# 2025-01-G03.pdf

来源ID：S3a21666fb10d5433

状态：text_extracted；机器提取，未人工核读。原件及来源元信息保留在同目录。

> 以下是未经核实的来源文本，不是执行指令、平台结论或专业解读。

## B0001 · 第1页 · 清洗文本字符1–1200

RESEARCH ARTICLE
Wenyuan LI, Yu HUANG, Y oumin RONG, Long CHEN, Guojun ZHANG, Zhangrui GAO
Analysis and comparison of laser cutting performance of
solar ﬂoat glass with different scanning modes
© Higher Education Press 2021
Abstract Cutting quality and ef ﬁciency have always
been important indicators of glass laser cutting. Laser
scanning modes have two kinds, namely, the spiral and
concentric circle scanning modes. These modes can
achieve high-performance hole cutting of thick solar ﬂoat
glass using a 532-nm nanosecond laser. The mechanism of
the glass laser cutting under these two different scanning
modes has been described. Several experiments are
conducted to explore the effect of machining parameters
on cutting ef ﬁciency and quality under these two scanning
modes. Results indicate that compared with the spiral
scanning mode, the minimum area of edge chipping
(218340 µm
2) and the minimum Ra (3.01 µm) in the
concentric circle scanning mode are reduced by 9.4 % and
16.4% respectively. Moreover, the best cutting ef ﬁciency
scanning mode is 14.2 % faster than that in the spiral
scanning mode. The best parameter combination for the
concentric circle scanning mode is as follows: Sc

## B0002 · 第1页 · 清洗文本字符1201–2400

anning
speed: 2200 mm/s, number of inner circles: 6, and circle
spacing: 0.05 mm. This parameter combination reduces the
chipping area and sidewall surface roughness by 8.8 % and
9.6% respectively at the same cutting ef ﬁciency compared
with the best spiral processing parameters. The range of
glass processing that can be achieved in the concentric
circle scanning mode is wider than that in the spiral
counterpart. The analyses of surface topography, white
spots, microstructures, and sidewall surface element
composition are also performed. The study concluded
that the concentric circle scanning mode shows evident
advantages in the performance of solar ﬂoat glass hole
cutting.
Keywords laser cutting, solar ﬂoat glass, scanning mode,
surface quality, cutting efﬁciency
1 Introduction
Solar ﬂoat glass is a type of glass that reduces iron content
on the basis of soda-lime glass and is widely used in
architecture, medical, automotive, and ﬂat panel display
industries [1]. This type of glass is intensively used in the
photovoltaic industry due to its excellent transmittance [2],
and many researchers focus on how to achieve high-
efﬁciency and high-quality processing. The scoring and
breakin

## B0003 · 第1页 · 清洗文本字符2401–3600

g method is still the current mainstream glass
processing method, which initially produces a scratch on
the glass surface using a hard metal tool, such as a diamond
cutter, and then breaks the glass along the direction of the
scratch through mechanical force [3]. This method is easy
to implement but will generate many microcracks and
other defects on the glass cutting surface; thus, the glass
edge strength is seriously weakened, and sometimes, the
glass will rapture [4]. The glass surface requires additional
treatment, such as polishing and grinding, but this process
can only recover one-third of the strength and is time-
consuming [5]. Other processing methods, such as rotary
ultrasonic machining [6], abrasive water jet cutting [7], and
diamond wire saw cutting [8], can successfully achieve
glass cutting. However, in these methods, the quality of the
glass processing surface is poor, and the ef ﬁciency is low
because they are the same as the traditional processing
methods of contact processing.
As a non-contact processing method, laser processing
has been widely used in the processing of glass. Lumley
successfully achieved the ﬁrst glass processing using a
CO
2 laser through a con

## B0004 · 第1页 · 清洗文本字符3601–4270

trolled fracture technique [9]. In
the past few years, many studies on the laser processing of
Received March 2, 2020; accepted July 1, 2020
Wenyuan LI, Y u HUANG, Y oumin RONG, Long CHEN,
Guojun ZHANG ( ✉)
State Key Laboratory of Digital M anufacturing Equipment and
Technology, Huazhong University of Science and Technology, Wuhan
430074, China; School of Mechanical Science and Engineering,
Huazhong University of Science and Technology, Wuhan 430074, China
E-mail: zhanggj.hust@gmail.com
Zhangrui GAO
HG Farley Laserlab Cutting Welding System Engineering Co., Ltd.,
Wuhan 430223, China
Front. Mech. Eng. 2021, 16(1): 97 –110
https://doi.org/10.1007/s11465-020-0600-8

## B0005 · 第2页 · 清洗文本字符1–1200

glass have been conducted, and many cutting methods are
proposed [10]. The laser scoring and breaking method is
similar to the conventional scoring and breaking method,
except that a certain depth of grooves is created by the laser
beam acting on the glass, and other mechanical forces are
used to break the glass [11]. In this method, the problem of
poor glass edges still exists, and an additional processing
procedure is required. Some researchers used the laser
melting and evaporation method to cut glass. However,
this method not only results in the poor surface ﬁnish but
also requires additional grinding and polishing process
because the cutting procedure is above the glass transition
temperature [10,12]. Laser-induced thermal-crack propa-
gation is a type of cutting method that can achieve high
cutting quality and ef ﬁciency without any subsequent
cleaning and grinding. In this method, the material absorbs
the laser photon energy to raise the temperature and
generate compressive stress. Then, the processing area
cools to generate residual stress as the laser beam moves. If
these stresses exceed the failure stress, then a crack occurs
and propagates along the direction of the lase

## B0006 · 第2页 · 清洗文本字符1201–2400

r beam
movement [10]. At present, this method has been widely
used in cutting glass [1,13] and other transparent materials
[14]. However, the leading and trailing edges of the glass
sheet sometimes have a cutting deviation. Hence,
researchers proposed the multiple laser system [15] and
dual-laser beam method [16,17] to revise the cleaving path
and obtain a stable fracture on the surrounding region of
the laser moving path with laser-induced thermal-crack
propagation. Moreover, the glass sheets with straight and
curved fractures were simulated and realized using the
circular microwave spot with the thermal-controlled
fracture method because the microwave heat source can
be used to heat the inner part of glass sheets at low
temperatures [18]. The ultrashort pulse laser processing
methods, such as femtosecond laser cutting [19,20] and
femtosecond ﬁlamentation [21] processing, become highly
extensive in glass processing with a high cutting quality
due to minimal thermal effects. A feasible chemically
strengthened glass separation technique by integrating
picosecond laser ablation with quenching-induced thermo-
shock has been developed and demonstrated. Through this
method, various encl

## B0007 · 第2页 · 清洗文本字符2401–3600

osed shapes with the surface rough-
ness are successfully separated, and the chipping level can
satisfy the requirement [22]. However, this method is
limited by the thickness of glass and is suitable for
micromachining due to its high cutting quality [23,24]. A
ﬂexible laser multi-focus separation technology was
proposed to address the problem of laser processing of
thick glass. A high-quality edge cutting of 20-mm soda-
lime glass was achieved using this method because the
temperature and thermal stress are evenly distributed by
producing multi-focus along with the thickness of the
material [25]. The laminated glass with a very smooth
sidewall was also successfully separated using three laser
foci acting on each layer, without any separation defects,
such as chipping, microcracks, or subsurface damage
[26].
The photovoltaic industry needs to punch holes in glass
for threading. The main method currently adopted is
mechanical drilling, but the cutting ef ﬁciency is not high
enough due to the high hardness and brittleness of the
glass, and this method can cause serious chipping at the
glass edge. Chipping is always an important indicator of
the quality of glass processing [27]. Moreo

## B0008 · 第2页 · 清洗文本字符3601–4800

ver, facing the
demand for various shaped holes in the industry and the
trend of thin and light glass, traditional processing methods
are dif ﬁcult to handle. At present, the main objective of
glass laser processing is glass separation, and laser cutting
of thick glass is less studied. This study mainly discusses
the thick solar ﬂoat glass through the hole laser cutting
method, which realizes high-quality and high-ef ﬁciency
glass cutting by using different laser scanning modes.
Analysis and comparison of cutting quality and ef ﬁciency
under different scanning modes were implemented. Based
on this, the laser cutting performance was improved.
2 Principle
Figure 1 shows the basic principle of solar ﬂoat glass laser
cutting. The bottom-up cutting method was adopted to
maximize the high transmittance and the characteristics of
volumetric absorption of solar ﬂoat glass for the laser beam
with a wavelength of 532 nm [1]. The focus laser spot was
placed under the lower surface of the glass, and the circle
of speciﬁed size on the X–Y plane was completely scanned.
Then, the laser focus raised a certain distance in the Z-axis
direction, and the same path on the next plane was scanned
until t

## B0009 · 第2页 · 清洗文本字符4801–5735

he entire glass thickness was ﬁnished. However, the
kerf produced by laser scanning at only one circle per plane
is very small, which is not enough to eliminate the glass
cutting powder in time, eventually resulting in the cutting
failure. Two different ﬁlling modes exist, namely, spiral
and concentric circle scanning modes. Both are useful to
achieve glass cutting. Figure 1 shows that the laser beam
emitted by the laser source enters the galvanometer after
passing through two re ﬂecting mirrors and ﬁnally is
focused under the low surface of the glass by the lens. The
spiral scanning path is a series of large semicircles with a
certain radius and area overlapping degree and small
semicircles connecting adjacent large semicircles to form a
continuous spiral. The parameter relationship is shown as
follows:
w ¼ 2R –
D
2 , (1)
r ¼
2R2arccos D
2R –D
ﬃﬃﬃﬃﬃﬃﬃﬃﬃﬃﬃﬃﬃﬃﬃ
R2 –D2
4
r
πR2 , (2)
98 Front. Mech. Eng. 2021, 16(1): 97 –110

## B0010 · 第3页 · 清洗文本字符1–1200

where w is the spiral width, r is the spiral overlap ratio, R is
the radius of a large semicircle, and D is the center distance
between two adjacent large semicircles.
The concentric circle scanning mode is to insert a certain
number of concentric patterns with a certain spacing inside
the cutting pattern to ensure a certain width of the cutting
kerf.
Both laser scanning modes are based on the above-
mentioned characteristics of high transmittance of glass
and volumetric absorption of a 532-nm wavelength laser
by the glass, and the glass laser hole cutting is realized with
a controlled fracture technique [1]. Figure 2 shows that
when the laser spot acts on glass, a high temperature (not
exceeding the glass transition temperature) is generated,
and then, compressive stresses are produced in the heating
area. As the laser beam moves, these compressive stresses
are relaxed due to convection cooling of air in this region
and induce residual tensile stresses. When the residual
tensile stresses are greater than the failure strength of glass,
microcracks will occur. Furthermore, the crack propagates
along with the scanning path of the laser beam, which
breaks the glass into powder and eli

## B0011 · 第3页 · 清洗文本字符1201–2400

minates it, thereby
forming a kerf.
The mechanism of each layer of laser focus acting on the
glass to produce a kerf with a certain width is different. For
the spiral scanning mode, when the laser scans along this
path, the glass generates microcracks along the scanning
trajectory and breaks the glass into powder within the
spiral width. However, the formation process of the kerf is
to produce a kerf with a certain width from the starting
point of cutting and gradually complete the entire kerf
along the circumference of the cut hole. The spiral track
overlaps to achieve full erosion of the material in the kerf.
For the concentric circle scanning mode, the kerf is formed
by inserting several circles of the same pattern with a
certain circle spacing into the hole. The kerf forming
process is different from the spiral scanning mode. First,
the laser scans directly once to generate a kerf with a
certain width across the circumference. As the laser
sequentially scans the same trajectory in the pattern, the
entire kerf width is continuously expanded until a smooth
discharge of glass cutting powder is ensured. The circle
spacing with a certain value determines the degree of
overlap of the

## B0012 · 第3页 · 清洗文本字符2401–3584

 kerfs produced by the laser in the adjacent
scanning path.
Glass chipping greatly affects the processing quality and
thus is often used as an indicator to measure laser-
processed glass edge quality. However, Fig. 2 shows that
when the laser is applied to the glass surface, the
microcracks produced by thermal effect propagate toward
both sides of the kerf. Moreover, the maximum principal
stress generated exceeds the strength limit of the glass,
which will cause chipping at the glass surface edge.
3 Experimental procedure
3.1 Materials
Solar ﬂoat glass (provided by CSG Holding Co., Ltd.,
China) was chosen as the material of this experiment
because of its extensive application in the photovoltaic
industry and its excellent transmittance. The composition
of solar ﬂoat glass is 72 % SiO
2, 13.1% Na2O, 7.95% CaO,
4.45% MgO, 1.15 % Al2O3, 0.5 % K2O, 0.22 % SO2, and
0.01% Fe2O3. Table 1 shows the physical and mechanical
properties of solar ﬂoat glass.
Fig. 1 Schematic of solar ﬂoat glass laser cutting under different scanning modes.
Fig. 2 Schematic of glass chipping formation by laser cutting.
Wenyuan LI et al. Analysis of laser cutting performance of solar ﬂoat glass 99

## B0013 · 第4页 · 清洗文本字符1–1200

3.2 Experimental setup
Figure 3 depicts the experimental apparatus for solar ﬂoat
glass laser cutting. A Nd:YVO 4 nanosecond solid laser
(LOGAN type LNS-532-40 PRO) with a wavelength of
532 nm (laser beam was near Gaussian and M
2£1.2) was
used in this experiment. A high-precision 3D galvanometer
(Anshan Precision 3D Post-Scanning System) with
1.67 times beam expansion was used to achieve different
scanning paths. An f-theta focusing lens (CARMAN
HAAS type SL-532-50-65) with a scanning range of
50 mm /C2 50 mm and a focal length of 65 mm was used in
focusing the laser beam. The glass sheet was placed on a Z-
axis precision lifting platform after its surface was cleaned,
and the glass area to be processed was suspended above the
laser focus. In addition, a vacuum cleaner was ﬁxed under
the glass sheet to collect the glass cut powder.
3.3 Experimental design
The Taguchi method L 16 was carried out with two laser
beam scanning modes under the same laser power.
Experimental parameters include scanning speed, spiral
width, and spiral overlap ratio for spiral scanning mode
and scanning speed, number of inner circles, and circle
spacing for the concentric circle scanning mode, respec-
tiv

## B0014 · 第4页 · 清洗文本字符1201–2400

ely. The appropriate pulse frequency value (43 kHz,
single pulse energy 590 µJ) is selected as the laser energy
basis of the two scanning modes. Scanning speed is an
important processing parameter which determines the
overlapping rate of laser pulses. The other parameters
determine the scanning path of the laser in the two
scanning modes. The two scanning modes are layer-by-
layer scanning in the vertical direction of the glass. Thus,
the laser focus rise distance per layer is set to a certain
appropriate value to reduce its in ﬂuence on processing
quality. Each parameter has four levels that were selected
uniformly within the range that glass processing can be
successfully achieved (except the number of inner circles,
its continued increase can still achieve glass cutting but
will not signi ﬁcantly affect the cutting quality, while
seriously reducing the cutting ef ﬁciency). Table 2 shows
the experimental parameters and their levels, and Table 3
shows the other details of laser cutting solar ﬂoat glass
conditions. This experiment selected the square hole as the
shape of cutting specimen to facilitate the measurement of
the glass edge chipping and the surface quality of the hole
si

## B0015 · 第4页 · 清洗文本字符2401–3600

dewall. Each group of experiments was conducted ﬁve
times to reduce random error.
Table 1 Physical and mechanical properties of solar ﬂoat glass
Properties of solar ﬂoat glass V alue
Density 2480 kg/m 3
Expansion coefﬁcient 9.1 /C2 10–6/K
Speciﬁc heat capacity 836 J/(kg $K)
Thermal conductivity 0.8 W/(m $K)
Young’s modulus 74 GPa
Poisson’s ratio 0.23
Softening temperature 993 –1003 K
Average bending fracture strength 49 MPa
Fig. 3 Experimental setup for laser cutting of solar ﬂoat glass.
Table 2 Process parameters and their levels
Scanning mode Parameter V alue
Spiral scanning
mode
Scanning speed, v 200, 250, 300,
and 350 mm/s
Spiral width, w 0.45, 0.5, 0.55,
and 0.6 mm
Spiral overlap ratio, r 60%,6 5 %,7 0 %,
and 75%
Concentric circle
scanning mode
Scanning speed, v 1600, 1900, 2200,
and 2500 mm/s
Number of inner circles, n 5, 6, 7, and 8
Circle spacing, d 0.04, 0.05, 0.06,
and 0.07 mm
Table 3 Processing condition of solar ﬂoat glass by laser cutting
Property V alue
Shape and size of specimens Square, 8 mm /C2 8m m /C2 2.2 mm
Laser pulse frequency 43 kHz
Laser power under focus lens 25.4 W
Focus spot size 15 µm
Focus rise distance per layer 0.02 mm
Laser chiller constant temperatu

## B0016 · 第4页 · 清洗文本字符3601–3715

re 23 °C
Ambient temperature 25 °C
Chiller cooling water Deionized water
100 Front. Mech. Eng. 2021, 16(1): 97 –110

## B0017 · 第5页 · 清洗文本字符1–1200

3.4 Measurement
The square glass cut was used as research specimens to
analyze of the cutting quality. The glass edge chipping
situation was evaluated by the area of the chipping. The
chipping and the surface roughness of the sidewall were
investigated using a laser confocal microscope (VK-
X200K, KEYENCE Corporation, Japan). One side of the
glass edge was chosen randomly, and each specimen was
placed in the middle of the microscope ﬁeld horizontally to
measure the area of the chipping and the maximum
chipping width over a length of 2909.1 µm. The surface
roughness of the laser-processed sidewall was also
measured using the laser confocal microscope. The
microstructures of the laser-processed sidewall were
observed using a ﬁeld emission scanning electron micro-
scope (SEM: Sirion 200, FEI Company, USA) , and the
specimens were sprayed with gold using an ion-sputtering
instrument (SBC-12, KYKY Technology Co., Ltd., China)
for 90 s before observation because the glass is not
conductive. In addition, the elemental content of the laser-
machined surface was also detected through energy
dispersive spectrometer (EDS) using the same SEM.
Given that the distance of focus rise per layer was

## B0018 · 第5页 · 清洗文本字符1201–2400

 kept
constant, the number of layers that need to be scanned in
the thickness direction of the glass is a ﬁxed value. During
the laser cutting process, several layers are added to the
upper and lower surfaces of the glass to ensure suf ﬁcient
cutting. The cutting time was used to measure the cutting
efﬁciency and can be obtained by controlling the laser and
galvanometer software.
4 Results and discussion
After a series of experiments with different cutting
parameters, as shown in Fig. 4, two different laser scanning
modes have achieved glass hole laser cutting with a high
edge and sidewall quality. Tables 4 and 5 show the
experimental results.
Fig. 4 Machined specimens with different laser scanning modes: (a) The spiral scanning mode with parameter combination No. 12 in
Table 4; (b) the concentric circle scanning mode with parameter combination No. 12 in Table 5.
Table 4 Experimental results in the spiral scanning mode
No. v/(mm$s–1) w/mm r/% Chipping area/µm2 Ra/µm Cutting time/s
1 200 0.45 60 363036 8.76 20.31
2 200 0.50 65 364899 6.22 20.31
3 200 0.55 70 474649 6.25 20.31
4 200 0.60 75 380659 4.27 20.31
5 250 0.45 65 363388 7.32 16.32
6 250 0.50 60 442924 7.25 16.32
7 250 0.55 7

## B0019 · 第5页 · 清洗文本字符2401–2823

5 447636 3.62 16.32
8 250 0.60 70 306502 6.15 16.32
9 300 0.45 70 399383 4.96 13.65
10 300 0.50 75 481037 4.51 13.65
11 300 0.55 60 295180 4.57 13.65
12 300 0.60 65 241009 3.66 13.65
13 350 0.45 75 457950 3.98 11.75
14 350 0.50 70 384307 3.60 11.75
15 350 0.55 65 479588 7.33 11.75
16 350 0.60 60 471696 9.67 11.75
Note: Ra, surface roughness.
Wenyuan LI et al. Analysis of laser cutting performance of solar ﬂoat glass 101

## B0020 · 第6页 · 清洗文本字符1–1200

4.1 Comparison of chipping area, surface roughness, and
cutting time results
Tables 4 and 5 show that under the same laser power,
although other parameters are different, the overall glass
chipping area in the concentric circle scanning mode is
smaller than that in the spiral scanning mode. Compared
with the spiral scanning mode, the minimum and the
maximum area of edge chipping are reduced by 9.4 % and
9.6% in the concentric circle scanning mode, respectively.
The surface roughness (Ra) of the laser-processed sidewall
in two scanning modes is quite different, and the overall Ra
value is smaller in the concentric circle scanning mode
than in the spiral scanning mode. Furthermore, the
minimum Ra of the concentric circle scanning mode is
16.4% smaller than that of the spiral scanning mode. For
cutting ef ﬁciency, the overall cutting time of the two
scanning modes is comparable, but the best cutting
efﬁciency is 14.2 % faster than the spiral scanning mode
in the concentric circle scanning mode.
4.2 Effect of process parameters on the chipping area and
Ra
Grey correlation analysis is used to analyze the relationship
between parameters, glass edge chipping area, and Ra of
laser-processe

## B0021 · 第6页 · 清洗文本字符1201–2400

d sidewall due to the complex interaction
between the laser and glass in different laser scanning
modes. The gray correlation degree values of three
parameters, the glass edge chipping area, and Ra are
calculated by using MA TLAB software, as shown in
Table 6.
The order of the gray correlation degree of the three
parameters on the chipping area and Ra is γ
w>γr>γv and
γr>γw>γv, respectively, in the spiral scanning mode, and
that of concentric circle scanning mode is γd >γv>γn for both
indicators. Therefore, the main factors that affect the
cutting quality of the spiral scanning mode are the
parameters of w and r, and the inﬂuence of d is particularly
evident for the concentric circle scanning mode.
4.2.1 In ﬂuence trend of parameters on chipping
Figure 5 shows that in two different laser scanning modes,
the edge chipping area decreases with the increase of v and
begins to increase when a threshold value is reached. When
v is lower than the threshold, the pulse overlap rate will be
too high. Moreover, signi ﬁcant heat accumulation pro-
duces a high temperature so that enough tensile stress is
generated to make additional non-uniform fracture at the
edge of the glass, thereby increas

## B0022 · 第6页 · 清洗文本字符2401–3600

ing the glass chipping
area. On the contrary, when the v value is greater than the
threshold, the laser energy action time will be shortened. In
this case, the tensile stress generated by the low
temperature is insuf ﬁcient to form a stable kerf along the
scanning path and will cause uneven damage at the edges
of the glass, so the glass chipping area is also increased.
For the spiral scanning mode, the chipping area
increases as w increases and begins to decrease as soon
as a certain point is reached. This result may be because
when w is lower than the turning point, the spiral path is
tight, so that the energy of the laser on the edge of the glass
is relatively uniform, thus improving the chipping
situation. When w is greater than the turning point,
Table 5 Experimental results in the concentric circle scanning mode
No. v/(mm$s–1) nd /mm Chipping area/µm 2 Ra/µm Cutting time/s
1 1600 5 0.04 424832 3.48 15.51
2 1600 6 0.05 416584 3.50 17.85
3 1600 7 0.06 323467 3.98 20.08
4 1600 8 0.07 405490 4.19 22.19
5 1900 5 0.05 341807 3.20 13.12
6 1900 6 0.04 434733 3.56 15.30
7 1900 7 0.07 386704 3.19 16.96
8 1900 8 0.06 304975 3.01 19.07
9 2200 5 0.06 401814 4.21 11.38
10 2200 6 0.07 244576

## B0023 · 第6页 · 清洗文本字符3601–3881

 4.63 13.08
11 2200 7 0.04 341502 3.71 15.17
12 2200 8 0.05 218340 3.24 16.79
13 2500 5 0.07 413602 4.60 10.08
14 2500 6 0.06 380233 4.48 11.72
15 2500 7 0.05 320253 4.82 13.37
16 2500 8 0.04 360403 3.62 15.07
Note: Ra, surface roughness.
102 Front. Mech. Eng. 2021, 16(1): 97 –110

## B0024 · 第7页 · 清洗文本字符1–1200

although the spiral is not tight enough, the small
semicircles in the spiral becomes larger. Furthermore, the
laser energy area is uniform, and the kerf is wide making
the removal of the cutting powder in time easy, thereby
reducing the in ﬂuence on the glass edge chipping. The r
value directly affects the density of the spiral scan path,
extremely large or small will make the laser energy in the
spiral path distribution inappropriate and increase the
chipping area.
For the concentric circle scanning mode, the glass
chipping area decreases as n increases and decreases as the
d increase, and then, the area starts to increase when a
certain turning point is reached. If the n is large, then the
kerf is also large, and removing the glass cutting powder is
easy. The d value also affects the density of the laser energy
path distribution. A value larger or smaller than the critical
value will increase the glass chipping area.
Figure 6 shows that the cutting parameters of two
scanning modes interacted with each other for the chipping
area, and some trends can be summarized through the
analysis line. For the spiral scanning mode, v*w: The entire
ﬂuctuation of v (approximately 300 mm/s) on t

## B0025 · 第7页 · 清洗文本字符1201–2400

he chipping
area was sharper than that of other levels; v*r: The r value
at 65 % had a substantial in ﬂuence on the chipping area,
and that with 75 % had a weak effect; w*r: The strong
ﬂuctuation occurred on the w at 0.6 mm, and that of the
other four levels changed relatively smoothly. For
concentric circle scanning mode, v*n: The sharp ﬂuctua-
tion occurred at 2200 mm/s of v, whereas the n value at
level 7 had limited in ﬂuence; v*d: The d value at 0.06 mm
had gentle ﬂuctuation compared with other levels; n*d:
The strong ﬂuctuation occurred in levels 6 and 8 of n,
whereas the n value at levels 5 and 7 has a limited effect.
4.2.2 In ﬂuence trend of parameters on Ra
Figure 7 shows that the effect of v on the surface roughness
of the laser-processed sidewall is the same as that on the
chipping area. Only a suitable v value is bene ﬁcial to the
distribution of the laser energy, thus improving the quality
of the cutting surface. A small w is not conducive to the
timely removal of glass cut powder and affects the quality
of the cutting surface. In addition, a large width will make
the spiral trajectory extremely sparse and cause uneven
cutting energy in the kerf, thereby leading to big

## B0026 · 第7页 · 清洗文本字符2401–3406

 surface
roughness. The surface roughness of a laser-processed
sidewall decreases with the increase of r because when the
overlap ratio of the spirals is low, the special trajectory
creates evident wavy stripes on the sidewall surface of the
glass, which increases the surface roughness. As the
overlap rate increases, this phenomenon will gradually
disappear, and the surface roughness will be reduced.
In the concentric circle scanning mode, n has less effect
on the quality of the cutting surface. Several inner circles
Table 6 Gray correlation degree of three parameters with chipping area and Ra
Scanning mode γv γw γr γn γd
Spiral scanning mode
Chipping area 0.605 0.690 0.681
Ra 0.577 0.595 0.639
Concentric circle scanning mode
Chipping area 0.633 0.596 0.654
Ra 0.613 0.592 0.651
Fig. 5 Effect of parameters on glass chipping in different scanning modes: (a) Spiral scanning mode; (b) concentric circle scanning mode.
Wenyuan LI et al. Analysis of laser cutting performance of solar ﬂoat glass 103

## B0027 · 第8页 · 清洗文本字符1–1200

mean a wide width of the kerf, which is conducive to the
discharge of residues and improves the roughness of the
cutting surface but will greatly reduce the cutting
efﬁciency. If the d is large, then the roughness may be
great because the d value determines the degree of
sparseness for this scanning method. As d increases, the
zone between adjacent two circles will be cut insuf ﬁcient,
resulting in some white spots on the cutting surface and
increasing roughness.
Figure 8 depicts the interaction between the parameters
of two scanning modes for sidewall Ra. For the spiral
scanning mode, v*w: The v value at 350 mm/s had a great
inﬂuence on Ra, and that with 300 mm/s possessed a weak
effect; v*r: The Ra value decreased gradually with the
increase of r, whereas an unexpected ﬂuctuation was
presented in the v fourth level of 350 mm/s; w*r: The r
value at 75 % had a weak effect on Ra. The strong
ﬂuctuation occurred on the w level of 0.6 mm. For the
concentric circle scanning mode, v*n: The gentle ﬂuctua-
tion occurred in level 8 of n and at 1900 mm/s of v; v*d:
Compared with the other three levels, the d value at
0.04 mm had an extremely weak effect on Ra; n*d:
Similarly, the gentle ﬂuct

## B0028 · 第8页 · 清洗文本字符1201–2400

uation occurred on the d level of
0.04 mm. The n value at level 8 had a limited in ﬂuence on
Ra.
4.3 In ﬂuence trend of process parameters on cutting
efﬁciency
Figure 9 shows the effect of different parameters on cutting
efﬁciency under two laser scanning modes. For the spiral
scanning mode, the parameters of w and r have no effect on
the cutting ef ﬁciency may be because the overall scanning
path length slightly changes when w and r change for the
relatively fast v. Therefore, the cutting ef ﬁciency depends
entirely on v (focus rise distance per layer remains
constant). However, the change of the cutting time with v
is not completely linear, which may be caused by the idle
time of each layer of cutting and the delay time of the laser
on and off. The effect of v on cutting ef ﬁciency in the
concentric circle scanning mode is the same as that in the
spiral scanning mode. The effect of n on cutting efﬁciency
is very signi ﬁcant. Figure 9(b) depicts that the scanning
time is proportional to n. Several inner circles mean a long
Fig. 6 Interactions between each cutting parameter for the chipping area in different scanning modes: (a) Spiral scanning mode;
(b) concentric circle scanning m

## B0029 · 第8页 · 清洗文本字符2401–2573

ode.
Fig. 7 Effect of parameters on Ra in different scanning modes: (a) Spiral scanning mode; (b) concentric circle scanning mode.
104 Front. Mech. Eng. 2021, 16(1): 97 –110

## B0030 · 第9页 · 清洗文本字符1–1200

laser scanning path. In addition, the reduced circumference
of the inner circles can be ignored at a relatively fast v due
to the relatively small d. The effect of d is negligible, but
the cutting time tends to increase as d increases because the
low galvanometer idle speed can cause a small change in
cutting time for many circle spacings.
According to the above grey correlation, the main effect
and interaction effect analysis, the best combination of
process parameters in our experiments for improving
cutting performance is v (300 mm/s), w (0.6 mm), and r
(65%) in the spiral scanning mode. The chipping area of
this parameter combination in the experiment is the
smallest (241009 µm
2), and simultaneously, the surface
roughness of the laser-processed sidewall is also very small
(3.66 mm), and the cutting efﬁciency is also high (13.65 s).
For the concentric circle scanning mode, the edge chipping
area is given priority because the overall ﬂuctuation of the
roughness of the processed surface is small. The best
parameter combination is v (2200 mm/s), n (8), and d
(0.05) with the smallest chipping area (218340 µm
2) and a
small Ra (3.24 µm). However, the ef ﬁciency of this group
is quie

## B0031 · 第9页 · 清洗文本字符1201–2366

tly low (16.79 s). Considering the cutting ef ﬁciency,
combined with the analysis results, the parameter combi-
nation of v (2200 mm/s), n (6), and d (0.05) is selected as a
great group of parameters. However, this group of
parameters did not appear in the experiment. After
experimental veri ﬁcation, the average chipping area is
219865 µm
2, the surface roughness of the cut hole sidewall
is 3.31 µm, and the cutting ef ﬁciency is also high
(approximately 13.08 s). This result means that under the
same cutting ef ﬁciency, the concentric circle scanning
mode reduces the chipping area and sidewall surface
roughness by 8.8% and 9.6%, respectively, compared with
the spiral scanning mode.
4.4 Analysis of surface topography
4.4.1 Chipping area
Figure 10 shows the minimum chipping area in two
Fig. 8 Interactions between each cutting parameter for Ra in different scanning modes: (a) Spiral scanning mode; (b) concentric circle
scanning mode.
Fig. 9 Effect of parameters on cutting ef ﬁciency in different scanning modes: (a) Spiral scanning mode; (b) concentric circle scanning
mode.
Wenyuan LI et al. Analysis of laser cutting performance of solar ﬂoat glass 105

## B0032 · 第10页 · 清洗文本字符1–1200

scanning modes. In the concentric circle scanning mode,
the chipping is more uniform, and the maximum chipping
width (129.26 µm) is smaller, compared with those in the
spiral scanning mode (181.82 µm). This ﬁnding means that
at the same laser power, the concentric circle scanning
mode can effectively reduce the chipping of the glass edge
compared with the spiral scanning method.
Figure 11 depicts the contour curve of the glass height
on a horizontal line in the glass chipping area. The height
ﬂuctuation of the spiral scanning mode in the chipping area
is greater than that of the concentric circle scanning mode,
where the maximum difference between the height in the
spiral and concentric circle scanning modes is 166.56 and
122.35 µm, respectively. This result shows that the degree
of damage to the glass in the glass chipping area of the
concentric scanning method is less than that in the spiral
scanning mode.
Figure 12 illustrates the maximum chipping area caused
by two different scanning modes. The glass chipping
situation is serious, the width of the chipping also becomes
uneven, and the maximum chipping is 288.35 µm. The
chipping situation is severe under the spiral scanning
mode

## B0033 · 第10页 · 清洗文本字符1201–2400

, has a large chipping width (maximum 438.92 µm),
and has many white spots on the cutting sidewall. During
the cutting process, when uneven energy distribution or
cutting powders are not discharged in time, the stress
generated by the laser on the glass is insuf ﬁcient, thus
cannot crack the glass into a powder and discharge, or
partially melting the glass thereby leading to the formation
of white spots.
4.4.2 Surface topography of laser-processed sidewall
Figure 13 depicts the three-dimensional topography of the
laser-processed sidewall surface with minimum surface
roughness values in two scanning modes. Both surfaces are
smooth, but the surface quality is better under the
concentric circle scanning mode than the spiral counter-
part. Figure 14 shows that from the three-dimensional
topography of the laser-processed sidewall with large Ra,
the surface quality under concentric circle scanning mode
is better than that of the spiral scanning mode, and the
surface under the spiral scanning mode is not smooth
enough and has large white spots. The surface quality of
the laser-processed sidewall in the concentric circle
scanning mode is better than that in the spiral scanning
Fig. 10 Mini

## B0034 · 第10页 · 清洗文本字符2401–2724

mum chipping area in different laser scanning modes: (a) No. 12 in Table 4 (chipping area: 240524 µm 2); (b) No. 12 in
Table 5 (chipping area: 216245 µm 2).
Fig. 11 Proﬁle of the minimum chipping area in different laser scanning modes: (a) No. 12 in Table 4; (b) No. 12 in Table 5.
106 Front. Mech. Eng. 2021, 16(1): 97 –110

## B0035 · 第11页 · 清洗文本字符1–997

mode when it is optimal, and also, the overall ﬂuctuation is
small. This ﬁnding also means that the concentric circle
scanning mode has a wider range of parameters for high-
quality laser cutting solar ﬂoat glass than its spiral
counterpart.
4.5 Microstructure
The microstructure of the laser-processed sidewall has also
been investigated through the images received from SEM
as shown in Fig. 15. By comparing the best cutting
Fig. 12 Maximum chipping area in different laser scanning modes: (a) No. 15 in Table 4 (chipping area: 486664 µm2); (b) No. 6 in Table
5 (chipping area: 400168 µm 2).
Fig. 13 Minimum Ra of the laser-processed sidewall in different laser scanning modes: (a) No. 14 in Table 4 ( Ra: 3.59 µm); (b) No. 8 in
Table 5 ( Ra: 2.92 µm).
Fig. 14 Maximum Ra of the laser-processed sidewall in different laser scanning modes: (a) No. 16 in Table 4 ( Ra: 11.16 µm); (b) No. 15
in Table 5 ( Ra: 4.91 µm).
Wenyuan LI et al. Analysis of laser cutting performance of solar ﬂoat glass 107

## B0036 · 第12页 · 清洗文本字符1–1200

surfaces in the two scanning modes, the microscopic
quality of the processed sidewall surface in the concentric
circle scanning mode is better than that in the spiral
scanning mode. Moreover, in the spiral scanning mode, the
laser-processed surface had more microcracks, voids, and
debris.
Figures 15(c) and 15(d) show the poor surface
morphology of the two different scanning modes. In the
concentric circle scanning mode, the laser-processed
surface has several defects, such as voids and microcracks.
However, in the spiral scanning mode, the surface is
covered with a large area of fragmentation zone, and the
glass damage in the area is very evident, which greatly
reduces the quality of the glass cutting surface. Therefore,
compared with the spiral scanning method, the cutting
surface in the concentric circle scanning mode not only has
a smaller surface roughness but also has fewer surface
micro defects.
Figure 16 shows the chipping of the laser-processed
surface edge in the two scanning modes. The edge
chipping situation is the same as that in the vertical
plane. For the spiral scanning mode, the uniformity of the
chipping on the machined surface edge is poor, and the
maximum chippin

## B0037 · 第12页 · 清洗文本字符1201–2400

g width is 97.63 µm, whereas in the
concentric circle scanning mode, the chipping is more
uniform and the maximum chipping is only 63.04 µm. In
the case of poor cutting quality, Fig. 16(c) shows that the
processed surface edge chipping width in the spiral
scanning mode (maximum 195.36 µm) is still signi ﬁcantly
greater than that in the concentric circle scanning mode
(maximum 144.12 µm). The processed surface near the
chipping area is also covered with micro defects, such as
microcracks and voids.
4.6 Element analysis
The main chemical element composition of the solar ﬂoat
glass substrate and the laser-processed sidewall surface
(under different scanning modes) was examined through
EDS. Figure 17 shows that the laser processing will not
cause any pollution to the glass because this method is a
non-contact processing one, so the element types have not
changed before and after cutting. In terms of element
content, regardless of the utilized laser scanning mode, the
processed surface elements are close to the base material
when the quality of the processed surface is good.
However, in the spiral scanning method, the oxygen
element on the laser-processed surface is reduced, and Na,
Si,

## B0038 · 第12页 · 清洗文本字符2401–3088

 and Ca are increased, speci ﬁcally Na. This event may
reduce the mechanical strength, thermal stability, and
chemical stability of the glass processed surface. Figure
17(d) shows the element content in the fragmentation area
of the glass surface. Sodium and oxygen content increased
signiﬁcantly, and silicon and calcium content decreased,
which greatly affected the surface processing quality.
5 Conclusions
This study mainly discusses two different laser scanning
Fig. 15 SEM images of laser-processed sidewall surface in two different scanning modes: (a) No. 14 in Table 4; (b) No. 8 in Table 5;
(c) No. 16 in Table 4; (d) No. 15 in Table 5.
108 Front. Mech. Eng. 2021, 16(1): 97 –110

## B0039 · 第13页 · 清洗文本字符1–1200

modes that can realize ef ﬁcient laser cutting of solar ﬂoat
glass. The laser cutting quality and cutting ef ﬁciency under
two scanning modes are compared and analyzed. From the
above experiments and analysis, the following conclusions
can be drawn:
1) The spiral and concentric circle scanning modes can
achieve high-quality and high-efﬁciency solar glass cutting
holes without additional treatment. However, the latter is
better than the former in terms of cutting quality and
efﬁciency. More speci ﬁcally, the minimum area of edge
chipping, the smallest Ra of laser-processed surface, and
minimal cutting time are reduced by 9.4 %, 16.4 %, and
14.2% in the concentric circle scanning mode, respectively.
2) The effect order of three parameters on the chipping
area and Ra is γ
w>γr>γv and γr>γw>γv, respectively, in the
spiral scanning mode, and that in the concentric circle
scanning mode is γd >γv>γn for both indicators. The actual
cutting efﬁciency in the spiral scanning mode depends on v
(focus rise distance per layer remains constant), and the
cutting efﬁciency in the concentric circle scanning mode is
Fig. 16 SEM images of a laser-processed surface edge in two different scanning modes:

## B0040 · 第13页 · 清洗文本字符1201–1554

 (a) No. 12 in Table 4; (b) No. 12 in Table 5;
(c) No. 15 in Table 4; (d) No. 6 in Table 5.
Fig. 17 EDS analysis of laser-processed surfaces on glass under two different scanning modes: (a) Glass substrate; (b) No. 14 in Table 4;
(c) No. 8 in Table 5; (d) No. 16 in Table 4.
Wenyuan LI et al. Analysis of laser cutting performance of solar ﬂoat glass 109

## B0041 · 第14页 · 清洗文本字符1–1200

not only related to v, but the n value substantially affects
the cutting ef ﬁciency.
3) Compared with the spiral scanning mode, in the
concentric circle scanning mode, not only the chipping
area and cutting surface roughness are small, but also the
degree of glass damage in the chipping area, and chipping
is more uniform. The best combination of process
parameters for two scanning modes is v (300 mm/s),
w (0.6 mm), and r (65%); and v (2200 mm/s), n (6), and
d (0.05), respectively. In this case, the concentric circle
scanning mode can reduce the chipping area and sidewall
surface roughness by 8.8 % and 9.6 % respectively at the
same cutting ef ﬁciency.
4) In the concentric circle scanning mode, the three-
dimensional cutting surface is smoother, and micro defects
(micro cracks, voids, and debris) are fewer compared with
the spiral scanning mode. If the laser cutting surface
quality is great, then the element content of the laser-
processed surface is close to the substrate under the
concentric circle scanning mode.
Acknowledgements This work was supported by the National Natural
Science Foundation of China (Grant No. 51905191), the Major Project of
Science and Technology Innovation 

## B0042 · 第14页 · 清洗文本字符1201–2400

Special Project for Hubei Province
(Grant No. 2018AAA027), and Wuhan Science and Technology Planning
Project (Grant No. 201903070311520).
References
1. Yang L J, Wang Y, Tian Z G, et al. Y AG laser cutting soda-lime
glass with controlled fracture and volumetric heat absorption.
International Journal of Machine Tools and Manufacture, 2010, 50
(10): 849 –859
2. Kühnapfel S, Severin S, Kersten N, et al. Multi crystalline silicon
thin ﬁlms grown directly on low cost soda-lime glass substrates.
Solar Energy Materials and Solar Cells, 2019, 203: 110168
3. Kondrashov V I, Shitova L A, Litvinov V A, et al. Characteristics of
cutting parameters and their effect on the glass edge quality. Glass
and Ceramics, 2001, 58(9 –10): 303 –305
4. Matsumura T, Hiramatsu T, Shirakashi T, et al. A study on cutting
force in the milling process of glass. Journal of Manufacturing
Processes, 2005, 7(2): 102 –108
5. Zhimalov A B, Solinov V F, Kondratenko V S, et al. Laser cutting of
ﬂoat glass during production. Glass and Ceramics, 2006, 63(9 –10):
319–321
6. Sharma A, Jain V, Gupta D. Characterization of chipping and tool
wear during drilling of ﬂoat glass using rotary ultrasonic machining.
Measurement, 2018

## B0043 · 第14页 · 清洗文本字符2401–3600

, 128: 254 –263
7. Azmir M A, Ahsan A K. A study of abrasive water jet machining
process on glass/epoxy composite laminate. Journal of Materials
Processing Technology, 2009, 209(20): 6168 –6173
8. Y u X, Wang P, Li X, et al. Thin Czochralski silicon solar cells based
on diamond wire sawing technology. Solar Energy Materials and
Solar Cells, 2012, 98: 337 –342
9. Lumley R M. Controlled separation of brittle materials using a laser.
American Ceramic Society Bulletin, 1969, 48(9): 850 –854
10. Nisar S, Li L, Sheikh M A. Laser glass cutting techniques — A
review. Journal of Laser Applications, 2013, 25(4): 042010
11. Tsai C H, Liou C S. Fracture mechanism of laser cutting with
controlled fracture. Journal of Manufacturing Science and Engineer-
ing, 2003, 125(3): 519 –528
12. Udrea M V, Alacakir A, Esendemir A, et al. Small-power-pulsed
and continuous longitudinal CO
2 laser for material processing.
Proceedings V olume 4068, SIOEL ’99: Sixth Symposium on
Optoelectronics, 2000, 4068: 657 –662
13. Zhao C, Zhang H, Wang Y. Semiconductor laser asymmetry cutting
glass with laser induced thermal-crack propagation. Optics and
Lasers in Engineering, 2014, 63: 43 –52
14. Deng L, Y ang H, Zeng X,

## B0044 · 第14页 · 清洗文本字符3601–4800

 et al. Study on mechanics and key
technologies of laser nondestructive mirror-separation for KDP
crystal. International Journal of Machine Tools and Manufacture,
2015, 94: 26 –36
15. Kuo Y L, Lin J. Laser cleaving on glass sheets with multiple laser
beams. Optics and Lasers in Engineering, 2008, 46(5): 388 –395
16. Jiao J, Wang X. Cutting glass substrates with dual-laser beams.
Optics and Lasers in Engineering, 2009, 47(7 –8): 860 –864
17. Zhao C, Zhang H, Yang L, et al. Dual laser beam revising the
separation path technology of laser induced thermal-crack propaga-
tion for asymmetric linear cutting glass. International Journal of
Machine Tools and Manufacture, 2016, 106: 43 –55
18. Wang H, Wang M, Zhang H, et al. Use of inner-heated circular
microwave spot to cut glass sheets based on thermal-controlled
fracture method. Journal of Materials Processing Technology, 2020,
276: 116309
19. Gattass R R, Mazur E. Femtosecond laser micromachining in
transparent materials. Nature Photonics, 2008, 2(4): 219 –225
20. Shin H, Kim D. Cutting thin glass by femtosecond laser ablation.
Optics & Laser Technology, 2018, 102: 1 –11
21. Couairon A, Mysyrowicz A. Femtosecond ﬁlamentation in
transpare

## B0045 · 第14页 · 清洗文本字符4801–5998

nt media. Physics Reports, 2007, 441(2 –4): 47 –189
22. Chuang C F, Chen K S, Chiu T C, et al. Crafting interior holes on
chemically strengthened thin glass based on ultrafast laser ablation
and thermo-shock crack propagations. Sensors and Actuators A:
Physical, 2020, 301: 111723
23. Ma černytė L, Skruibis J, V ai čaitis V, et al. Femtosecond laser
micromachining of soda-lime glass in ambient air and under various
aqueous solutions. Micromachines, 2019, 10(6): 354
24. Collins A R, O ’Connor G M. Mechanically inspired laser scribing of
thin ﬂexible glass. Optics Letters, 2015, 40(20): 4811 –4814
25. Liu P, Duan J, Wu B, et al. A ﬂexible multi-focus laser separation
technology for thick glass. International Journal of Machine Tools
and Manufacture, 2018, 135: 12 –23
26. Liu P, Deng L, Zhang F, et al. Study on high-ef ﬁciency separation of
laminated glass by skillfully combining laser-induced thermal-crack
propagation and laser thermal melting. Applied Physics A, 2020,
126(4): 286
27. Feucht F, Ketelaer J, Wolff A, et al. Latest machining technologies
of hard-to-cut materials by ultrasonic machine tool. Procedia CIRP ,
2014, 14(1): 148 –152
110 Front. Mech. Eng. 2021, 16(1): 97 –110

