu L. Integral and layered mechanical properties of friction stir welded joints of 2014 aluminium alloy. Mater Sci Technol 2006;22(8):995 –8.
https://doi.org/10.1179/174328406X102408.
[129] Sattari S, Bisadi H, Sajed M. Mechanical properties and temperature distributions of thi

## B0232 · 第68页 · 清洗文本字符4801–6000

n friction stir welded sheets of AA5083. Int J Mech Appl 2012;2:1 –6.
https://doi.org/10.5923/j.mechanics.20120201.01.
[130] Kumar M, Kailas SV, Narayanan RG. In ﬂuence of external weld ﬂash on the in-plane plane-strain formability of friction stir welded sheets. J Strain Anal Eng Des
2013;48:376–85. https://doi.org/10.1177/0309324713488884.
[131] Ma YE, Staron P, Fischer T, Irving PE. Size e ﬀects on residual stress and fatigue crack growth in friction stir welded 2195 –T8 aluminium – Part II: Modelling. Int
J Fatigue 2011;33:1426 –34. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijfatigue.2011.05.008.
[132] Ma YE, Staron P, Fischer T, Irving PE. Size e ﬀects on residual stress and fatigue crack growth in friction stir welded 2195 –T8 aluminium – Part I: Experiments.
Int J Fatigue 2011;33:1417 –25. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijfatigue.2011.05.006.
[133] Ji S, Li Z, Wang Y, Ma L. Joint formation and mechanical properties of back heating assisted friction stir welded Ti –6Al–4V alloy. Mater Des 2017;113:37 –46.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matdes.2016.10.012.
[134] Huang Y, Meng X, Xie Y, Lv Z, Wan L, Cao J, et al. Friction spot welding of carbon ﬁber-reinforced polyetherimide laminate. Compos Struct 2018

## B0233 · 第68页 · 清洗文本字符6001–7200

;189:627 –34.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.compstruct.2018.02.004.
[135]
Azarsa E, Mostafapour A. Experimental investigation on ﬂexural behavior of friction stir welded high density polyethylene sheets. J Manuf Process
2014;16:149–55. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jmapro.2013.12.003.
[136] Eslami S, Ramos T, Tavares PJ, Moreira PMGP. Shoulder design developments for FSW lap joints of dissimilar polymers. J Manuf Process 2015;20:15 –23.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jmapro.2015.09.013.
[137] Davies PS, Wynne BP, Rainforth WM, Thomas MJ, Threadgill PL. Development of Microstructure and crystallographic texture during stationary shoulder
friction stir welding of Ti-6Al-4V. Metall Mater Trans A 2011;42:2278 –89. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11661-011-0606-2.
[138] EADS. DELTAN FS ® SYSTEM FOR FRICTION-STIR WELDING n.d. http://www.technology-licensing.com/etl/int/en/What-we-oﬀer/Technologies-for-
licensing/Metallics-and-related-manufacturing-technologies/Delta N-system-for- friction-stir-welding.html .
[139] Wu H, Chen YC, Strong D, Prangnell P. Stationary shoulder FSW for joining high strength aluminum alloys. J Mater Process Technol 2015;221:187 –96. https://
doi.org/10.1016/j.jmatprotec.2015.02.015

## B0234 · 第68页 · 清洗文本字符7201–8400

.
[140] Russell MJ, Threadgill PL, Thomas MJ, Wynne BP. Static shoulder friction stir welding of Ti-6Al-4V: process and evaluation. In: Proc. 11th World Conf.
‘Titanium,’ Kyoto, Japan; 2007.
[141] Russell MJ, Blignault C, Horrex NL, Wiesner CS. Recent developments in the friction stir welding of titanium alloys. Weld World 2013;52:12 –5. https://doi.org/
10.1007/BF03266662.
[142] Brassington WDP, Colegrove PA. Alternative friction stir welding technology for titanium –6Al–4V propellant tanks within the space industry. Sci Technol Weld
Join 2017;22:300 –18. https://doi.org/10.1080/13621718.2016.1236002.
[143] Rai R, De A, Bhadeshia HKDH, DebRoy T. Review: friction stir welding tools. Sci Technol Weld Join 2011;16:325 –42. https://doi.org/10.1179/1362171811Y.
0000000023.
[144] Ji SD, Meng XC, Liu JG, Zhang LG, Gao SS. Formation and mechanical properties of stationary shoulder friction stir welded 6005A –T6 aluminum alloy. Mater
Des 2014;62:113 –7. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matdes.2014.05.016.
[145] Li JQ, Liu HJ. E ﬀects of tool rotation speed on microstructures and mechanical properties of AA2219-T6 welded by the external non-rotational shoulder assisted
friction stir welding. Mater

## B0235 · 第68页 · 清洗文本字符8401–8838

 Des 2013;43:299 –306. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matdes.2012.07.011.
[146] Zafar A, Awang M, Khan SR, Emamian S. Investigating friction stir welding on thick Nylon 6 plates. Weld Res 2016;95:210 –8.
[147] Barmouz M, Shahi P, Asadi P. Friction stir welding/processing of polymeric materials. Adv Frict Weld Process 2014:601 –70. https://doi.org/10.1533/
9780857094551.601.
X. Meng, et al. Progress in Materials Science 115 (2021) 100706
68

## B0236 · 第69页 · 清洗文本字符1–1200

[148] Mostafapour A, Taghizad Asad F. Investigations on joining of Nylon 6 plates via novel method of heat assisted friction stir welding to ﬁnd the optimum process
parameters. Sci Technol Weld Join 2016;21:660 –9. https://doi.org/10.1080/13621718.2016.1169669.
[149] Li D, Yang X, Cui L, He F, Zhang X. Fatigue property of stationary shoulder friction stir welded additive and non-additive T joints. Sci Technol Weld Join
2015;20:650–4. https://doi.org/10.1179/1362171815Y.0000000045.
[150] Wei S, Martin J. New techniques: Robotic friction stir welding. In: 10th Int. Symp. Frict. Stir Weld., Beijing, China; 2014. p. 20 –2.
[151] Maltin CA, Nolton LJ, Scott JL, Toumpis AI, Galloway AM. The potential adaptation of stationary shoulder friction stir welding technology to steel. Mater Des
2014;64:614–24. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matdes.2014.08.017.
[152] Martin J, Stanhope C, Gascoyne S. Novel techniques for corner joints using friction stir welding. In: TMS Annu. Meet.; 2011. p. 177 –86. https://doi.org/10.
1002/9781118062302.ch22.
[153] Jesus JS, Costa JM, Loureiro A, Ferreira JM. Assessment of friction stir welding aluminium T-joints. J Mater Process Technol 2018;255:387 –99. https://do

## B0237 · 第69页 · 清洗文本字符1201–2400

i.org/
10.1016/j.jmatprotec.2017.12.036.
[154] Feistauer EE, Bergmann LA, dos Santos JF. E ﬀect of reverse material ﬂow on the microstructure and performance of friction stir welded T-joints of an Al-Mg
alloy. Mater Sci Eng A 2018;731:454 –64. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.msea.2018.06.056.
[155] Texier D, Atmani F, Bocher P, Nadeau F, Chen J, Zedan Y, et al. Fatigue performances of FSW and GMAW aluminum alloys welded joints: competition between
microstructural and structural-contact-fretting crack initiation. Int J Fatigue 2018;116:220 –33. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijfatigue.2018.06.020.
[156] Li D, Yang X, Cui L, He F, Zhang X. Investigation of stationary shoulder friction stir welding of aluminum alloy 7075– T651. J Mater Process Technol
2015;222:391–8. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jmatprotec.2015.03.036.
[157] Meng X, Jin Y, Ji S, Yan D. Improving friction stir weldability of Al/Mg alloys via ultrasonically diminishing pin adhesion. J Mater Sci Technol
2018;34:1817–22. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jmst.2018.02.022.
[158] Liu Z, Meng X, Ji S, Li Z, Wang L. Improving tensile properties of Al/Mg joint by smashing intermetallic compounds via ultrasonic-assisted stationary shoulder
friction 

## B0238 · 第69页 · 清洗文本字符2401–3600

stir welding. J Manuf Process 2018;31:552 –9. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jmapro.2017.12.022.
[159] Huang Y, Meng X, Xie Y, Li J, Wan L. Joining of carbon ﬁber reinforced thermoplastic and metal via friction stir welding with co-controlling shape and
performance. Compos Part A Appl Sci Manuf 2018;112:328 –36. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.compositesa.2018.06.027.
[160] Ji SD, Meng XC, Li ZW, Ma L, Gao SS. Experimental study of stationary shoulder friction stir welded 7N01-T4 aluminum alloy. J Mater Eng Perform
2016;25:1228–36. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11665-016-1954-2.
[161] Shah LH, Othman NH, Gerlich A. Review of research progress on aluminium –magnesium dissimilar friction stir welding. Sci Technol Weld Join
2017;1718:1–15. https://doi.org/10.1080/13621718.2017.1370193.
[162] Strand S. E ﬀects of friction stir welding on polymer microstructure. Brigham Young University; 2004.
[163] Ji S, Li Z, Zhang L, Zhou Z, Chai P. E ﬀect of lap conﬁ guration on magnesium to aluminum friction stir lap welding assisted by external stationary shoulder.
Mater Des 2016;103:160 –70. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matdes.2016.04.066.
[164] Ji S, Meng X, Liu Z, Huang R, Li Z. Dissimilar friction stir welding o

## B0239 · 第69页 · 清洗文本字符3601–4800

f 6061 aluminum alloy and AZ31 magnesium alloy assisted with ultrasonic. Mater Lett
2017;201:173–6. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matlet.2017.05.011.
[165] Meng X, Jin Y, Ji S, Yan D. Improving friction stir weldability of Al/Mg alloys via ultrasonically diminishing pin adhesion. J Mater Sci Technol 2018;34. https://
doi.org/10.1016/j.jmst.2018.02.022.
[166] Meng X, Xu Z, Huang Y, Xie Y, Wang Y, Wan L, et al. Interface characteristic and tensile property of friction stir lap welding of dissimilar aircraft 2060 –T8 and
2099–T83 Al– Li alloys. Int J Adv Manuf Technol 2018;94:1253 –61. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00170-017-0996-4.
[167] Ji S, Li Z. Microstructure and mechanical properties of friction stir lap welded Mg/Al joint assisted by stationary shoulder. Met Mater Int 2017;23:1158 –67.
https://doi.org/10.1007/s12540-017-7065-2.
[168] Yue Y, Zhou Z, Ji S, Zhang J, Li Z. E ﬀect of welding speed on joint feature and mechanical properties of friction stir lap welding assisted by external stationary
shoulders. Int J Adv Manuf Technol 2017;89:1691 –8. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00170-016-9240-x.
[169] Li Z, Yue Y, Ji S, Chai P, Zhou Z. Joint features and mechanical properties of friction stir 

## B0240 · 第69页 · 清洗文本字符4801–6000

lap welded alclad 2024 aluminum alloy assisted by external stationary
shoulder. Mater Des 2016;90:238 –47. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matdes.2015.10.056.
[170] Wen Q, Li WY, Wang WB, Wang FF, Gao YJ, Patel V. Experimental and numerical investigations of bonding interface behavior in stationary shoulder friction
stir lap welding. J Mater Sci Technol 2019;35:192 –200. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jmst.2018.09.028.
[171] Ahmed MMZ, Wynne BP, Rainforth WM, Threadgill PL. Through-thickness crystallographic texture of stationary shoulder friction stir welded aluminium. Scr
Mater 2011;64:45 –8. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scriptamat.2010.08.060.
[172] Li D, Yang X, Cui L, He F, Shen H. E ﬀect of welding parameters on microstructure and mechanical properties of AA6061-T6 butt welded joints by stationary
shoulder friction stir welding. Mater Des 2014;64:251 –60. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matdes.2014.07.046.
[173] Sun T, Roy MJ, Strong D, Withers PJ, Prangnell PB. Comparison of residual stress distributions in conventional and stationary shoulder high-strength aluminum
alloy friction stir welds. J Mater Process Tech 2017;242:92 –100. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jmatprotec.2016.11.015.
[174] Sun T, T

## B0241 · 第69页 · 清洗文本字符6001–7200

remsin AS, Roy MJ, Hofmann M, Prangnell PB, Withers PJ. Investigation of residual stress distribution and texture evolution in AA7050 stationary
shoulder friction stir welded joints. Mater Sci Eng A 2018;712:531 –8. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.msea.2017.12.019.
[175] Barbini A, Carstensen J, dos Santos JF. In ﬂuence of a non-rotating shoulder on heat generation, microstructure and mechanical properties of dissimilar
AA2024/AA7050 FSW joints. J Mater Sci Technol 2017;34:119 –27. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jmst.2017.10.017.
[176] Regensburg A, Schürer R, Weigl M, Bergmann J. In ﬂuence of pin length and electrochemical platings on the mechanical strength and macroscopic defect
formation
in stationary shoulder friction stir welding of aluminium to copper. Metals (Basel) 2018;8:2 –9. https://doi.org/10.3390/met8020085.
[177] Mostafapour Amir. A study on the role of processing parameters in joining polyethylene sheets via heat assisted friction stir welding: Investigating micro-
structure, tensile and ﬂexural properties. Int J Phys Sci 2012;7.. https://doi.org/10.5897/IJPS11.1653.
[178] Kiss Z, Czigany T. Microscopic analysis of the morphology of seams in friction stir welded polypropylene.

## B0242 · 第69页 · 清洗文本字符7201–8400

 Express Polym Lett 2012;6:54 –62. https://doi.org/10.
3144/expresspolymlett.2012.6.
[179] Bagheri A, Azdast T, Doniavi A. An experimental study on mechanical properties of friction stir welded ABS sheets. Mater Des 2013;43:402 –9. https://doi.org/
10.1016/j.matdes.2012.06.059.
[180] Rahbarpour R, Azdast T, Rahbarpour H, Shishavan SM. Feasibility study of friction stir welding of wood –plastic composites. Sci Technol Weld Join
2014;19:673–81. https://doi.org/10.1179/1362171814Y.0000000233.
[181] Mendes N, Loureiro A, Martins C, Neto P, Pires JN. Morphology and strength of acrylonitrile butadiene styrene welds performed by robotic friction stir welding.
Mater Des 2014;64:81 –90. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matdes.2014.07.047.
[182] Czigány T, Kiss Z. Friction stir welding of ﬁber reinforced polymer composites. In: 18th Int. Conf. Compos. Mater.; 2015.
[183] Eslami S, Mourão L, Viriato N, Tavares PJ, Moreira PMGP. Multi-axis force measurements of polymer friction stir welding. J Mater Process Technol
2018;256:51–6. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jmatprotec.2018.01.044.
[184] Ji S, Li Z, Zhang L, Wang Y. Eliminating the tearing defect in Ti-6Al-4V alloy joint by back heating assisted frictio

## B0243 · 第69页 · 清洗文本字符8401–9382

n stir welding. Mater Lett 2017;188:21 –4.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matlet.2016.10.032.
[185] Zhou L, Liu HJ, Liu QW. E ﬀect of process parameters on stir zone microstructure in Ti-6Al-4V friction stir welds. J Mater Sci 2010;45:39 –45. https://doi.org/10.
1007/s10853-009-3881-1.
[186] Pilchak AL, Juhas MC, Williams JC. Microstructural changes due to friction stir processing of investment-cast Ti-6Al-4V. Metall Mater Trans A Phys Metall
Mater Sci 2007;38:401 –8. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11661-006-9061-x.
[187] Knipling KE, Fonda RW. Microstructural evolution in Ti-5111 friction stir welds. Metall Mater Trans A 2011;42:2312 –22. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11661-011-
0630-2.
[188] Avettand-Fènoël MN, Taillard R. E ﬀect of a pre or postweld heat treatment on microstructure and mechanical properties of an AA2050 weld obtained by
SSFSW. Mater Des 2016;89:348 –61. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matdes.2015.09.151.
X. Meng, et al. Progress in Materials Science 115 (2021) 100706
69

## B0244 · 第70页 · 清洗文本字符1–1200

[189] Ma ZY, Feng AH, Chen DL, Shen J. Recent advances in friction stir welding/processing of aluminum alloys: microstructural evolution and mechanical prop-
erties. Crit Rev Solid State Mater Sci 2017;8436:1 –65. https://doi.org/10.1080/10408436.2017.1358145.
[190] Leng L, Zhang ZJ, Duan QQ, Zhang P, Zhang ZF. Improving the fatigue strength of 7075 alloy through aging. Mater Sci Eng A 2018;738:24 –30. https://doi.org/
10.1016/j.msea.2018.09.047.
[191] Ferragut R, Somoza A, Tolley A. Microstructural evolution of 7012 alloy during the early stages of arti ﬁcial ageing. Acta Mater 1999;47:4355 –64. https://doi.
org/10.1016/S1359-6454(99)00315-8.
[192] Berg LK, Gjoønnes J, Hansen V, Li XZ, Knutson-Wedel M, Waterloo G, et al. GP-zones in Al-Zn-Mg alloys and their role in arti ﬁcial aging. Acta Mater
2001;49:3443–51. https://doi.org/10.1016/S1359-6454(01)00251-8.
[193] Sun Z, Yang X, Li D, Cui L. The local strength and toughness for stationary shoulder friction stir weld on AA6061-T6 alloy. Mater Charact 2016;111:114 –21.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matchar.2015.11.020.
[194] Arici A, Sinmazçelýk T. E ﬀects of double passes of the tool on friction stir welding of polyethylene. J Mater Sci

## B0245 · 第70页 · 清洗文本字符1201–2400

 2005;40:3313 –6. https://doi.org/10.1007/
s10853-005-2709-x.
[195] Arici A, Selale S. E ﬀects of tool tilt angle on tensile strength and fracture locations of friction stir welding of polyethylene. Sci Technol Weld Join
2007;12:536–9. https://doi.org/10.1179/174329307X173706.
[196] Huang Y, Meng X, Xie Y, Wan L, Lv Z, Cao J, et al. Friction stir welding/processing of polymers and polymer matrix composites. Compos Part A Appl Sci Manuf
2018;105:235–57. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.compositesa.2017.12.005.
[197] Gao J, Shen Y, Zhang J, Xu H. Submerged friction stir weld of polyethylene sheets. J Appl Polym Sci 2014;41059:1 –8. https://doi.org/10.1002/app.41059.
[198] He X, Gu F, Ball A. A review of numerical analysis of friction stir welding. Prog Mater Sci 2014;65:1 –66. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.pmatsci.2014.03.003.
[199] Chen G, Li H, Wang G, Guo Z, Zhang S, Dai Q, et al. E ﬀects of pin thread on the in-process material ﬂow behavior during friction stir welding: a computational
ﬂuid dynamics study. Int J Mach Tools Manuf 2018;124:12 –21. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijmachtools.2017.09.002.
[200] Chen G, Ma Q, Zhang S, Wu J, Zhang G, Shi Q. Computational ﬂuid dynamics simulation of fri

## B0246 · 第70页 · 清洗文本字符2401–3600

ction stir welding: a comparative study on di ﬀerent frictional
boundary conditions. J Mater Sci Technol 2017;34:128 –34. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jmst.2017.10.015.
[201] Li JQ, Liu HJ. Design of tool system for the external nonrotational shoulder assisted friction stir welding and its experimental validations on 2219 –T6 aluminum
alloy. Int J Adv Manuf Technol 2013;66:623 –34. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00170-012-4353-3.
[202] Chu K, Wang X, Wang F, Li Y, Huang D, Liu H, et al. Largely enhanced thermal conductivity of graphene/copper composites with highly aligned graphene
network. Carbon N Y 2018;127:102 –12. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.carbon.2017.10.099.
[203]
Li H, Dai S, Miao J, Wu X, Chandrasekharan N, Qiu H, et al. Enhanced thermal conductivity of graphene/polyimide hybrid ﬁlm via a novel “molecular welding”
strategy. Carbon N Y 2018;126:319 –27. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.carbon.2017.10.044.
[204] Chung SH, Kim H, Jeong SW. Improved thermal conductivity of carbon-based thermal interface materials by high-magnetic- ﬁeld alignment. Carbon N Y
2018;140:24–9. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.carbon.2018.08.029.
[205] Aydin M. E ﬀects of welding parameters and pre-heating on the friction 

## B0247 · 第70页 · 清洗文本字符3601–4800

stir welding of UHMW-polyethylene. Polym Plast Technol Eng 2010;49:595 –601.
https://doi.org/10.1080/03602551003664503.
[206] Vijendra B, Sharma A. Induction heated tool assisted friction-stir welding (i-FSW): A novel hybrid process for joining of thermoplastics. J Manuf Process
2015;20:234–44. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jmapro.2015.07.005.
[207] Liu Z, Ji S, Meng X. Joining of magnesium and aluminum alloys via ultrasonic assisted friction stir welding at low temperature. Int J Adv Manuf Technol
2018;97:4127–36. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00170-018-2255-8.
[208] Ji S, Li Z, Zhou Z, Zhang L. Microstructure and mechanical property di ﬀerences between friction stir lap welded joints using rotating and stationary shoulders.
Int J Adv Manuf Technol 2017;90:3045 –53. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00170-016-9640-y.
[209] Jayaraman N, Prevéy P, Mahoney M. Fatigue life improvement of an aluminum alloy FSW with low plasticity burnishing. In: Proc. 132nd TMS Annu. Meet., San
Diego, CA; 2003. p. 1 –10.
[210] Huang Y, Wan L, Lv S, Zhang J, Fu G. In situ rolling friction stir welding for joining AA2219. Mater Des 2013;50:810 –6. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matdes.
2013.03.088.
[211] Huang Y, Wan L, Lv S, 

## B0248 · 第70页 · 清洗文本字符4801–6000

Liu H, Feng J. Gradient micro-structured surface layer on aluminum alloy fabricated by in situ rolling friction stir welding. Mater Des
2013;52:821–7. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matdes.2013.06.026.
[212] Huang YX, Wan L, Lv SX, Zhang Z, Liu HJ. New technique of in situ rolling friction stir welding. Sci Technol Weld Join 2012;17:636 –42. https://doi.org/10.
1179/1362171812Y.0000000056.
[213] Ji S, Meng X, Ma L, Lu H, Gao S. Vertical compensation friction stir welding assisted by external stationary shoulder. Mater Des 2015;68:72 –9. https://doi.org/
10.1016/j.matdes.2014.12.009.
[214] Zhang H, Wang M, Zhou W, Zhang X, Zhu Z, Yu T, et al. Microstructure-property characteristics of a novel non-weld-thinning friction stir welding process of
aluminum alloys. Mater Des 2015;86:379 –87. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matdes.2015.06.106.
[215] Wang M, Zhang H, Yu T, Zhu Z, Zhang X, Yang G. In ﬂuence and aﬀecting mechanism of tool pin geometrical con ﬁguration on weld formation during non-tilting
friction stir welding. J Mech Eng 2017;53:63. https://doi.org/10.3901/JME.2017.18.057.
[216] Guan M, Wang Y, Huang Y, Liu X, Meng X, Xie Y, et al. Non-weld-thinning friction stir welding. Mater Lett 201

## B0249 · 第70页 · 清洗文本字符6001–7200

9;255:126506 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matlet.
2019.126506.
[217]
Zhang HJ, Wang M, Zhu Z, Zhang X, Yu T, Yang GX. Improving the structure-property of aluminum alloy friction stir weld by using a non-shoulder-plunge
welding tool. Int J Adv Manuf Technol 2016;87:1095 –104. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00170-016-8599-z.
[218] Huang Y, Meng X, Xie Y, Li J, Si X, Fan Q. Improving mechanical properties of composite/metal friction stir lap welding joints via a taper-screwed pin with
triple facets. J Mater Process Technol 2019;268:80 –6. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jmatprotec.2019.01.011.
[219] Xu W, Liu J, Luan G, Dong C. Temperature evolution, microstructure and mechanical properties of friction stir welded thick 2219-O aluminum alloy joints.
Mater Des 2009;30:1886 –93. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matdes.2008.09.021.
[220] Çam G, Mistikoglu S. Recent developments in friction stir welding of Al-Alloys. J Mater Eng Perform 2014;23:1936 –53. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11665-014-
0968-x.
[221] Sandnes L, Grong Ø, Torgersen J, Welo T, Berto F. Exploring the hybrid metal extrusion and bonding process for butt welding of Al –Mg–Si alloys. 1067–1067 Int
J Adv Manuf Technol 2018;98. https://doi.org/10.100

## B0250 · 第70页 · 清洗文本字符7201–8400

7/s00170-018-2397-8.
[222] Li N, Li W, Yang X, Xu Y, Vairis A. Corrosion characteristics and wear performance of cold sprayed coatings of reinforced Al deposited onto friction stir welded
AA2024-T3 joints. Surf Coat Technol 2018;349:1069 –76. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.surfcoat.2018.06.058.
[223] Li N, Li WY, Yang XW, Feng Y, Vairis A. An investigation into the mechanism for enhanced mechanical properties in friction stir welded AA2024-T3 joints
coated with cold spraying. Appl Surf Sci 2018;439:623 –31. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.apsusc.2018.01.049.
[224] Huang Y, Han B, Lv S, Wan L, Liu H, Feng J. In-situ additive friction stir welding method for eliminating weld-thining. CN103157903A; 2013.
[225] Li W, Assadi H, Gaertner F, Yin S. A review of advanced composite and nanostructured coatings by solid-state cold spraying process. Crit Rev Solid State Mater
Sci 2018;8436:1 –48. https://doi.org/10.1080/10408436.2017.1410778.
[226] Ogura T, Saito Y, Nishida T, Nishida H, Yoshida T, Omichi N, et al. Partitioning evaluation of mechanical properties and the interfacial microstructure in a
friction stir welded aluminum alloy/stainless steel lap joint. Scr Mater 2012;66:531 –4. https://doi.org

## B0251 · 第70页 · 清洗文本字符8401–9131

/10.1016/j.scriptamat.2011.12.035.
[227] Meng X, Gao S, Ma L, Li Z, Yue Y, Xiao H. E ﬀects of rotational velocity on microstructures and mechanical properties of surface compensation friction stir
welded 6005A –T6 aluminum alloy. Eng Rev 2016;36:107 –13.
[228] Wen Q, Yue Y, Ji S, Li Z, Gao S. E ﬀect of welding speeds on mechanical properties of level compensation friction stir welded 6061– T6 aluminum alloy. High
Temp Mater Process 2016;35:375 –9. https://doi.org/10.1515/htmp-2014-0220.
[229] Liu H, Fujii H, Maeda M, Nogi K. Heterogeneity of mechanical properties of friction stir welded joints of 1050– H24 aluminum alloy. J Mater Sci Technol
2003;22:441–4.
X. Meng, et al. Progress in Materials Science 115 (2021) 100706
70

## B0252 · 第71页 · 清洗文本字符1–1200

[230] Korayem AH, Chen SJ, Zhang QH, Li CY, Zhao XL, Duan WH. Failure of CFRP-to-steel double strap joint bonded using carbon nanotubes modi ﬁed epoxy
adhesive at moderately elevated temperatures. Compos Part B Eng 2016;94:95 –101. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.compositesb.2016.03.042.
[231] Wang W, Lin S, H Z. Friction stir welding method for eliminating weld thinning by using additional T-plate, involves obtaining ﬂat weld and completing friction
stir welding of ﬁrst to-be-welded plate and second to-be-welded plate using additional T-plate; 2018.
[232] Kuang B, Shen Y, Chen W, Yao X, Xu H, Gao J, et al. The dissimilar friction stir lap welding of 1A99 Al to pure Cu using Zn as ﬁller metal with “pinless” tool
conﬁguration. Mater Des 2015;68:54 –62. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matdes.2014.12.008.
[233] Ji SD, Meng XC, Ma L, Gao SS. E ﬀect of groove distribution in shoulder on formation, macrostructures, and mechanical properties of pinless friction stir welding
of 6061-O aluminum alloy. Int J Adv Manuf Technol 2016;87:3051 –8. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00170-016-8734-x.
[234] Yang XW, Fu T, Li WY. Friction stir spot welding: a review on joint macro- and microstructure, property, and proce

## B0253 · 第71页 · 清洗文本字符1201–2400

ss modelling. Adv Mater Sci Eng
2014;2014:1–11. https://doi.org/10.1155/2014/697170.
[235] Acerra F, Bu ﬀa G, Fratini L, Troiano G. On the FSW of AA2024-T4 and AA7075-T6 T-joints: an industrial case study. Int J Adv Manuf Technol 2010;48:1149 –57.
https://doi.org/10.1007/s00170-009-2344-9.
[236] Li B, Shen Y. A feasibility research on friction stir welding of a new-typed lap-butt joint of dissimilar Al alloys. Mater Des 2012;34:725 –31. https://doi.org/10.
1016/j.matdes.2011.05.033.
[237] TWI. Weld repair, reclamation and recti ﬁcation n.d. https://www.twi-global.com/capabilities/joining-technologies/weld-repair-reclamation-and-
rectiﬁcation/.
[238] Feng C, Liang J, Gong C, Pai W, Liu S. Repair volume extraction method for damaged parts in remanufacturing repair. Int J Adv Manuf Technol
2018;98:1523–36. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00170-018-2300-7.
[239] Chai Q, Xiao Z, Lai K, Hung, Zhou G. Can carbon cap and trade mechanism be bene ﬁcial for remanufacturing? Int J Prod Econ 2018;203:311 –21. https://doi.
org/10.1016/j.ijpe.2018.07.004.
[240] Wu X. Research on design management based on green remanufacturing engineering. Syst Eng Procedia 2012;4:448 –54. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.sepr

## B0254 · 第71页 · 清洗文本字符2401–3600

o.2012.
01.009.
[241] Heidarzadeh A, Jabbari M, Esmaily M. Prediction of grain size and mechanical properties in friction stir welded pure copper joints using a thermal model. Int J
Adv Manuf Technol 2015;77:1819 –29. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00170-014-6543-7.
[242] Sharma V, Prakash U, Kumar BVM. Surface composites by friction stir processing: a review. J Mater Process Technol 2015;224:117 –34. https://doi.org/10.
1016/j.jmatprotec.2015.04.019.
[243] Ji S, Meng X, Zeng Y, Ma L, Gao S. New technique for eliminating keyhole by active-passive ﬁlling friction stir repairing. Mater Des 2016;97:175 –82. https://
doi.org/10.1016/j.matdes.2016.02.088.
[244]
Teimurnezhad J, Pashazadeh H, Masumi A. E ﬀect of shoulder plunge depth on the weld morphology, macrograph and microstructure of copper FSW joints. J
Manuf Process 2016;22:254 –9. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jmapro.2016.04.001.
[245] Khan NZ, Siddiquee AN, Khan ZA, Shihab SK. Investigations on tunneling and kissing bond defects in FSW joints for dissimilar aluminum alloys. J Alloys Compd
2015;648:360–7. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jallcom.2015.06.246.
[246] Zheng Q, Feng X, Shen Y, Huang G, Zhao P. E ﬀect of plunge depth on microstructure 

## B0255 · 第71页 · 清洗文本字符3601–4800

and mechanical properties of FSW lap joint between aluminum alloy and
nickel-base alloy. J Alloys Compd 2017;695:952 –61. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jallcom.2016.10.213.
[247] Zhou N, Song D, Qi W, Li X, Zou J, Attallah MM. In ﬂuence of the kissing bond on the mechanical properties and fracture behaviour of AA5083-H112 friction stir
welds. Mater Sci Eng A 2018;719:12 –20. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.msea.2018.02.011.
[248] Han B, Huang Y, Lv S, Wan L, Feng J, Fu G. AA7075 bit for repairing AA2219 keyhole by ﬁlling friction stir welding. Mater Des 2013;51:25 –33. https://doi.org/
10.1016/j.matdes.2013.03.089.
[249] Arbegast WJ. A ﬂow-partitioned deformation zone model for defect formation during friction stir welding. Scr Mater 2008;58:372 –6. https://doi.org/10.1016/
j.scriptamat.2007.10.031.
[250] Tao Y, Zhang Z, Ni DR, Wang D, Xiao BL, Ma ZY. In ﬂuence of welding parameter on mechanical properties and fracture behavior of friction stir welded Al-Mg-
Sc joints. Mater Sci Eng A 2014;612:236 –45. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.msea.2014.06.051.
[251] Zeng KW, Su ZM, Luo SM, Lin PC, Dong MT, Tang T, et al. Removing approach for ﬂashes of friction stir spot welds. J Mater Process Technol
2013

## B0256 · 第71页 · 清洗文本字符4801–6000

;213:1725–33. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jmatprotec.2013.03.019.
[252] Shultz EF, Cole EG, Smith CB, Zinn MR, Ferrier NJ, Pfeﬀ erkorn FE. E ﬀect of compliance and travel angle on friction stir welding with gaps. J Manuf Sci Eng
2010;132:041010https://doi.org/10.1115/1.4001581.
[253] Wanjara P, Monsarrat B, Larose S. Gap tolerance allowance and robotic operational window for friction stir butt welding of AA6061. J Mater Process Technol
2013;213:631–40. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jmatprotec.2012.10.010.
[254] Yang Y, Kalya P, Landers RG, Krishnamurthy K. Automatic gap detection in friction stir butt welding operations. Int J Mach Tools Manuf 2008;48:1161 –9.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijmachtools.2008.01.007.
[255] Liu XC, Wu CS. Elimination of tunnel defect in ultrasonic vibration enhanced friction stir welding. Mater Des 2016;90:350 –8. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.
matdes.2015.10.131.
[256] Sahlot Pankaj, Jha Kaushal, Dey GK, Arora Amit. Quantitative wear analysis of H13 steel tool during friction stir welding of Cu-0.8%Cr-0.1%Zr alloy. Wear
2017;378-379:82–9. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.wear.2017.02.009.
[257] Sahlot P, Arora A. Numerical model for prediction of tool wear and worn-out pi

## B0257 · 第71页 · 清洗文本字符6001–7200

n pro ﬁle during friction stir welding. Wear 2018;408 –409:96–107. https://doi.
org/10.1016/j.wear.2018.05.007.
[258] Salih OS, Ou H, Sun W, McCartney DG. A review of friction stir welding of aluminium matrix composites. Mater Des 2015;86:61 –71. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.
matdes.2015.07.071.
[259] Bist A, Saini JS, Sharma B. A review of tool wear prediction during friction stir welding of aluminium matrix composite. Trans Nonferrous Met Soc China
2016;26:2003–18. https://doi.org/10.1016/S1003-6326(16)64318-2.
[260] Zhang YN, Cao X, Larose S, Wanjara P. Review of tools for friction stir welding and processing. Can Metall Q 2012;51:250 –61. https://doi.org/10.1179/
1879139512Y.0000000015.
[261] Avettand-Fènoël MN, Simar A. A review about friction stir welding of metal matrix composites. Mater Charact 2016;120:1 –17. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.
matchar.2016.07.010.
[262] Ji S, Huang R, Zhang L, Meng X, Lv Z. Microstructure and mechanical properties of friction stir repaired Al –Cu casting alloy. Trans Indian Inst Met
2018;71:2057–65. https://doi.org/10.1007/s12666-018-1340-x.
[263] Li W, Diao G, Liang Z, Wang D. Repair welding of tunnel defect in friction stir weld of Al-Zn-Mg alloys.

## B0258 · 第71页 · 清洗文本字符7201–8400

In: Int. Conf. Mech. Eng. Control Autom.; 2017. p. 202 –7.
https://doi.org/10.12783/dtetr/icmeca2017/11934.
[264] Gunter C, Miles MP, Liu FC, Nelson TW. Solid state crack repair by friction stir processing in 304L stainless steel. J Mater Sci Technol 2017;34:140 –7. https://
doi.org/10.1016/j.jmst.2017.10.023.
[265] Li Z, Han K, Liu C, Huang C, Chang Z, Wu H, et al. Repair welding of defects in 2219 Al alloy friction stir welded joints. J Aeronaut Mater 2016;36:26 –32.
[266] Liu H, Zhang H. Repair welding process of friction stir welding groove defect. Trans Nonferrous Met Soc China 2009;19:563 –7. https://doi.org/10.1016/S1003-
6326(08)60313-1.
[267] Liu HJ, Zhang HJ. Study of hybrid welding repair process of friction stir welding grove defect. Sci Technol Weld Join 2012;17:169 –73. https://doi.org/10.
1179/136217111X13218932822646.
[268] Ji SD, Meng XC, Li ZW, Ma L, Gao SS. Investigation of vertical compensation friction stir-welded 7N01-T4 aluminum alloy. Int J Adv Manuf Technol 2016;84.
https://doi.org/10.1007/s00170-015-7904-6.
[269] Abu-Okail M, Ata MH, Abu-oqail A, Essa GMF, Mahmoud TS, Hassab-Allah I. Production of tailor-welded blanks by vertical compensation friction stir

## B0259 · 第71页 · 清洗文本字符8401–8569

 welding
technique. Mater Sci Technol 2018;34:2030 –41. https://doi.org/10.1080/02670836.2018.1510070.
X. Meng, et al. Progress in Materials Science 115 (2021) 100706
71

## B0260 · 第72页 · 清洗文本字符1–1200

[270] Huang YX, Han B, Tian Y, Liu HJ, Lv SX, Feng JC, et al. New technique of ﬁlling friction stir welding. Sci Technol Weld Join 2011;16:497 –501. https://doi.org/
10.1179/1362171811Y.0000000032.
[271] Du B, Sun Z, Yang X, Cui L, Song J, Zhang Z. Characteristics of friction plug welding to 10mm thick AA2219-T87 sheet: weld formation, microstructure and
mechanical property. Mater Sci Eng A 2016;654:21 –9. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.msea.2015.12.019.
[272] Metz DF, Barkey ME. Fatigue behavior of friction plug welds in 2195 Al-Li alloy. Int J Fatigue 2012;43:178 –87. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijfatigue.2012.04.
002.
[273] Behmand SA, Mirsalehi SE, Omidvar H, Safarkhanian MA. Filling exit holes of friction stir welding lap joints using consumable pin tools. Sci Technol Weld Join
2015;20:330–6. https://doi.org/10.1179/1362171815Y.0000000018.
[274] Zhou L, Nakata K, Tsumura T, Fujii H, Ikeuchi K, Michishita Y, et al. Microstructure and mechanical properties of 316L stainless steel ﬁlling friction stir-welded
joints. J Mater Eng Perform 2014;23:3718 –26. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11665-014-1124-3.
[275] Zhou L, Liu D, Nakata K, Tsumura T, Fujii H, Ikeuchi K, et al. New technique of self-r

## B0261 · 第72页 · 清洗文本字符1201–2400

e ﬁlling friction stir welding to repair keyhole. Sci Technol Weld Join
2012;17:649–55. https://doi.org/10.1179/1362171812Y.0000000058.
[276] Xiong J, Yang X, Lin W, Liu K. Evaluation of inhomogeneity in tensile strength and fracture toughness of underwater wet friction taper plug welded joints for
low-alloy pipeline steels. J Manuf Process 2018;32:280 –7. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jmapro.2018.02.016.
[277] Yin Y, Yang X, Cui L, Wang F, Li S. Material ﬂow in ﬂuence on the weld formation and mechanical performance in underwater friction taper plug welds for
pipeline steel. Mater Des 2015;88:990 –8. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matdes.2015.09.123.
[278] Mukherjee S, Ghosh AK. Friction stir processing of direct metal deposited copper-nickel 70/30. Mater Sci Eng A 2011;528:3289 –94. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.
msea.2011.01.063.
[279] Ji SD, Meng XC, Huang RF, Ma L, Gao SS. Microstructures and mechanical properties of 7N01-T4 aluminum alloy joints by active-passive ﬁlling friction stir
repairing. Mater Sci Eng A 2016;664:94 –102. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.msea.2016.03.131.
[280] Huang R, Ji S, Meng X, Li Z. Drilling- ﬁlling friction stir repairing of AZ31B magnesium alloy. J Mater Process T

## B0262 · 第72页 · 清洗文本字符2401–3600

echnol 2018;255:765 –72. https://doi.org/10.
1016/j.jmatprotec.2018.01.019.
[281] Niu S, Wu B, Ma L, Lv Z, Yan D. Passive ﬁlling friction stir repairing AZ31-B magnesium alloy by external stationary shoulder. Int J Adv Manuf Technol
2018;97:2461–8. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00170-018-2130-7.
[282] Reimann M, Gartner T, Suhuddin U, Göbel J, Dos Santos JF. Keyhole closure using friction spot welding in aluminum alloy 6061 –T6. J Mater Process Technol
2016;237:12–8. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jmatprotec.2016.05.013.
[283] Reimann M, Goebel J, Gartner TM, dos Santos JF. Re ﬁlling termination hole in AA 2198 –T851 by re ﬁll friction stir spot welding. J Mater Process Technol
2017;245:157–66. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jmatprotec.2017.02.025.
[284] Reimann M, Goebel J, dos Santos JF. Microstructure and mechanical properties of keyhole repair welds in AA 7075– T651 using re ﬁll friction stir spot welding.
Mater Des 2017;132:283 –94. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matdes.2017.07.013.
[285] Saeedy S, Besharati Givi MK. Experimental Investigation of Double Side Friction Stir Welding (FSW) on High Density Polyethylene Blanks. In: ASME 2010 10th
Bienn. Conf. Eng. Syst. Des. Anal. vol. 4; 2010. p. 845 

## B0263 · 第72页 · 清洗文本字符3601–4800

–8. https://doi.org/10.1115/ESDA2010-25346.
[286] Cabibbo M, Forcellese A, El Mehtedi M, Simoncini M. Double side friction stir welding of AA6082 sheets: microstructure and nanoindentation characterization.
Mater Sci Eng A 2014;590:209 –17. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.msea.2013.10.031.
[287] Widener CA. High-rotational speed friction stir welding with a ﬁxed shoulder. In: 6th Int. Syposium Frict. Stir Weld., Montreal, Canada; 2006. p. 1 –45.
[288] Ji S, Meng X, Xing J, Ma L, Gao S. Vertical compensation friction stir welding of 6061 –T6 aluminum alloy. High Temp Mater Process 2016;35:843 –51. https://
doi.org/10.1515/htmp-2015-0063.
[289] Park SK, Hong ST, Park JH, Park KY, Kwon YJ, Son HJ. E ﬀect of material locations on properties of friction stir welding joints of dissimilar aluminium alloys. Sci
Technol Weld Join 2010;15:331 –6. https://doi.org/10.1179/136217110X12714217309696.
[290] Yoon TJ, Kang CY. Observations on metallurgical phenomena and formation of onion ring nugget during friction stir lap welding of dissimilar aluminum by a
new 3D technique. Mater Lett 2015;142:253 –7. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matlet.2014.12.033.
[291] Yoon TJ, Yun JG, Kang CY. Formation mechanism of 

## B0264 · 第72页 · 清洗文本字符4801–6000

typical onion ring structures and void defects in friction stir lap welded dissimilar aluminum alloys. Mater
Des 2016;90:568 –78. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matdes.2015.11.014.
[292] Krishnan KN. On the formation of onion rings in friction stir welds. Mater Sci Eng A 2002;327:246 –51. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0921-5093(01)01474-5.
[293] Liu FC, Nelson TW. In-situ material ﬂow pattern around probe during friction stir welding of austenitic stainless steel. Mater Des 2016;110:354 –64. https://doi.
org/10.1016/j.matdes.2016.07.147.
[294] Venkateswaran P, Reynolds AP. Factors a ﬀecting the properties of Friction Stir Welds between aluminum and magnesium alloys. Mater Sci Eng A
2012;545:26–37. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.msea.2012.02.069.
[295] Liu FC, Nelson TW. In-situ grain structure and texture evolution during friction stir welding of austenite stainless steel. Mater Des 2017;115:467 –78. https://
doi.org/10.1016/j.matdes.2016.11.066.
[296] McNelley TR, Swaminathan S, Su JQ. Recrystallization mechanisms during friction stir welding/processing of aluminum alloys. Scr Mater 2008;58:349 –54.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scriptamat.2007.09.064.
[297] Dolatkhah A, Golbabaei P, Besharati Givi 

## B0265 · 第72页 · 清洗文本字符6001–7200

MK, Molaiekiya F. Investigating e ﬀects of process parameters on microstructural and mechanical properties of
Al5052/SiC metal matrix composite fabricated via friction stir processing. Mater Des 2012;37:458 –64. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matdes.2011.09.035.
[298] Izadi H, Sandstrom R, Gerlich AP. Grain growth behavior and Hall-Petch strengthening in friction stir processed Al 5059. Metall Mater Trans A Phys Metall
Mater Sci 2014;45:5635 –44. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11661-014-2492-x.
[299] Dunkerton S, Nicholas D, Sketchley P. Repairing defective metal workpiece-by friction welding with a metal plug. 9125978; 1991.
[300] Coletta ER, Cantrell MA, McCool A. Friction plug weld repair geometric innovations; 2017. https://NtrsNasaGov/SearchJsp?R=20000112928.
[301] Li Z, Cantrell M, Brown R, McCool A. Process development and microstrutural characterization plug welded 2195 and 2219 alloys; 2000. https://NtrsNasaGov/
SearchJsp?R=20000089963.
[302] Hartley PJ. Frition plug weld repair geometric innovations; 2017. https://NtrsNasaGov/SearchJsp?R=20000093962.
[303] Metz DF, Weishaupt ER, Barkey ME, Fairbee BS. A microstructure and microhardness characterization of a friction plug weld in fri

## B0266 · 第72页 · 清洗文本字符7201–8400

ction stir welded 2195 Al-Li. J
Eng Mater Technol 2012;134:021005 https://doi.org/10.1115/1.4006066.
[304] Metz DF, Barkey ME, Bradt RC, Hubner JP, Weaver ML, Jackson JE, et al. Experimental and numerical characterization of the fatigue and fracture properties of
friction plug welds in 2195-T8 aluminum lithium alloy. The University of Alabama; 2013.
[305] Lange M, Schwenker S. Friction plug welding of 2024-T3 Aluminum. In: Proc. Aircr. Struct. Integr. Conf., San Antoni; 2014.
[306] Du B, Cui L, Yang X, Wang D, Sun Z. Weakening mechanism and tensile fracture behavior of AA 2219– T87 friction plug welds. Mater Sci Eng A
2017;693:129–35. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.msea.2017.03.093.
[307] Mission Success Bulletin, Lockheed Martin Space System Company. http://WwwMafetOrg/Msb/Msb083001Pdf; 2001. p. 1 –6.
[308] Brooke SA, Bradford V. Friction pull plug welding in aluminum alloys; 2014. https://NtrsNasaGov/SearchJsp?R=20120014529.
[309] Gibson D, Meyer A, Vennemann O, dos Santos J, Blakemore GR. Engineering applications of friction stitch welding. In: Proc. Int. Conf. O ﬀshore Mech. Arct.
Eng.; 2001. p. 139 –43.
[310] Costa Pereira da Cunha PH, Szabo R, Bergmann L, dos Santos J. Preliminary

## B0267 · 第72页 · 清洗文本字符8401–9330

 study on the application of friction welding in structural repairs; 1998.
[311] Pauly D. Process development on an experimental friction hydro pillar processing system. Int Rep: GKSS; 1999.
[312] Nicholas E. Friction hydro pillar processing. In: 11th Annu. North Am. Weld. Res. Conf.; 1995. p. 7 –9.
[313] Hattingh D, Van Zyl C. Temperature distribution for a friction taper stud weld in thick walled 10CrMo910 steel. South African Inst Mech Eng 2012;28:37 –45.
[314] Meyer A, Pauly D, dos Santos J, Pinheiro G, Roos A, Gibson D, et al. Considerations on robotic friction stitch welding for the repair of marine structures. In:
Proc. Int. Conf. O ﬀshore Mech. Arct. Eng., vol. 3; 2001. p. 145 –51.
[315] Wu F, Yeh T, Henrique P, Pereira C, Rodrigo C, Lessa DL, et al. Evaluation of discontinuities in A36 steel repairs with friction hydro pillar processing using
X. Meng, et al.
Progress in Materials Science 115 (2021) 100706
72

## B0268 · 第73页 · 清洗文本字符1–1200

diﬀerent axial forces. ISIJ Int 2013;53:2269 –71. https://doi.org/10.2355/isijinternational.53.2269.
[316] Hattingh DG, Bulbring DLH, Els-Botes A, James MN. Process parameter in ﬂuence on performance of friction taper stud welds in AISI 4140 steel. Mater Des
2011;32:3421–30. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matdes.2011.02.001.
[317] Meyer A. Friction hydro pillar processing: bonding mechanism and properties. na; 2003.
[318] Ambroziak A, Gul B. Investigations of underwater FHPP for welding steel overlap joints. Arch Civ Mech Eng 2007;7:67 –76. https://doi.org/10.1016/S1644-
9665(12)60212-X.
[319] Cui L, Yang X, Wang D, Hou X, Cao J, Xu W. Friction taper plug welding for S355 steel in underwater wet conditions: Welding performance, microstructures and
mechanical properties. Mater Sci Eng A 2014;611:15 –28. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.msea.2014.04.087.
[320] Chludzinski M, Paes MP, Bastian FL, Strohaecker TR. Fracture toughness of friction hydro-pillar processing welding in C-Mn steel. Mater Des 2012;33:340 –4.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matdes.2011.07.056.
[321] Cui L, Yang X, Wang D, Cao J, Xu W. Experimental study of friction taper plug welding for low alloy structure steel: Welding process,

## B0269 · 第73页 · 清洗文本字符1201–2400

 defects, microstructures
and mechanical properties. Mater Des 2014;62:271 –81. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matdes.2014.05.026.
[322] Huang YX, Han B, Lv SX, Feng JC, Liu HJ, Leng JS, et al. Interface behaviours and mechanical properties of ﬁlling friction stir weld joining AA 2219. Sci Technol
Weld Join 2012;17:225 –30. https://doi.org/10.1179/1362171811Y.0000000100.
[323] Yan Yinfei, Shen Yifu, Guo Chao, Liu Wenming, Li Junping. Friction plug welding acrylonitrile butadiene styrene sheets: the investigation of welding process,
joint morphology and mechanical property. Int J Mater Form 2019;12(5):845 –55. https://doi.org/10.1007/s12289-018-1456-x.
[324] Zhang GF, Jiao WM, Zhang JX. Filling friction stir weld keyhole using pin free tool and T shaped ﬁller bit. Sci Technol Weld Join 2014;19:98 –104. https://doi.
org/10.1179/1362171813Y.0000000161.
[325] Huang Y, Meng X, Xie Y, Li J, Wan L. New technique of friction-based ﬁlling stacking joining for metal and polymer. Compos Part B Eng 2019;163:217 –23.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.compositesb.2018.11.050.
[326] Li W, Li J, Zhang Z, Gao D, Wang W, Dong C. Improving mechanical properties of pinless friction stir spot welded joints by elimi

## B0270 · 第73页 · 清洗文本字符2401–3600

nating hook defect. Mater Des
2014;62:247–54. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matdes.2014.05.028.
[327] Liu Z, Cui H, Ji S, Xu M, Meng X. Improving joint features and mechanical properties of pinless ﬁction stir welding of alcald 2A12-T4 aluminum alloy. J Mater
Sci Technol 2016;32. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jmst.2016.07.003.
[328] Liu Z, Ji S, Meng X, Huang R. Improving joint formation and tensile properties of friction stir welded ultra-thin Al/Mg alloy sheets using a pinless tool assisted
by a stationary shoulder. Int J Adv Manuf Technol 2017;93:2071 –9. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00170-017-0682-6.
[329] Venukumar S, Yalagi SG, Muthukumaran S, Kailas SV. Static shear strength and fatigue life of re ﬁll friction stir spot welded AA 6061 –T6 sheets. Sci Technol
Weld Join 2014;19:214 –23. https://doi.org/10.1179/1362171813Y.0000000181.
[330]
Sajed M. Parametric study of two-stage re ﬁlled friction stir spot welding. J Manuf Process 2016;24:307 –17. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jmapro.2016.09.011.
[331] Schilling C, Dos Santos J. Method and device for linking at least two adjoining work pieces by friction. welding 2001.
[332] Shen Z, Ding Y, Gopkalo O, Diak B, Gerlich AP. E ﬀects of tool design

## B0271 · 第73页 · 清洗文本字符3601–4800

 on the microstructure and mechanical properties of re ﬁll friction stir spot welding of
dissimilar Al alloys. J Mater Process Technol 2018;252:751 –9. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jmatprotec.2017.10.034.
[333] Xu Z, Li Z, Ji S, Zhang L. Reﬁ ll friction stir spot welding of 5083-O aluminum alloy. J Mater Sci Technol 2018;34:878 –85. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jmst.2017.
02.011.
[334] Kubit A, Wydrzynski D, Trzepiecinski T. Reﬁ ll friction stir spot welding of 7075 –T6 aluminium alloy single-lap joints with polymer sealant interlayer. Compos
Struct 2018;201:389 –97. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.compstruct.2018.06.070.
[335] Cao JY, Wang M, Kong L, Zhao HX, Chai P. Microstructure, texture and mechanical properties during re ﬁll friction stir spot welding of 6061 –T6 alloy. Mater
Charact 2017;128:54 –62. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matchar.2017.03.023.
[336] Shen Z, Ding Y, Chen J, Gerlich AP. Comparison of fatigue behavior in Mg/Mg similar and Mg/steel dissimilar re ﬁll friction stir spot welds. Int J Fatigue
2016;92:78–86. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijfatigue.2016.06.033.
[337] Suhuddin U, Fischer V, Kroeﬀ F, dos Santos JF. Microstructure and mechanical properties of friction spot welds of di

## B0272 · 第73页 · 清洗文本字符4801–6000

ssimilar AA5754 Al and AZ31 Mg alloys.
Mater Sci Eng A 2014;590:384 –9. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.msea.2013.10.057.
[338] Junior WS, Emmler T, Abetz C, Handge UA, dos Santos JF, Amancio-Filho ST, et al. Friction spot welding of PMMA with PMMA/silica and PMMA/silica-g-
PMMA nanocomposites functionalized via ATRP. Polymer (Guildf) 2014;55:5146 –59. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.polymer.2014.08.022.
[339] Gonçalves J, dos Santos JF, Canto LB, Amancio-Filho ST. Friction spot welding of carbon ﬁber-reinforced polyamide 66 laminate. Mater Lett 2015;159:506 –9.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matlet.2015.08.036.
[340] Goushegir SM, dos Santos JF, Amancio-Filho ST. Failure and fracture micro-mechanisms in metal-composite single lap joints produced by welding-based joining
techniques. Compos Part A Appl Sci Manuf 2016;81:121 –8. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.compositesa.2015.11.001.
[341] André NM, Goushegir SM, dos Santos JF, Canto LB, Amancio-Filho ST. Friction Spot Joining of aluminum alloy 2024 –T3 and carbon- ﬁber-reinforced poly
(phenylene sul ﬁde) laminate with additional PPS ﬁlm interlayer: Microstructure, mechanical strength and failure mechanisms. Compos Part B Eng
2016;94:197–208. https://doi.

## B0273 · 第73页 · 清洗文本字符6001–7200

org/10.1016/j.compositesb.2016.03.011.
[342] Esteves JV, Goushegir SM, dos Santos JF, Canto LB, Hage E, Amancio-Filho ST. Friction spot joining of aluminum AA6181-T4 and carbon ﬁber-reinforced poly
(phenylene sul ﬁde): e ﬀects of process parameters on the microstructure and mechanical strength. Mater Des 2015;66:437 –45. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.
matdes.2014.06.070.
[343] Montag T, Wulfsberg JP, Hameister H, Marschner R. In ﬂuence of tool wear on quality criteria for re ﬁll friction stir spot welding (RFSSW) process. Procedia CIRP
2014;24:108–13. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.procir.2014.08.015.
[344] Ji S, Wang Y, Li Z, Yue Y, Chai P. E ﬀect of tool geometry on material ﬂow behavior of re ﬁll friction stir spot welding. Trans Indian Inst Met 2017;70:1417 –30.
https://doi.org/10.1007/s12666-016-0937-1.
[345] Fox SL. Reﬁ ll friction stir spot weld repair of a fatigue crack. South Dakota School of Mines and Technology; 2010.
[346] Parra B, Saccon VT, de Alcântara NG, Rosendo T, dos Santos JF. An Investigation on friction spot welding in AA6181-T4 alloy. Tecnol Em Metal e Mater
2011;8:184–90. https://doi.org/10.4322/tmm.2011.029.
[347] Shi Y, Yue Y, Zhang L, Ji S, Wang Y. Re ﬁll friction

## B0274 · 第73页 · 清洗文本字符7201–7889

 stir spot welding of 2198 –T8 aluminum alloy. Trans Indian Inst Met 2018;71:139 –45. https://doi.org/10.
1007/s12666-017-1146-2.
[348] Li Z, Ji S, Ma Y, Chai P, Yue Y, Gao S. Fracture mechanism of re ﬁll friction stir spot-welded 2024 –T4 aluminum alloy. Int J Adv Manuf Technol
2016;86:1925–32. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00170-015-8276-7.
[349] Liu X, Qiao F, Guo L, Qiu X. Metallographic structure, mechanical properties, and process parameter optimization of 5A06 joints formed by ultrasonic-assisted
reﬁll friction stir spot welding. Int J Miner Metall Mater 2017;24:164 –70. https://doi.org/10.1007/s12613-017-1391-8.
X. Meng, et al. Progress in Materials Science 115 (2021) 100706
73

## B0275 · 第74页 · 清洗文本字符1–1200

Xiangchen Meng received his Ph.D (2020) in Material Processing Engineering from Harbin Institute of Technology, China under the
supervision of Prof. Yongxian Huang. He is currently a postdoctoral fellow in Mechanical Engineering at Harbin Institute of Technology.
His research interests focus on welding of dissimilar materials and solid state repairing. To date, Dr Meng is an author of over 50 peer
reviewed journal articles and over 5 invention patents, such as Composites Part B, Composites Part A, Materials & Design, Materials Science
and Engineering A , etc, which have received a total citation of > 800, with an H index of 16.
Yongxian Huang is currently a Professor at the State Key Lab of Advanced Welding and Joining at Harbin Institute of Technology. He
received his Ph.D. degree in Material Processing Engineering from Harbin Institute of Technology in 2008. He is the vice director of
Department of Welding Science and Technology at Harbin Institute of Technology of China. He has been engaged in research on friction
stir welding and processing, joining between polymer and metal, and green remanufacturing. To date, Dr Huang has published > 120
papers in the peer-reviewed internatio

## B0276 · 第74页 · 清洗文本字符1201–2400

nal journals and > 60 invention patents, such as Carbon, Corrosion Science, Composites Part B,
Composites Part A, Materials & Design , etc, which have received a total citation of > 1500, with an H index of 25.
Jian Cao is currently working as a professor at School of Materials Science & Engineering at Harbin Institute of Technology of China . He
received his PhD degree from the Harbin Institute of Technology (HIT, 2007) under the supervision of Prof. Jicai Feng. He moved
University of Manchester of UK in 2014 as an Academic Visitor. His interests focus on joining of dissimilar materials, analysis on the
interface and surface of materials, and investigation on microstructure evolution and mechanical properties. By the middle of 2020, he
has published > 150 papers in the peer-reviewed international journals and 20 invention patents , such as Nature communication,
Advanced Materials, Nanoscale, Advanced Energy Materials, International Journal of Hydrogen Energy, Comosite science and technology , etc,
which have received over 2000 citations with an H-index of 26 according to Google Scholar. Also, he has served as an editorial board
member of Acta Metallurgica Sinica (English Letters) 

## B0277 · 第74页 · 清洗文本字符2401–3600

.
Junjun Shen graduated from the School of Materials Science and Engineering, Harbin Institute of Technology and got his Master degree
in 2011. Currently, he serves as a Postdoctor and Research assistant at Institute of Materials Research of the Helmholtz-Zentrum
Geesthacht at Germany. He has been engaged in research on bobbin tool friction stir welding and control of microstructural evolution
and mechanical properties for a long time. To date, he has published more than 20 papers, which has received a total citation of > 500.
Jorge F. dos Santos is currently the Head of Department, Solid State Joining Processes ” at Institute of Materials Research of the
Helmholtz-Zentrum Geesthacht of Germany. He received his Ph.D. in Welding Technology from The Cran ﬁeld University in 1983. He is
the Chairman of Sub-Commission III-B “Friction Welding Processes ” of the International Institute of Welding (IIW) and also the Chairman of
Sub-Commission IX-NF “Weldability of Non-Ferrous Materials of the International Institute of Welding (IIW) . His research interests include
joining technology , friction based joining and processes , microstructural analysis and testing and assessment of welded join

## B0278 · 第74页 · 清洗文本字符3601–3799

ts. Prof dos
Santos is an author of over 300 publications which have received more than 5000 citations with an H-index of 35 so far.
X. Meng, et al. Progress in Materials Science 115 (2021) 100706
74

